Skip to main content
. 2016 May 20;8(5):695–706. doi: 10.1016/j.eujim.2016.05.005

Table 2.

Characteristics of the retrieved studies regarding animal interventions for inpatient children. The table reported information about the study design, the participant characteristics (sample size, disease, and setting), the intervention type (including length and animal used), the considered outcomes and the main results.

Authors and Year Study Design Sample Disease/setting Intervention Type Length Animals Outcome Findings
Barker, 2015 RCT 40 hospitalized children Children admitted to Hospital of Richmond except Pediatric Intensive Care Units Intervention group: AAI
Active control group: jigsaw puzzle
10 min sessions Dogs Pain and Anxiety ratings
Attachments Questionnaire for Children
Family life-space Diagrams
The AAI-group experienced lower post-intervention anxiety scores (p < 0.05). No significant within- or between-group pre-post changes in either pain or anxiety were detected.
Tsai, 2010 Quasi-experimental design 15 hospitalized children Acute or chronic conditions AAT (taking place in patient room)
Control group: puzzle
(each child did both the interventions)
6–10 min sessions Dogs Blood pressure and heart rate
Child Medical Fear Scale
State-Trait Anxiety Inventory for Children (STAI-C)
Systolic Blood Pressure (SBP) decreased from before, during and after AAT (p = 0.008). Children’s anxiety and medical fear did not differ after the AAT visit compared with the comparison intervention.
Braun 2009 Quasi-experimental intervention study 57 children Acute care settings Intervention group: AAT Control group: children sat quietly for 15 min 15–20 min sessions Dogs Blood pressure, pulse rate, respiratory rate
Pain level (FACE pain scale)
The group experiencing AAT had a significantly lower post-test pain score compared to the control group (p = 0.006). Even parents perception of pain reduction was higher for the intervention group (p = 0.008). AAT group presented higher respiratory rate (p = 0.011), no differences were found in blood pressure and pulse
Caprilli 2006 RCT 138 children Different hospital wards AAA Once a week for 2-h sessions Dogs Children participation
Infection rate in the hospital
Children pleasure
Parents and staff level of satisfaction
No increase in infection or in contagious disease transmitted by dogs were found. The children pleasure evaluation showed significant improvement. Parents and staff satisfaction rate was high.
Gagnon 2004 Descriptive study 16 parents and 12 nurses Pediatric oncology wards Dog-AAT Each session lasted a whole day Dogs Satisfaction with the program and of quality of care Beneficial role of animal therapy was underlined for physical, social, emotional, coping and self-esteem dimension
Bouchard 2004 Pilot project 27 children Pediatric oncology wards AAT with a dog at bed-side / Dogs Client satisfaction
Impact on nursing work
Appropriateness of prevention measures
Parents outlined positive aspects of the experience (as increasing children confidence, mood improvement). According to nurses, the program was well structured. They used the children’s relationship with dogs as a therapeutic tool during the intervention process.
Kaminski 2002 Clinical trial on a convenience sample 70 hospitalized children General inpatients Intervention group: dog-facilitated therapy
Control group: Child Life group
One session per week Dogs Self-reported mood, and parents and caregiver reports
Clinical assessment
Physiological indicators: heart rate, blood pressure, salivary cortisol
Parents and caregivers rated their children as happier after intervention in both groups (p < 0.001). Heart rate was significantly higher in the pet therapy group (99.27 ± 16.38) than in control group (88.44 ± 12.68).
Moody et al. 2002 Two cross-sectional surveys Staff Questionnaire: 115 pre-program and 45 after Pediatric Medical wards Pet-visitation program / Dogs Hospital staff perception (questionnaire to administrators, doctors, nursing staff and therapists; 6 weeks before and 12 weeks after the introduction of the program) Prior to the introduction of the dog visitation, there were high staff expectations regarding the program. Healthcare workers outlined the relaxation effect, the mood improvement. Staff member generally accepted dogs.