Table 2.
Authors and Year | Study Design | Sample | Disease/setting | Intervention Type | Length | Animals | Outcome | Findings |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Barker, 2015 | RCT | 40 hospitalized children | Children admitted to Hospital of Richmond except Pediatric Intensive Care Units | Intervention group: AAI Active control group: jigsaw puzzle |
10 min sessions | Dogs | Pain and Anxiety ratings Attachments Questionnaire for Children Family life-space Diagrams |
The AAI-group experienced lower post-intervention anxiety scores (p < 0.05). No significant within- or between-group pre-post changes in either pain or anxiety were detected. |
Tsai, 2010 | Quasi-experimental design | 15 hospitalized children | Acute or chronic conditions | AAT (taking place in patient room) Control group: puzzle (each child did both the interventions) |
6–10 min sessions | Dogs | Blood pressure and heart rate Child Medical Fear Scale State-Trait Anxiety Inventory for Children (STAI-C) |
Systolic Blood Pressure (SBP) decreased from before, during and after AAT (p = 0.008). Children’s anxiety and medical fear did not differ after the AAT visit compared with the comparison intervention. |
Braun 2009 | Quasi-experimental intervention study | 57 children | Acute care settings | Intervention group: AAT Control group: children sat quietly for 15 min | 15–20 min sessions | Dogs | Blood pressure, pulse rate, respiratory rate Pain level (FACE pain scale) |
The group experiencing AAT had a significantly lower post-test pain score compared to the control group (p = 0.006). Even parents perception of pain reduction was higher for the intervention group (p = 0.008). AAT group presented higher respiratory rate (p = 0.011), no differences were found in blood pressure and pulse |
Caprilli 2006 | RCT | 138 children | Different hospital wards | AAA | Once a week for 2-h sessions | Dogs | Children participation Infection rate in the hospital Children pleasure Parents and staff level of satisfaction |
No increase in infection or in contagious disease transmitted by dogs were found. The children pleasure evaluation showed significant improvement. Parents and staff satisfaction rate was high. |
Gagnon 2004 | Descriptive study | 16 parents and 12 nurses | Pediatric oncology wards | Dog-AAT | Each session lasted a whole day | Dogs | Satisfaction with the program and of quality of care | Beneficial role of animal therapy was underlined for physical, social, emotional, coping and self-esteem dimension |
Bouchard 2004 | Pilot project | 27 children | Pediatric oncology wards | AAT with a dog at bed-side | / | Dogs | Client satisfaction Impact on nursing work Appropriateness of prevention measures |
Parents outlined positive aspects of the experience (as increasing children confidence, mood improvement). According to nurses, the program was well structured. They used the children’s relationship with dogs as a therapeutic tool during the intervention process. |
Kaminski 2002 | Clinical trial on a convenience sample | 70 hospitalized children | General inpatients | Intervention group: dog-facilitated therapy Control group: Child Life group |
One session per week | Dogs | Self-reported mood, and parents and caregiver reports Clinical assessment Physiological indicators: heart rate, blood pressure, salivary cortisol |
Parents and caregivers rated their children as happier after intervention in both groups (p < 0.001). Heart rate was significantly higher in the pet therapy group (99.27 ± 16.38) than in control group (88.44 ± 12.68). |
Moody et al. 2002 | Two cross-sectional surveys | Staff Questionnaire: 115 pre-program and 45 after | Pediatric Medical wards | Pet-visitation program | / | Dogs | Hospital staff perception (questionnaire to administrators, doctors, nursing staff and therapists; 6 weeks before and 12 weeks after the introduction of the program) | Prior to the introduction of the dog visitation, there were high staff expectations regarding the program. Healthcare workers outlined the relaxation effect, the mood improvement. Staff member generally accepted dogs. |