Skip to main content
. 2020 Mar 18;368:m575. doi: 10.1136/bmj.m575

Table 2.

Characteristics of included studies, Koepping to Whitley

Author and year Country Study period* Study length Follow-up time Outcome Intervention measured Celebrity No of interventions / celebrities§ Celebrity type Celebrity recognition Total suicides and specific suicide method Media type** Total risk of bias
Koepping 1989 The Netherlands 1974-84 4018 days 7 days (including day 0) Daily count Binary† No 126 Total suicides Newspaper Serious
Ladwig 2012 Germany October-December 2009 56 days 28 days Daily counts aggregated over the follow-up period Binary† Yes Sports International Railway suicides Mixed Moderate
Lee 2019 South Korea 2007-15 164 fortnights 2 weeks Daily counts aggregated to 2 week periods Binary† Yes 69¶ Mixed Mixed, more local Total suicides Mixed Serious
Mockus 2018 USA 1973-88 5844 days 3 days including day 0 Daily counts Binary† Yes 11¶ Mixed Mixed, more local Total suicides Mixed Serious
Niederkrotenthaler 2009 Austria 1996-2006 896 days 28 days Daily counts aggregated to 28 day period Binary† Yes 16¶ Mixed Mixed Total suicides and mixed suicide methods Mixed Moderate
Phillips 1974 USA 1947-68 102 months Same month or next month depending on intervention date Monthly counts Binary† Yes 34¶ Mixed Mixed, more local Total suicides Newspaper Serious
Pirkis 2020 Australia 2001-16 5845 days 2 months Daily counts Binary† Yes Entertainer International Total suicides and by hanging Mixed Moderate
Queinec 2011 France 1979-2006 10 227 days 30 days Daily counts aggregated to months Binary† Yes Mixed Mixed, more local Total suicides and mixed suicide methods Mixed Moderate
Romer 2006 USA July-October 1993 123 days 10 days Daily counts Continuous‡ No 125 Total suicides Mixed Serious
Ruddigkeit 2010 Germany 2001-03 156 weeks 1 week Daily counts aggregated to weeks Binary† No 143 Total suicides Newspaper Serious
Schafer 2015 Germany 1992-2009 90 weeks 4 weeks Daily counts aggregated to weeks Binary† Yes Mixed Mixed, more local Total suicides and mixed suicide methods Mixed Moderate
Stack 1996 Japan 1955-85 372 months Same month or next month depending on intervention date Monthly counts Binary† Yes 24¶ Mixed Mixed Total suicides Mixed Serious
Ueda 2014 Japan 1989-2010 8035 days 10 days Daily counts Binary† Yes 109¶ Mixed Local Total suicides Mixed Moderate
Ueda 2017 Japan 2010-14 1645 days 10 days Daily counts Binary† Yes 26¶ Mixed Local Total suicides Mixed Moderate
Whitley 2019 Canada 1999-2015 189 months 2 months (same month and next month) Monthly counts Binary† Yes Entertainer International Total suicides and by hanging Mixed Moderate
*

Time frame when outcome data were selected.

Period of intervention.

Number of media reports of suicide.

§

Number of celebrities (¶) or number of interventions.

**

For celebrities, media type is always assumed to be mixed.