Table 3.
Cell classification performances of hematologists and the deep learning model in the development cohort.
| Cell class | Precision/recall/APa (%) | |||
|
|
Hematologist-1 (V10)b | Hematologist-2 (V8)b | Hematologist-3 (V6)b | Artificial intelligence modelc |
| Cellsd (n=17,319) | N/Ae | N/Ae | N/Ae | 55.8/85.6/67.4 |
| Erythroid (n=2967) | 87.6/92.3/N/Ae | 88.0/94.1/N/A | 89.1/91.4/N/A | 85.0/84.5/49.1 |
| Blasts (n=4063) | 91.0/85.2/N/A | 79.1/88.2/N/A | 87.5/88.5/N/A | 86.5/80.7/50.2 |
| Myeloid (n=2506) | 79.1/94.2/N/A | 92.0/93.5/N/A | 93.8/80.0/N/A | 94.0/76.4/49.5 |
| Lymphoid (n=1619) | 59.0/78.4/N/A | 67.1/79.7/N/A | 61.2/71.9/N/A | 74.0/58.9/21.9 |
| Plasma cells (n=600) | 84.0/92.6/N/A | 82.3/96.7/N/A | 84.9/81.4/N/A | 53.4/74.1/30.0 |
| Monocyte (n=192) | 25.9/88.7/N/A | 65.7/37.5/N/A | 40.2/64.5/NA | 57.4/30.0/6.1 |
| Megakaryocyte (n=42) | 84.1/97.0/N/A | 52.9/61.5/N/A | 96.8/100.0/N/A | 71.0/56.4/19.0 |
| Unable to identify (n=5330) | 86.5/78.5/N/A | 82.3/77.5/N/A | 83.9/93.5/N/A | 60.9/86.1/25.1 |
aAP: average precision based on the area under the precision-recall curve.
bThe abbreviation V(X) denotes a visiting staff member with (X) years of practice experience.
cAll results were based on 6-fold cross-validation.
dBounding box prediction performance regardless of the classifications (only for the deep learning model).
eNot available.