Skip to main content
. 2013 Feb 28;2013(2):CD007651. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD007651.pub2
Characteristic
Study ID
Measurement period Study population Intervention group Control group Overall effect Comments
Araujo‐Soares 2009 Baseline 195 boys and girls 122 115 NS PA was assessed with the International Physical Activity Questionnaire for adolescents using the 7‐day recall method. Children indicated how many sessions of activities they had engaged in and how long each lasted. From this questionnaire a measure of general MVPA and exercise was derived consisting of a composite score that multiplied the frequency of sessions per week with minutes per session.
Intention‐to‐treat analysis conducted
Large treatment effect despite minimal intervention Intervention effects increased following intervention
End of intervention (9 months) 158 113 P = 0.016
45 (95% CI 9 to 82)
Barbeau 2007 Baseline 201 girls 27.6 27.6 NA Free‐living PA was measured using a 7‐day recall tool
End of intervention 60 40.2 P = 0.0006 22.2 (95% CI 9.6 to 34.2)
Bayne‐Smith 2004 Baseline 442 girls 67.5 82.5 NS Self‐reported activity measured as the number of 15 min sessions engaged in outside of school time
End of intervention 79.5 82.5 NS
Donnelly 2009 Baseline 1490 boys and girls NA NA NS PA assessment was conducted using direct observations via the System for Observing Fitness Instruction Time (SOFIT) method. Values are means taken from 4‐day averages of minutes of MVPA (≥4 METs)
End of intervention (year 3) 98 72 P = 0.001
Ewart 1998 Baseline 88 adolescent girls 8.6 8.1 Observed step test exercise duration measured in seconds
End of intervention 9.55 7.03 P < 0.0003
Haerens 2006 Boys Baseline 2434 boys and girls 18 23 Self‐reported leisure time PA measured in number of minutes.
Intervention 1 = curricula to promote physical activity with parental involvement.
Intervention 2 = curricula to promote physical activity with no parental involvement.
End of intervention (year 2) 25 24 P < 0.05
Girls Baseline 13 17
End of intervention (Year 2) 16 18 NS
Intervention 1 Baseline 16
During intervention (9 months) 23 19 P < 0.05
Intervention 2 Baseline 16
During intervention (9 months) 21 19 P < 0.05
Haerens 2009 Baseline 281 boys and girls 87.6 86.7 Physical activity levels were determined using the validated Flemish Physical Activity Questionnaire.
The FPAQ measured total physical activity (min/day).
End of intervention (3 months) 88.6 83.9 NS
Jones 2008 Baseline 606 girls 65 65 NS PA data were collected using multiple administrations of the Self‐Administered Physical Activity Checklist (SAPAC), as well as with the Calcium, Osteoporosis and Physical Activity (COPA) questionnaire
End of intervention 71 64 P = 0.16
7.05
95% CI (6.75 to 7.35)
Kriemler 2010 Baseline 502 boys and girls 21.2 21.2 NS PA was monitored with an accelerometer which was worn continuously around the hip for 5 weekdays, at baseline and at the end of the intervention
End of intervention 21.2 19.4 P = 0.03
0.44
95% CI (0.05 to 0.82)
Lubans 2009 Baseline 106 boys and girls 71 73 NS Yamax SW700 pedometers were used to measure PA. Participants were asked to wear sealed pedometers for 5 days (including 4 consecutive school days and 1 weekend day)
Follow‐up (6 months) 75.4 64 NS
Luepker 1996 Vigorous activity Baseline 4019 boys and girls NA NA NA Self‐reported PA of 1 day. Recall of duration of 22 common physical activities
Prolonged treatment effect noted in sample 3 years post intervention. No gender specific analysis
Results favor the control group
Absence of baseline measurements requires results to be interpreted with caution for both outcomes
End of intervention (year 3) 30 22 P < 0.001
Total PA Baseline NA NA NA
End of intervention (year 3) 121 125 P = 0.59
McManus 2008 Intervention 1 Baseline 193 boys and girls 159 NA NS Percent time and (min) per day moderately active (HR >139 and <160 beats/min). Children had weekday PA assessed using continuous HR telemetry
Intervention 1 = educational group (PE classes with PA and heart health education)
Intervention 2 = Non‐educational group (PE classes without PA or heart health education)
Changes in amount of time spent in PA only improved when daily feedback was provided to children‐ in the absence of feedback, no change in PA was observed.
While study data suggest a treatment effect, text in publication indicated no treatment effect at the end of the intervention.
End of intervention (6 months) 245 NA P<0.05
Intervention 2 Baseline 193 NA NS
End of intervention (6 months) 262 NA P < 0.05
Neumark‐Sztainer 2009 Baseline 96 boys and girls NA NA NS PA was assessed with the Past Day Physical Activity Recall. Trained staff completed this tool with participants in a one‐on‐one interview.
End of intervention 157.2 142.8 P = 0.651
Neumark‐Sztainer 2010 Baseline 336 adolescent girls 90 90   There were the mean of the number of 30‐min blocks (˜90 min/day, or just under 90 min/day at baseline)
Follow‐up (5 months post‐intervention) 84 69 0.186 (NS)
Peralta 2009 Baseline 32 boys 92 79.7 NA Weekday MVPA (min/day). PA was measured over 7 consecutive days using MTI 7164 Actigraph accelerometers worn on belts at the right hip. Average minutes of moderate (MPA) vigorous (VPA) and MVPA were calculated using a composite method.
Follow up (6 months) 123 96.6 P = 0.43
16.4
95% CI (‐26.8 to 59.6)
Robinson 1999 Child report Baseline 192 boys and girls 56.7 44.3   Self‐reported time spent in and out of school PA using an activity checklist.
PA, metabolic equivalent‐weighted, min/week
End of intervention 56.7 48.3 NS
Parent report Baseline 11 9  
End of intervention 16 17 NS
Salmon 2008 Intervention 1 Baseline 268 boys and girls NA NA   PA was assessed using Manufacturing Technology Inc. AM7164‐2.2C accelerometers. Children wore the MTI on a belt positioned over the right hip during waking hours, except when bathing or swimming, for 8 days at each of the 4 measurement points.
Intervention 1 = behavioural modification group (BM) ‐ aimed to reduce time spent in sedentary behaviors
Intervention 2 = fundamental movement skills group (FMS) ‐ aimed to increase skills and enjoyment of PA.
Intervention 3 = combined BM/FMS group received both the BM and FMS lessons.
Baseline data available for boys and girls; however, not available for whole sample. Results only available post intervention for whole sample. Statistically significant effect only observed for those in the FMS group compared to control and not the other 2 intervention arms
Follow up (12 months) NA NA NS
Intervention 2 Baseline NA NA  
Follow‐up (12 months) NA NA P < 0.05 (FMS)
9.5 (1.4 to 17.6)
Intervention 3 Baseline NA NA  
Follow‐up (12 months) NA NA NS
Simon 2004 Baseline 954 adolescent males and females 150 162   Self‐reported number of months that each activity is performed over the past year and the mean weekly time devoted to PA calculated
End of intervention (year 4) 207 153 P < 0.0001 66 (95% CI 33.6 to 97.8)
Stone 2003 End of intervention 1297 boys and girls NA NA P < 0.05 Accelerometers measured time spent engaged in PA
Webber 2008 Baseline 36 schools
all girls
23.7 23.7 NS
1.6
95% CI (0.0 to 3.3
MET‐weighted minutes of MVPA using accelerometers worn for 7 consecutive days except while bathing, swimming, or sleeping
End of intervention (year 2) 22.4 22.4 NS 
 ‐0.2 (95% CI ‐1.4 to 1.0)
Program Champion– directed intervention (year 3) 22.2 20.8 P = 0.05
1.6 (95% CI 0 to 3.3)
Weeks 2008 Boys Baseline 81 boys and girls NA NA NS A PA score was derived for each subject from responses to a bone‐specific physical activity questionnaire (BPAQ), using a custom‐designed LabVIEW program (National Instruments). The program ran an algorithm that accounted for frequency of exercise bouts and years of participation in past (whole of life) and current (previous 12 month) exercise involvement
Effect favors control
End of intervention NA NA NS
Girls Baseline NA NA NA
End of intervention NA NA P = 0.008
Wilson 2011 Baseline 1308 boys and girls 43.4 44
Follow‐up (2 weeks post intervention) 43.6 43.6 NS
Williamson 2007 Baseline 586 boys and girls HEE
NA
ADT
NA
NS The Self‐Administered Physical Activity Checklist (SAPAC) is a 29‐item self‐report, 1‐day recall of physical and selected sedentary activities using a checklist format. Self‐reported data from the SAPAC were summarized to measure minutes of MVPA
Intervention 1 = healthy eating and exercise group (HEE). Provided with increased opportunity for PA during the day and education
Intervention 2 = Alcohol/Drug/Tobacco use/abuse prevention (ADT). Program to modify children's beliefs about the use of tobacco, alcohol, and illicit drugs
End of intervention (18 months) 22 ‐3 P = 0.06
CI: confidence interval; NA: not acknowledged; NS: not significant; MVPA: moderate to vigorous physical activity; MET: metabolic equivalent; FPAQ: Flemish Physical Activity Questionnaire; HR: heart rate; PE: physical education; PA: physical activity.