Skip to main content
. 2020 Apr 17;14:253. doi: 10.3389/fnins.2020.00253

Table 6.

rs-fMRI studies with LLD, HC, and additional comparison groups.

References N
(LLD/HC/MCI/
LLD+MCI)
Study type Depression
status
Analysis
method
Frontal-executive
findings
Corticolimbic
findings
Other
findings
Xie et al. (2013) 72
(18/25/17/12
Cross-sectional Current Seed
(Hippo)
LLD vs. non-depressedLeft hippo: Decreased anti-correlation R-dlPFC1Right hippo: Increased FC in bilat-Thal2, and R-Lent3,
decreased anti-correlated FC in l-dlPFC and d-striatum4
MCI vs. non-CILeft hippo:
Decreased + and – FC in bilat-dlPFC, IPC5, L- pMTG6; and R-dACC7 and SPC8.• Right hippo: Decreased + and - FC in bilat-aTP9 and IPC5; L-vlPFC10, pMTG; R-ITC11.
Interactive effect of LLD*MCIRight hippo: Found in bilat-MOG12, L-dACC, R-dlPFC/dACC cluster
LLD vs. non-depressedLeft hippo: Increased FC bilat-PCC13, and R-dmPFC14Right hippo: Increased FC in L-Hippo
MCI vs. non-CILeft hippo: Decreased + and – FC in bilat-dmPFC• Right hippo: Decreased + and – FC in bilat-aTP9, PHG15
Interactive effect LLD*MCIRight hippo: Found in vmPFC16
LLD vs. non-depressedRight hippo: Decreased anti- correlated FC in bilat-MOG13
MCI vs. non-CI:Left hippo: Decreased + and – FC in bilat-RSC17; L-postCG18
Li et al. (2015b) 63
(25/26/-/15)
Cross-sectional Current Seed (Amygdala) LLD vs. HC
Decreased FC in R-SPL19, MFG20, IFG21, ITG22
Increased in cerebellar vermis
LLD+aMCI vs. HC
Decreased FC in bilat-SPL, R-IFG, MFG; and MTG23
Increased FC in IPL24
LLD+aMCI vs. LLD
Decreased FC in L-MTG20
LLD vs. HC
Increased FC in R-PCC13 and TP25
LLD+aMCI vs. HC
Decreased FC in left TP, PHG15, hippo26, cuneus
LLD+aMCI vs. LLD
Greater decrease of FC in the bilateral TP, cuneus (posterior DMN35)
LLD+MCI vs. LLD
Decreased FC in OG27
LLD vs. HC decreased FC in PreCG28
LLD+aMCI vs. HC
Decreased FC in PreCG, bilat-IOG29 and MOG30
LLD+aMCI vs. LLD
Decreased FC in bilat-FFG31, IOG, MOG
Chen et al. (2016) 256
(55/114/87)
Cross-sectional Remitted Correlation between each pair of 36 seeds that represent five major RSNs32 LLD vs. HC: Reduced FC degree in bilat-ITG22
MCI vs. HC:
Trend toward increased FC degree at all nodes (except for r-ITG22)
LLD vs. HC:
Reduced FC strength in ECN33-DMN35
*After controlling for age, sex, education and APOE genotype: reduced correlation in ECN-DMN pair in LLD > MCI vs. HC
LLD vs. HC: Reduced FC degree in SMA36
LLD vs. HC: Reduced FC strength in SMN37
aMCI vs. HC: A trend toward increased FC strength within SAL and SMN
LLD vs. aMCI: Reduced FC strength within SAL38 and SMN
Li et al. (2015a) 79
(23/25/18/13)
Cross-sectional Current Graph theory
threshold range (0.03–0.5)
LLD, aMCI, LLD+aMCI vs. HC
Combined ECN/VAN split into two distinct modules: ECN33 and VAN34
LLD and aMCI vs. HC
DMN module was split into two smaller modules
LLD vs. HC
Disrupted FC segregation (decreased local efficiency)
LLD+aMCI > LLD > MCI
Greatest mean nodal efficiency
LLD+aMCI vs. aMCI
Decreased local efficiency
LLD+aMCI vs. all other groups
greatest disruptions in integration (diminished global efficiency)
LLD+aMCI Had most variable modular community followed by LLD
1

dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (dlPFC);

2

thalamus (Thal);

3

lentiform nucleus (Lent);

4

dorsal striatum (caudate and putamen) d-striatum;

5

inferior parietal cortex (IPC);

6

left posterior middle temporal gyrus (pMTG);

7

dorsal anterior cingulate cortex (dACC);

8

superior parietal cortex (SPC);

9

anterior temporal pole (aTP);

10

ventrolateral prefrontal cortex (vlPFC);

11

inferior temporal cortex (ITC);

12

middle occipital gyrus (MOG);

13

posterior cingulate cortex (PCC);

14

dorsomedial prefrontal cortex (dmPFC);

15

parahippocampal gyrus (PHG);

16

ventromedial prefrontal cortex (vmPFC);

17

retro-splenial cortex (RSC);

18

post central gyrus (postCG);

19

superior parietal lobe (SPL);

20

middle frontal gyrus (MFG);

21

inferior frontal gyrus (IFG);

22

inferior temporal gyrus (ITG);

23

middle temporal gyrus (MTG);

24

inferior parietal lobule (IPL);

25

temporal pole (TP);

26

hippocampus (hippo);

27

occipital gyri (OG);

28

pre-central gyrus (PreCG);

29

inferior occipital gyrus (IOG);

30

middle occipital gyrus (MOG);

31

fusiform gyrus (FFG);

32

resting state networks (RSN);

33

executive control network (ECN);

34

ventral attention network (VAN);

35

default mode network (DMN);

36

supplemental motor area (SMA);

37

sensory-motor network (SMN);

38

salience network (SAL).