TABLE 4.
Level of Support Designations for Adolescent Substance Use Treatment Approaches, with Supporting Citations
| Weil-Established Stand-Alone Treatments | |
|---|---|
| CBT-G | 2014 EBU |
| Burrow-Sánchez et al. (2015): culturally tailored CBT-G equivalent to standard CBT-G | |
| CBT-I |
|
| FBT-E |
|
| Well-Established Multicomponent Treatments | |
| MET/CBT | 2014 EBU |
| Kelly et al. (2017): Equivalent to DC/12 but no SU effects | |
| MET/CBT + FBT-B | 2014 EBU |
| Probably Efficacious Stand-Alone Treatments | |
| FBT-B | 2014 EBU |
| MI/MET | 2014 EBU |
| de Gee et al. (2014): Equivalent to information only Walker et al. (2016) (MET): MET boosters superior to MET only | |
| Winters et al. (2014) (MI + Parent session): Superior to assessment only; Equivalent to MI only | |
| Probably Efficacious Multicomponent Treatments | |
| FBT-E + CM | 2014 EBU |
| Letourneau et al. (2017): Equivalent to UC | |
| MET/CBT + FBT-B + CM | 2014 EBU |
| MET/CBT + CM | Stanger et al. (2015): Superior to MET/CBT |
| Possibly Efficacious Stand-Alone Treatments | |
| DC/12 | 2014 EBU |
| Kelly et al. (2017): Equivalent to MET/CBT but no | |
| SU effects | |
Note: A-CRA = adolescent community reinforcement approach; BSFT = brief strategic family therapy; CBT = cognitive-behavioral therapy; CBT-G = group cognitive-behavioral therapy; CBT-I = individual cognitive-behavioral therapy; CM = contingency management; DC/12 = drug counseling/12-step approach; EBU = evidence base update; FBT-B = behavioral family-based treatment; FBT-E = ecological family-based treatment; MDFT = multidimensional family therapy; MET = motivational enhancement therapy; MI = motivational interviewing; SU = substance use; UC = usual care.
A 2014 EBU reference maintains designations from previous review (Hogue et al., 2014). Please consult that review for references supporting specific designations.