Characteristic Study ID |
Measurement period | Study population | Intervention group | Control group | Overall effect | Comments | ||
Colin‐Ramirez 2010 | Baseline | 498 boys and girls | 84 | 84 | ‐ | ‐ | ||
Follow‐up (12 months post‐intervention) | 85 | 89 | NS | |||||
Burke 1998 | Enrichment group boys | Baseline | 720 boys and girls | NA | NA | NS | Self‐reported time spent watching TV Time spent watching TV returned almost to baseline levels after the intervention in all groups, except in boys in the enrichment group |
|
End of intervention | NA | NA | NS | |||||
Follow‐up (6 months) | 18 | 23 | P = 0.014 | |||||
Enrichment group girls | Baseline | NA | NA | NS | ||||
End of intervention | NA | NA | NS | |||||
Follow‐up (6 months) | 2 | 5 | NS | |||||
Gentile 2009 | Child report | Baseline | 1029 boys and girls | 245.1 | 262.3 | Time spent viewing TV and playing video games was assessed by children, using methods that have been used reliably with children. Time spent on TV and video games was summed to create weekly screen time (hours/week) | ||
Follow up (6 months) | 238.3 | 249.4 | NS | |||||
Parent report | Baseline | 180 | 197.1 | |||||
Follow up (6 months) | 205.7 | 222.9 | P < 0.05 Cohen's d 1.38 = 2 hours less screen time in favour of experimental group |
|||||
Haerens 2006 | Boys | Baseline | 2434 boys and girls | 33.9 | 53.4 | ‐ | Self‐reported amount of time spent watching TV | |
End of intervention (year 2) | 34.6 | 35.0 | P<0.05 | |||||
Girls | Baseline | 20.5 | 24.8 | ‐ | ||||
End of intervention (year 2) | 18.7 | 22.9 | NS | |||||
Jones 2008 | Baseline | 606 girls | 137 | 114 | NA | Sedentary activity data were collected using multiple administrations of the Self‐Administered Physical Activity Checklist (SAPAC), as well as with the Calcium, Osteoporosis and Physical Activity (COPA) questionnaire. The SAPAC had an additional section for sedentary activities such as TV and video watching at 3 time periods during the previous day It is worth noting that the control group spent a lot more time in sedentary behaviours at follow‐up than they had at baseline, and also that the control group had much lower sedentary behavior at baseline than the intervention group |
||
End of intervention | 135 | 152 | P = 0.04 17 (95% CI 16.5 to 17.5) |
|||||
Kipping 2008 | Weekdays | Baseline | 604 boys and girls | 150 | 135 | Self reported time spent engaged in screen‐based activities. Child self‐report about the length of time spent doing screen‐based activities on the previous weekday and Saturday | ||
End of intervention | NA | NA | P = 0.62 ‐12 (95% CI ‐43 to 19) |
|||||
Weekends | Baseline | 150 | 180 | ‐ | ||||
End of intervention | NA | NA | P = 0.42 ‐15 (95% CI ‐58 to 27) |
|||||
Lubans 2009 | Baseline | 106 boys and girls | 150 | 131.4 | NS | Sedentary behaviors were assessed using a questionnaire. The items were adapted from the Adolescent Sedentary Activity Questionnaire used in the NSW Schools Physical Activity and Nutrition Study (SPANS) | ||
Follow up (6 months) | 124.8 | 135.6 | NS | |||||
Neumark‐Sztainer 2009 | Baseline | 96 boys and girls | NA | NA | NS | Children were asked on one average weekday and Saturday or Sunday, how many hours are spent watching TV/videos; 7 response options ranging from 0 to 6+ hours | ||
End of intervention | 136.8 | 140.4 | P = 0.857 | |||||
Neumark‐Sztainer 2010 | Baseline | 336 adolescent girls | 168 | 144 | NS | TV viewing for 30 min blocks/day. Overall there was a change in sedentary behaviors, but not for TV viewing | ||
Follow‐up (5 months post‐intervention) | 137.4 | 140.4 | P = 0.883 | |||||
Peralta 2009 | Baseline | 32 boys | 387 | 315 | NS | Time spent in small screen recreation on weekends was assessed using the Adolescent Sedentary Activities Questionnaire. Participants were asked to report (in hours) TV viewing, video viewing, video game, computer game/Internet use, and computer use for homework | ||
Follow up (6 months) | 285 | 287.7 | P = 0.56 12 (95% CI ‐306 to 168) |
|||||
Robinson 1999 | Child report | TV | Baseline | 192 boys and girls | 132 | 132.8 | ‐ | Self‐reported time spent in sedentary activities |
End of intervention | 77.1 | 124.3 | P < 0.001 | |||||
Videotapes | Baseline | 40.3 | 47.1 | ‐ | ||||
End of intervention | 30 | 44.6 | NS | |||||
Video games | Baseline | 22.3 | 33.4 | ‐ | ||||
End of intervention | 11.4 | 36 | P = 0.01 | |||||
Other sedentary behaviors | Baseline | 40.3 | 38.6 | ‐ | ||||
End of intervention | 32.6 | 35.1 | NS | |||||
Parental report | TV | Baseline | 102.9 | 128.6 | ‐ | |||
End of intervention | 77.1 | 128.6 | P < 0.001 | |||||
Videotapes | Baseline | 42.9 | 37.7 | ‐ | ||||
End of intervention | 33.1 | 33.5 | NS | |||||
Video games | Baseline | 15.4 | 23.1 | ‐ | ||||
End of intervention | 12 | 22.3 | NS | |||||
Other sedentary behaviors | Baseline | 385.7 | 342.9 | ‐ | ||||
End of intervention | 351.4 | 368.6 | NS | |||||
Salmon 2008 | Intervention 1 | Baseline | 268 boys and girls | NA | NA | ‐ | Child self‐report time (hours/minutes) engaged in TV viewing, computer use and playing electronic games. Each of these variables was summed and divided by 7 to calculate average minutes per day Baseline data available for boys and girls; however, not available for whole sample. Results only available post intervention for whole sample. Statistically significant effect observed for Behavior Modification arm, in favor of the control group |
|
Follow‐up (12 months) | NA | NA | NS | |||||
Intervention 2 | Baseline | NA | NA | ‐ | ||||
Follow‐up (12 months) | NA | NA | P < 0.05 (BM) |
|||||
Intervention 3 | Baseline | NA | NA | ‐ | ||||
Follow‐up (12 months) | NA | NA | 240 (95% CI 28 to 452) | |||||
Simon 2004 | % time in high sedentary activities | Baseline | 954 adolescent boys and girls | 34% | 27% | ‐ | Self‐reported time spent in sedentary activities such as TV viewing and video games. High sedentary behaviour ≥ 3 h/day TV viewing and computer/video games | |
During intervention (6 months) | 28% | 36% | P < 0.0001 OR 0.49 (95% CI 0.35 to 0.69) | |||||
Minutes of TV viewing and computer/ video games | Baseline | 108 | 104 | ‐ | ||||
End of intervention (year 4) | 88 | 99 | P < 0.02 ‐16 (95% CI ‐29 to ‐3) |
|||||
Singh 2009 | Boys | Baseline | 875 boys and girls | 268 | 294 | NA | Screen‐viewing behavior (TV viewing and computer use), min/d assessed using a questionnaire pre tested for clarity and length among adolescents not participating in the study | |
End of intervention Follow‐up (20 months) | 258 | 278 | P = 0.05 ‐25 (95% CI ‐50 to ‐0.3) |
|||||
Girls | Baseline | 212 | 250 | NA | ||||
End of intervention Follow‐up (20 months) | 258 | 248 | NS ‐2 (95% CI ‐9 to 5) |
|||||
Webber 2008 | Baseline | 36 schools all girls |
456.5 | 458 | NS ‐1.5 (95% CI ‐11 to 8) | Minutes of sedentary behavior defined as the number of minutes with less than light activity | ||
End of intervention (year 2) | 511 | 514 | NS ‐3.5 (95% CI ‐11 to 4) |
|||||
Program Champion– directed intervention (year 3) | 524 | 533 | P < 0.05 ‐8 (95% CI ‐17 to 0) |
|||||
Williamson 2007 | Baseline | 586 boys and girls | HEE NA |
ADT NA |
The Self‐Administered Physical Activity Checklist (SAPAC) 34 is a 29‐item self‐report, 1‐day recall of physical and selected sedentary activities using a checklist format. The SAPAC was administered to small groups of students in a classroom setting. Self‐reported data from the SAPAC were summarized to measure minutes in sedentary pursuits | |||
End of intervention (18 months) | 4 | ‐20 | P = 0.4864 | |||||
CI: confidence interval; NA: not acknowledged; NS: not significant; OR: odds ratio; TV: television; NSW: New South Wales; h/day: hours per day. |