Santerre 1996.
Methods | Study design: ITS | |
Participants | Physicians Clinical speciality: obstetrics and gynaecology Level of training: fully trained Setting/country: not clear/US |
|
Interventions | In October 1988, the ACOG issued a physician practice guideline stating that a prior caesarean section was no longer a reason for performing a repeat section | |
Outcomes | 1 process outcome: vaginal birth after previous caesarean section | |
Notes | ‐ | |
Risk of bias | ||
Bias | Authors' judgement | Support for judgement |
Intervention independent of other changes ‐ ITS | Unclear risk | No information was provided |
Shape of Intervention effect pre‐specified ‐ ITS | Low risk | Quote, pg. 317: "the ACOG guideline essentially states that a previous birth by cesarean is no longer a good reason for doing one again in the future. Consequently, if guidelines are effective at altering practice patterns, a noticeable increase in the VBAC rate should be detected after 1988 when the ACOG guideline was established" |
Intervention unlikely to affect data collection ‐ ITS | Low risk | The intervention (ACOG guidelines) did not affect either the source or method of data collection |
Blinding of outcome assessors (detection bias) ‐ ITS All outcomes | Low risk | The outcome was objective |
Incomplete outcome data (attrition bias) ‐ ITS All outcomes | Low risk | The data set came from 55 Massachusetts hospitals from 1987 to 1991 |
Selective reporting (reporting bias) ‐ ITS | Low risk | All relevant outcomes in the methods section were reported in the results section |
Other bias ‐ ITS | Low risk | There was no evidence of other risks of bias |