Skip to main content
. 2020 Apr 28;15(4):e0231646. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0231646

Table 2. Subgroups examined in the sensitivity analyses.

Group Rationale for Evaluation Studies, n I2, % Overall HR (95% CI)
DCGL reported as an outcome To investigate the effect of TG on loss of graft, where patients who died were excluded from the graft survival analysis 12 [34, 3641, 43, 46, 48, 49, 51] 70.0 3.30 (2.43–4.50)
DCGF reported (graft loss and other laboratory indicators of graft failure) To investigate the effect of TG on graft loss/functional deterioration 5 [26, 42, 45, 47, 52] 80.5 3.31 (1.55–7.11)
Graft loss and patient death as outcomes To investigate the effect of TG in studies that did not censor death 4 [35, 44, 50, 53] 11.4 2.58 (1.80–3.71)
Studies that included published HRs and CIs To investigate the effect of TG in studies that presented HR and CIs, avoiding uncertainties around the estimation of the HR 13 [26, 34, 3638, 40, 4244, 46, 5153] 62.7 4.11 (2.94–5.73)
Follow-up reported as commencing at time of biopsy To investigate the effect of TG in studies that defined follow-up initiation at the time of biopsy 17 [26, 35, 36, 3840, 42, 4453] 65.5 3.24 (2.45–4.28)
Follow-up reported as commencing at time of biopsy and published HR To investigate the effect of TG in studies that met the strict criteria where follow-up was reported as commencing at the time of biopsy and HR was published 10 [26, 36, 38, 40, 42, 44, 46, 5153] 50.3 4.53 (3.19–6.43)
For-cause biopsy and time to biopsy data reported To investigate the effect of TG in studies that were used in the meta-regression analysis 16 [3437, 4042, 44, 45, 4753] 61.6 2.89 (2.20–3.80)
For-cause biopsy reported, DC graft outcome and time to biopsy data To investigate the effect of TG in a subgroup of studies used in the meta-regression analysis that censored death 12 [34, 36, 37, 4042, 45, 4749, 51, 52] 69.1 3.09 (2.18–4.37)

CI, confidence interval; DC, death-censored; DCGF, death-censored graft failure; DCGL, death-censored graft loss; HR, hazard ratio; TG, transplant glomerulopathy.