Skip to main content
. 2011 Oct 5;2011(10):CD003439. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD003439.pub2
Study Reason for exclusion
Aitken 1985 Not a longitudinal study. Qualitative study of children's perceptions of advertisements.
Aitken 1987 Not a longitudinal study. Focuses on recognition of advertisements and brand preferences.
Aitken 1991 Future intention to smoke measured at follow‐up. Data not given separately for current and nonsmokers.
Aloise‐Young 2006 Not a longitudinal study. No primary outcome data on youth smoking behaviour.
Altman 1996 Not a longitudinal study.
Arnett 1998 Not a longitudinal study. Investigated correlation between preferred and most advertised brands.
Arora 2008 Not a longitudinal study.
Audrain McGovern 2003 Not a longitudinal study. Corss‐sectional design aimed to identify adolescents' most receptive to tobacco advertising based on differences in novelty‐seeking personality and other variables.
Audrain‐McGovern 2004 Longitudinal study using same data source as Audrain‐McGovern 2006. Focus was on characterizing adolescent smoking trajectories based on a variety of covariates including tobacco advertising receptivity.
Barbeau 1998 Not a longitudinal study. Assessed the appeal of advertisement for adolescents.
Beguinot 2010 Not a longitudinal study. Examined the relationship between exposure to sports sponsorship of tobacco products and recall of cigarette brands. Sample was aged 12 to 24.
Beltramini 2001 Longitudinal study. Measures changes in students' understanding of the role of advertising when exposed to an educational curriculum.
Borzekowski 1999 Not a longitudinal study. Correlates perceived influence of advertisements and smoking susceptibility.
Botvin 1991 Not a longitudinal study.
Botvin 1993 Not a longitudinal study.
Braverman 2004 Not a prospective cohort study. Used two sperate samples from two different years, but from the same city.
Brown 2009 Time series study, before, during, and after the UK's ban on tobacco advertising and promotion.
Burton 2010 Not a longitudinal study. Outcome was intention to smoke. No measure of smoking behaviour.
Butt 2009 Not a longitudinal study.
Carson 2005 Not a longitudinal study.
Carter 2007 Experimental study on the influence of smoking imagery in magazines. Outcome was smoking intention.
Chapman 1982 Not a longitudinal study.
Charlton 1986 Not a longitudinal study.
Chen 2002 Not a longitudinal study.
Chetwynd 1988 Effect of advertising cannot be separated for young people.
Choi 2002 Longitudinal study using same data sources as Pierce 1998, analyses progress of smoking uptake by subset who were already experimenting at baseline. Results given briefly with Pierce 1998.
Delener 1995 Review
DiFranza 1991 Not a longitudinal study.
DiFranza 1994 Not a longitudinal study.
Dirocco 2007 Not a longitudinal study. No measure of smoking behaviour. Outcome was intention to smoke after viewing cigarette advertisements.
Emri 1998 Not a longitudinal study.
Evans 1995 Not a longitudinal study. Assessed susceptibility to smoking and receptivity to advertising.
Feighery 1998 Not a longitudinal study.
Feighery 2006 Not a longitudinal study.
Freeman 2009 Not a longitudinal study. Examined relationship between understanding of cigarette advertisements and susceptibility to smoking. No measure of smoking behaviour.
Galduroz 2007 Time series study, before and after a ban on cigarette advertising in Brazil.
Gilpin 1997 Not a longitudinal cohort study. Correlated cross‐sectional data in initiation rates with cigarette prices and marketing activity 1979‐89.
Gilpin 2004 Time series study, before and after the master settlement agreement in the USA.
Gittelsohn 1999 Not a longitudinal study.
Goldberg 2003 Not a longitudinal study.
Goldstein 1987 Not a longitudinal study.
Grandpre 2003 Not a longitudinal study. Primary outcome was smoking intention.
Green 2002 Opinion piece, not an original research study.
Hanewinkel 2010 Not a longitudinal study.
Hastings 1994 Not a longitudinal study.
Hawkins 2000 Not a longitudinal study.
Henk 1995 Not a longitudinal study.
Henriksen 2008 Not a longitudinal study.
Ho 1994 Not a longitudinal study.
Jason 2004 No primary outcome data on youth smoking behaviour.
Kaufman 2002 Not a longitudinal study.
Kaufman 2004 Not a longitudinal study. Used 3 national cross‐sectional surveys to understand changes in adolescent cigarette brand choices.
Kelly 2002 Not a longitudinal study. No primary outcome data on youth smoking behaviour.
Klitzner 1991 Not a longitudinal study.
Krugman 2005 Not a longitudinal study. No primary outcome data on youth smoking behaviour.
Lam 1998 Not a longitudinal study.
Lancaster 2003 No primary outcome data on youth smoking behaviour.
Lewit 1981 Not a longitudinal study. Used survey data to correlate teenage smoking status and hours of television watched.
Lewit 1997 Not a longitudinal cohort study. Cross‐sectional surveys correlating smoking status with tobacco‐related variables.
Lovato 2007 Not a longitudinal study.
Manfredi 2002 Descriptive article.
Mashita 2011 Not a longitudinal study.
Maziak 2003 Not a prospective cohort study. Used two separate samples from two different years, but from the same city.
Meier 1991 Not a longitudinal study.
Minh 2010 Not a longitudinal study.
Moodie 2008 Time series study, before and after the UK's ban on tobacco advertising and promotion.
Peters 2006 Not a longitudinal study.
Pierce 1991 Not a longitudinal cohort study. Correlates advertising of brands to smoking behaviour from two cross‐sectional surveys.
Pierce 1994 Not a longitudinal cohort study. Correlated trends in initiation rates and targeted advertising, based on cross‐sectional surveys.
Pierce 1995 Not a longitudinal cohort study. Correlated trends in initiation rates and targeted advertising, based on cross‐sectional surveys.
Pierce 1996 Longitudinal study (Teenage Attitudes and Practices Survey). No assessment of tobacco advertising exposure or attitudes.
Pierce 1999 Estimates the number of experimenters attributable to promotion of specific brands and the consequent future mortality.
Pierce 2002 Associations between tobacco advertising and youth smoking initiation is reported by parenting style only. Data used in this analysis is also used in Gilpin 2007, included in this review.
Pierce 2005 Main outcome measure was curiosity about smoking, not smoking status.
Pollay 1996 Econometric model using survey data correlating brand share for adults and youth with marketing spend.
Redmond 1999 Not a longitudinal cohort study. Cigarette marketing expenditure correlated to smoking rates from national survey 1978‐1995
Rimpela 1993 Not a longitudinal study. Review.
Ritchie 1988 Not a longitudinal study.
Santana 2003 Not a longitudinal study.
Shadel 2004 Not a longitudinal study. Investigated the role of self‐conflict on response to cigarette advertising. Did not measure smoking behavior.
Shadel 2008 Not a longitudinal study. Examined intention to smoke after exposure to cigarette advertisements. No measure of smoking behaviour.
Shadel 2009 Examined level of self‐conflict and intention to smoke after exposure to cigarette advertisements. No measure of smoking behaviour.
Slater 2007 Not a longitudinal study. Time series study using multiple, nationally representative, cross‐sectional studies that were part of the Monitoring the Future (MTF) Survey. Smoking uptake was estimated from measures of current smoking status and future smoking intentions.
Smith 1999 Not a longitudinal study.
Straub 2003 Not a longitudinal study.
Tercyak 2002 Does not report longitudinal data yet.
Turco 1997 Not a longitudinal study.
Unger 1995 Not a longitudinal study.
Unger 1999 Not a longitudinal study.
Villanti 2011 Not a longitudinal study.
Voorhees 2011 Not a longitudinal study.
Wakefield 2002 Not a longitudinal study. Outcome measure was usual brand choices.
Wen 2005 Econometric study.
Wills 2010 Not a longitudinal study. Examined the effect of self‐control as a moderator for adolescent alcohol and tobacco use.
Zulu 2009 Not a longitudinal study.