Peck 1990.
Methods | Observational retrospective cohort with control group. Follow‐up 6 months. | |
Participants | American nursing home patients. 52 intubated patients with dementia (Mini Mental Status Examination) MMS scores of zero) were compared with 52 non‐intubated patients of mixed diseases. In this group 71% were demented (scoring less than 23 on the MMS), and had resided in the nursing facility for a shorter time (mean 36 months compared to 66). In the intubated group the mean age was 87 years, and 45/52 were female. |
|
Interventions | Long term enteral feeding (nasogastric, gastrostomy and jejunostomy tubes ‐ does not state number of patients per mode of feeding), 26/52 had been in place for more than a year (range 1 month to 6.4 years). Reasons for feeding were weight loss 23/52 (44%), refusal to eat 12/52 (23%), dysphagia 9/52 (17%) and stroke 8/52 (15%). | |
Outcomes | In the tube fed group at 6 months: 25/52 (48%) increased in weight, 58% had episodes of aspiration pneumonia, 21% decubitus ulcers, and 71% were restrained to prevent extubation. | |
Notes | Limitation: non intubated group were not comparable on disease. |