Sarr 2003.
Methods | Randomised clinical trial (parallel design) | |
Participants | Country: USA
Sample size: 381
Post‐randomisation drop‐out: 106
Revised sample size: 275
Females: 95 (34.5%)
Mean age: 62 years
Malignancy: 138 (50.2%)
Chronic pancreatitis: 0 (0%)
Pancreatoduodenectomy: 108 (39.3%)
Follow‐up: 30 days Inclusion criteria: 1. People undergoing an elective, anatomic, proximal or central pancreatectomy with a pancreaticoenteric anastomosis or a distal pancreatectomy with or without a pancreaticoenteric anastomosis 2. At least 18 years of age 3. An elective pancreatic resection because of a presumed pancreatic or periampullary neoplasm Exclusion criteria: 1. Chronic pancreatitis 2. Emergency surgery 3. Total pancreatectomy 4. Duct‐drainage procedures alone without any pancreatic resection 5. Enucleation of neoplasm 6. Enteric drainage of a pancreatic pseudocyst 7. Serum creatinine of twice the local upper limit of normal 8. Serum bilirubin > 20 mg/dL 9. Administration of a somatostatin analogue within the previous month |
|
Interventions | The participants were randomly assigned to 2 groups Group 1: vapreotide (n = 135) Further details: 0.6 mg sc 2 h before operation and then twice daily for 7 days postoperatively Group 2: placebo (n = 140) Further details: same times as intervention | |
Outcomes | The outcomes reported were mortality and perioperative morbidity | |
Notes | Reasons for post‐randomisation drop‐out: did not undergo pancreatic resection Pancreatic fistula definition: drainage fluid (beginning on or after postoperative day 5) of both > 30 mL/day and amylase or lipase activity > 5‐fold upper limits of the normal serum value (grade A) | |
Risk of bias | ||
Bias | Authors' judgement | Support for judgement |
Random sequence generation (selection bias) | Unclear risk | Comment: this information was not available |
Allocation concealment (selection bias) | Unclear risk | Comment: this information was not available |
Blinding (performance bias and detection bias) All outcomes | Low risk | Quote: "patients received vapreotide acetate (0.6 mg) or placebo subcutaneously within up to 2 hours before operation and then twice daily for 7 days postoperatively" |
Incomplete outcome data (attrition bias) All outcomes | High risk | Quote: "patients not resected were replaced" Comment: this would have necessitated exclusion of the trial if there was no blinding (as replacing recruited patients with other patients introduces selection bias). However, we have treated the patients who were replaced as drop‐outs because of adequate blinding |
Selective reporting (reporting bias) | High risk | Comment: all pre‐defined outcomes were not reported |
Free of source of funding bias? | Low risk | Quote: "we would like to thank J‐M Dumont and K Besseghir from Debiopharm SA for their guidance and financial support" Comment: in spite of obtaining financial support from a pharmaceutical company, the authors of this report do not support the use of the drug |