Table 3.
Potential reasons for treatment failure for WHO-defined pneumonia at 72 h and possible solutions
Frequency* | Possible solution† | |
---|---|---|
Wrong diagnosis | ||
Reactive airways/asthma | Common | Physician referral |
Malaria | Geographically focused | Hospital for blood smear |
Foreign body | Rare | Hospital assessment |
Anaemia | Rare | Hospital assessment |
Cardiac disease | Rare | Hospital assessment |
Others | Rare | Hospital assessment |
Host failure | ||
HIV/AIDS | Geographically focused | Hospital for HIV test |
Malnutrition | Geographically focused | Hospital for intensive treatment |
Pulmonary maldevelopment | Rare | Hospital assessment |
Others | Rare | Hospital assessment |
Complication | ||
Empyema | Uncommon | Hospital for drainage |
Abscess | Rare | Hospital for radiography |
Others | Rare | Hospital assessment |
Non-susceptible pathogen | ||
Viral infection (respiratory syncytial virus, influenza, others) | Common | Observation or hospital |
Tuberculosis | Geographically focused | Four drugs and hospital assessment |
Mycoplasma, Chlamydophila | Uncommon | Appropriate antibiotics (eg, macrolide, doxycycline, or fluroquinolone) |
Non-susceptible S pneumoniae | Uncommon | Appropriate antibiotics (eg, high-dose amoxicillin, ceftriaxone) |
Beta-lactamase-producing Haemophlus influenzae | Uncommon | Appropriate antibiotics (eg, amoxicillin–clavulanic acid, ceftriaxone) |
Non-typhoidal salmonellae | Geographically focused | Appropriate antibiotics in hospital |
Staphylococcus aureus | Rare | Appropriate antibiotics in hospital |
Strongyloides, other parasites | Rare | Ivermectin etc, in or out of hospital |
Endemic fungi | Rare | Hospital assessment and anti-fungal therapy |
Others | Rare | Hospital assessment |
Common agents may be responsible for at least a third of outpatient pneumonia treatment failures; uncommon agents may be responsible for a minor fraction; rare agents are probably responsible for only occasional treatment failures; globally uncommon agents may be common in certain geographic areas, although they are uncommon as causes for pneumonia treatment failure globally. Based on data from Heffelfinger et al71 and discussions of the panel based on their clinical experience.
Note that referral to the next level facility instead of a hospital may occasionally be appropriate, depending on the resources at the facility and the suspected condition.