Skip to main content
. 2011 Dec 7;2011(12):CD008691. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD008691.pub2

1. Description of index tests.

Test Description Advantages Disadvantages Type of result Presence of cut‐off values
Screening tests
MPS
StressExercisedipyridamoledobutamine
Radionucleotidethallium‐201 or Tc‐99m sestamibi radionucleotide agents
 
This compares perfusion of myocardium at rest and after a ‘stress’ such as exercise or drugs (e.g. dipyridamole). 
 
 When coronary arteries are normal, ‘stress’ results in vasodilatation and increased coronary blood flow. However, diseased coronary arteries cannot dilate because they are already maximally dilated and there is no increase in blood flow after a stress. MPS reveals these areas as regions of decreased perfusion. A reversible perfusion defect is a sign of ischaemia. A fixed defect (when there is decreased perfusion before, during and after the stress) is an indicator of infarction.
Pharmacological agents overcome limitations of exercise testing in patients with kidney disease
Non‐invasive
Provides information regarding functional status of myocardium under stress conditions
Neither 100% sensitive nor specific
Radiation dose
Results subject to interpretation and reader bias
False positives due to increase in attenuation artefacts caused by left ventricular hypertrophy
False negatives due to balanced ischaemia (e.g. triple vessel disease)
More expensive than exercise ECG
Dichotomous (i.e. stress test positive or stress test negative) None. However, whether a stress test is interpreted as positive or negative depends largely on observer interpretation
DSE
StressExercise 
 dobutamine
Stress echocardiography compares the regional wall motion and thickness of myocardium both at rest and after stress. Regional systolic dysfunction is usually caused by CAD.
Pharmacological stress agent overcomes limitations of exercise testing in patients with kidney disease
Non‐invasive
No radiation dose
Provides information regarding functional status of myocardium under stress conditions
Provides assessment of ventricular size and function
Neither 100% sensitive nor specific
Results subject to interpretation and reader bias
Operator dependent
Acoustic windows not possible in up to 20% of subjects
Hypertensive response to stress agent possible
Cardiomyopathies may also show regional variation in function
Dichotomous (i.e. stress test positive or stress test negative) None. However, whether a stress test is interpreted as positive or negative depends largely on observer interpretation
Exercise ECG
Bruce protocol stress ECG
Patient exercises on a treadmill while connected to an ECG. The level of exercise is increased in progressive stages. The patient's symptoms and blood pressure response are checked repeatedly. Ischaemic ECG changes or angina symptoms brought on by exercise are highly suggestive of underlying CAD Non‐invasive
Provides information regarding functional status of myocardium under stress conditions
Neither 100% sensitive nor specific
Results subject to interpretation and reader bias
Often limited by the inability of CKD patients to achieve an adequate peak exercise workload, development of exercise‐induced hypotension
High proportion have abnormal baseline ECG (left ventricular hypertrophy)
Dichotomous (i.e. stress test positive or stress test negative) No. However, whether a stress test is interpreted as positive or negative depends largely on observer interpretation
Coronary artery calcium score
EBCT 
 Multidetector computed tomography
Cardiac calcium scoring is a non‐invasive test that uses computed tomography to detect the presence of calcium in plaque on the walls of the arteries of the heart (coronary arteries). A calcium score is then derived, calculated as a summation of all calcified lesions in the coronary arteries. The calcium score is then compared with a reference range appropriate to a patient's age and sex. High calcium scores are associated with higher risks of cardiovascular events Non‐invasive Neither 100% sensitive nor specific
Radiation dose
 
Continuous There is no uniformly agreed cut‐off value at which patients are considered at high risk of CAD. We planned to analyse results by combining data from studies which share identical cut‐off values
Echocardiography
Trans‐thoracicTrans‐oesophageal
An ultrasound of the heart that enables assessment of structure and function.
Impairment in systolic function can result from pre‐existing CAD
Provides information regarding myocardial function and regional wall abnormalities, which may suggest pre‐existing ischaemia or MI
Enables assessment of structure
Neither highly sensitive nor specific
Does not provide any information of reversible ischaemia
Results subject to interpretation and reader bias
Dichotomous (e.g. presence or absence of resting wall motion abnormality) None
CT coronary angiography Specialised form of CT that enables imaging of the heart and computerised reconstruction of coronary arteries, permitting assessment of the lumen and vessel walls Non‐invasive
Enables diagnosis of precise location and severity of each lesion as opposed to vascular territory affected, as is the case for most functional tests.
Assesses not only the lumen of the vessel but also the wall. It can also demonstrate soft atheromatous plaques, which cannot be demonstrated on conventional coronary angiography
Radiation dose
Contrast nephropathy
Inability to provide opportunity for immediate intervention (as opposed to coronary angiography)
Dichotomous (i.e. presence or absence of significant CAD) Yes (i.e. ≥ 50% stenosis or ≥ 70% stenosis)
We planned to manage the issue of different cut points by involving an analysis that included:
  • All studies regardless of threshold of CAD on coronary angiography (these will include both studies which have ≥ 50% stenosis and ≥ 70% stenosis

  • Only studies which had ≥ 70% stenosis threshold

Cardiac magnetic resonance imaging MRI of the heart that enables evaluation of its structure and function Non‐invasive
No radiation dose
Enables assessment of structure of myocardium
High spatial resolution means low inter‐observer variability
Neither highly sensitive nor specific
 
Dichotomous (e.g. presence or absence of left ventricular systolic dysfunction) None
Resting ECG Transthoracic interpretation of the electrical activity of the heart over time captured and externally recorded by skin electrodes Provides information regarding the electrical function of the myocardium, which may suggest pre‐existing ischaemia, left ventricular hypertrophy or arrhythmias Neither sensitive nor specific
Does not provide any information of reversible ischaemia
Dichotomous (i.e. presence or absence of certain ECG features) None
CIMT Measurement of the thickness of artery walls, usually by external ultrasound, to detect both the presence and to track the progression of atherosclerotic disease in humans. Used as a surrogate marker for atherosclerosis Non‐invasive Neither highly sensitive nor specific
Does not provide any information on cardiac function
Continuous Yes. This will vary depending on the institution (e.g. 0.75 mm)
Cardiopulmonary exercise testing Evaluates both cardiac and pulmonary function. Cardiac function is evaluated in terms of aerobic capacity and respiratory function.
The subject is exercised on a bicycle ergometer or treadmill. The test enables calculation of maximal aerobic capacity and the point during exercise where anaerobic metabolism is used to supplement aerobic metabolism as a source of energy. These can be measured via gas exchange data
Non‐invasive measurement of ventricular function, respiratory function and cellular function via measurement of gas exchange, as well as detection of myocardial ischaemia
Excellent method of evaluating fitness and operative fitness
Not commonly performed Dichotomous (e.g. stress ECG positive or stress ECG negative; presence or absence of cardiac failure) and
Continuous (e.g. measurement of the maximum aerobic capacity and anaerobic threshold)
Yes, although these will vary for different variables and for different institutions
DSF Used to detect coronary artery calcification. Digital subtraction improves resolution of conventional fluoroscopic methods Non‐invasive
Non exercise
Not commonly used
Radiation dose
Dichotomous (i.e. presence or absence of calcification) None
Exercise radionucleotide ventriculography Technique for a combined assessment of exercise capacity and an evaluation of ventricular size and performance   Not commonly used
Radiation dose
Dichotomous (i.e. stress test positive or stress test negative) None. However, whether a stress test is interpreted as positive or negative depends largely on observer interpretation
Reference standard
Coronary angiography Coronary catheterisation is an invasive procedure to access the coronary circulation and blood filled chambers of the heart using a catheter. It can be performed for both diagnostic and interventional (treatment) purposes. It assesses the diameter of coronary artery lumens, heart chamber size and heart muscle contraction performance Gold standard for detecting CAD.
Enables diagnosis of precise location and severity of each lesion
Intervention (PTCA) possible during procedure
High cost
Lack of sensitivity to intramural coronary atherosclerosis
Risk of complications
Intravenous contrast media may worsen kidney function
Little information on function
Radiation dose
Results subject to interpretation and reader bias, although to a lesser extent than functional tests
Dichotomous (i.e. presence or absence of significant CAD) Yes (i.e. ≥ 50% stenosis or ≥ 70% stenosis).
We managed the issue of different cut points by involving an analysis which included:
  • All studies regardless of threshold of CAD on coronary angiography (these will include both studies which have ≥ 50% stenosis and ≥ 70% stenosis

  • Only studies which had ≥ 70% stenosis threshold

CAD: coronary artery disease; CIMT: carotid intimal medial thickness; CT: computed tomography; ECG: electrocardiograph; MPS: myocardial perfusion scintigraphy; MRI: magnetic resonance imaging; PTAC: percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty