Skip to main content
. 2011 Dec 7;2011(12):CD008691. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD008691.pub2

2. Characteristics of included studies.

Study Country Participants Diabetic patients (%) Angina (%) Hypertensive (%)  Male (%) Reference threshold (% stenosis) TP FP FN TN
Dobutamine stress echocardiography (DSE)
Bates 1996 USA 17 100 NA 98 64 50 9 1 1 6
Brennan 1997 USA 12 56 21 90 45 50 4 1 2 5
Cai 2010 USA 38 54 NA 86 64 70 15 2 8 13
De Lima 2003 Brazil 89 30 25 95 77 70 15 7 19 48
Ferreira 2007 Brazil 126 27 12 NA 69 70 24 14 10 78
Gang 2007 India 40 100 5 92 90 70 9 1 10 20
Garcia‐Canton 1998 Spain 27 NA NA NA 67 70 11 2 1 13
Herzog 1999 USA 50 82 16 94 60 70 12 8 4 26
Jassal 2007 Canada 18 38 NA 77 44 50 0 0 0 18
Reis 1995 USA 30 64 30 96 63 50 22 1 1 6
Sharma 2005 UK 125 39 42 91 64 70 32 5 4 84
Sharma 2009 UK 140 38 27 92 64 70 36 5 4 95
West 2000 USA 33 NA NA NA NA 70 12 8 1 12
Myocardial perfusion scintigraphy (MPS)
Boudreau 1990 USA 80 100 12.5 NA 64 70 36 8 6 30
De Lima 2003 Brazil 65 30 25 95 77 70 8 10 15 32
Garcia‐Canton 1998 Spain 27 NA NA NA 67 70 11 3 1 12
Garg 2000 India 19 100 NA 100 88 50 9 4 2 4
Gowdak 2010 Brazil 219 100 NA 92 69 70 85 31 52 51
Krawczynska 1988 USA 46 NA NA NA NA 50 20 18 0 8
Marwick 1990 USA 45 51 33 81 71 70 4 9 10 22
Vandenberg 1996 USA 41 100 0 NA NA 75 10 6 6 19
Worthley 2003 Australia 40 78 18 98 48 70 13 3 2 22
Stress electrocardiography (EST)
Bennett 1978 USA 4 100 NA 100 36 70 3 1 0 0
Sharma 2005 UK 125 39 42 91 64 70 13 8 23 81
Electron beam computed tomography (EBCT)
Rosario 2010 Brazil 97 38 29 90 65 70 16 25 9 47
Sharples 2004 UK 18 NA NA NA 50 75 * * * *
Digital subtraction fluorography (DSF)
Marwick 1989 USA 86 29 11 36 27 70 28 17 8 33
Exercise ventriculography
Vandenberg 1996 USA 35 100 0 NA NA 75 7 7 7 14
Carotid intimal media thickness (CIMT)
Modi 2006 India 105 58 24 100 NA 97 38 14 4 49
Echocardiography (resting wall motion abnormality)
Sharma 2005 UK 125 39 42 91 64 70 11 4 25 85
Sharma 2009 UK 140 38 27 92 64 70 13 5 27 95
Echocardiography (cardiomegaly or LV dysfunction)
Garg 2000 India 19 100 NA 100 88 50 8 5 19 20
Echocardiography (mitral annular calcification)
Sharma 2005 UK 125 39 42 91 64 70 22 25 14 64
Resting ECG (pathological Q waves, left ventricular hypertrophy, ST depression ≥ 1 mm, ST elevation ≥ 1 mm, T wave inversion or bundle branch block)
Gang 2007 India 40 100 5 92 90 70 9 12 10 9
Garg 2000 India 98 100 NA 100 88 50 51 1 22 24
Sharma 2005 UK 125 39 42 91 64 70 27 14 9 75

FN: false negative; FP: false positive; NA: not available; TN: total negative; TP: total positive

* Study unable to contribute data to meta‐analysis as it reported results per coronary vessel, and not per patient