Table 1.
Incidence and risk factors for Caesarean scar pain. *Pain at 12 months after delivery. †The risk factors for combined pain of multiple body parts were reported, and the risk factors specific for Caesarean scar pain were not reported. ‡Pain at 8 months after delivery. ¶Pain at 14.5 months after delivery. §Pain at 26 months after delivery. ||Pain at 10.1 months after delivery. #Studies in which evaluated risk factors for Caesarean scar pain failed to demonstrate statistical significance. CD, Caesarean delivery; SF-36, Short Form 36 Health Survey.
Study | Sample size | Time points after delivery |
||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
8 weeks | 3 months | 6 months | 8 months or greater | |||
Wang and colleagues38 | 786 | Incidence | 6.9% | 1.9% | 0.3%* | |
Risk factors | † | |||||
Jin and colleagues40 | 502 | Incidence | 8.2% | 3.7% | 1.7%* | |
Risk factors | † | † | † | |||
Moriyama and colleagues41 | 225 | Incidence | 30.7% | |||
Risk factors | Lighter weight and omission of intrathecal morphine | |||||
Niklasson and colleagues42 | 231 | Incidence | 22.4% | 16.8% | 5.5%* | |
Risk factors | † | † | ||||
Richez and colleagues43 | 268 | Incidence | 28% | 19% | ||
Risk factors | Pain during current pregnancy, history of miscarriage, and lower mental component summary score of SF-36 | Postoperative complications and lower mental component summary score of SF-36 | ||||
Ortner and colleagues44 | 335 | Incidence | 11.0% | 3.0% | 0.6%* | |
Risk factors | Higher pain score at 24 h after operation | |||||
de Brito Cancado and colleagues45 | 402 | Incidence | 11.4% | |||
Risk factors | Higher pain level at 12 h after operation and postoperative Day 2, lower intrathecal bupivacaine dose, and omission of perioperative NSAIDs | |||||
Shahin and Osman46 | 325 | Incidence | 4.3%‡ | |||
Risk factors | † | |||||
Sng and colleagues47 | 857 | Incidence | Pain lasting more than 3 months: 9.2% | 6.0%¶ | ||
Risk factors | Higher pain scores immediately after operation, pain present elsewhere, and non-private insurance status | |||||
Loos and colleagues48 | 690 | Incidence | 32.3%§ | |||
Risk factors | >2 previous Pfannenstiel incisions, presence of scar numbness, and emergency CD | |||||
Nikolajsen and colleagues1 | 220 | Incidence | Pain lasting more than 3 months: 18.6% | 12.3%|| | ||
Risk factors | General anaesthesia, pain problem elsewhere, and higher recall of severe postoperative pain | |||||
Mackeen and colleagues49# | 589 | Incidence | ||||
Risk factors | Skin closure with staples (vs suture) | |||||
Liu and colleagues50# | 469 | Incidence | 14.6% | 4.2%* | ||
Risk factors | Elective CD (vs emergency CD), repeat CD (vs primary CD), severe acute postoperative pain, general anaesthesia, and wound infection | |||||
Bollag and colleagues51# | 81 | Incidence | ||||
Risk factors | Transversus abdominis plane block with placebo (vs bupivacaine vs bupivacaine+clonidine) | Transversus abdominis plane block with placebo (vs bupivacaine vs bupivacaine+clonidine) | Transversus abdominis plane block with placebo (vs bupivacaine vs bupivacaine+clonidine) |