Characteristic Study ID |
Measurement period | Study population | Intervention group | Control group | Overall effect | Comments | ||
Angelopoulos 2009 | Baseline | 646 boys and girls | 73 | 74 | NS | BP was measured in the right arm with the subject seated and quiet after a 5‐min rest, using a validated automated sphygmomanometer (Omron M5i Blood Pressure Monitor) | ||
End of intervention (12 months) | 73 | 76 | P = 0.005 | |||||
Bayne‐Smith 2004 | Baseline | 442 girls | 71 | 70 | Measured after 5 to 15 min of rest in a seated position by the auscultatory method from the right arm at heart level. The second of two measurements was used | |||
End of intervention | 68 | 70 | P < 0.001 | |||||
Burke 1998 | Standard PE program | Boys | Baseline | 720 boys and girls | NA | NA | BP measured using Dinamp. An initial measurement was taken and after a 5‐min rest period in the sitting position, 3 further measurements were taken at 1 minute intervals. The average of the latter 3 measurements was used All measures of diastolic BP increased over time and results tended to favor the control group, except for high risk girls attending the standard PE program |
|
End of intervention | NA | NA | NS | |||||
Girls | Baseline | NA | NA | |||||
End of intervention | NA | NA | P < 0.05 | |||||
Enriched PE program | Boys | Baseline | NA | NA | ||||
End of intervention | NA | NA | NS | |||||
Girls | Baseline | NA | NA | |||||
End of intervention | NA | NA | NS | |||||
Bush 1989 | Baseline | 431 boys and girls | 73 | 71 | P < 0.001 | 3 resting BP measurements were taken with a standard mercury sphygmomanometer read to the nearest mm, with the child seated. An average of the 2nd and 3rd readings were used Positive treatment effects prolonged throughout intervention period |
||
During intervention (year 1) | 67 | 70 | P < 0.000 | |||||
During intervention (year 2) | 64 | 68 | P < 0.000 | |||||
During intervention (year 3) | 57 | 61 | P < 0.000 | |||||
End of intervention | 59 | 61 | P < 0.009 | |||||
Ewart 1998 | Baseline | 88 adolescent girls | 58 | 60 | NS | BP was measured after 15 min in a sitting position. The average of 6 readings was used to assess baseline resting pressure. Same procedure was used at follow‐up. | ||
End of intervention | 57 | 59 | NS | |||||
Kriemler 2010 | Baseline | 502 boys and girls | 62 | 61 | NA | BP was assessed after a rest period of 5 min at the right arm based on recommendations of the American Heart Association. An automated oscillograph was used in order to reduce inter‐observer variability. BP was measured 5 times and the mean of the 3 measurements with the smallest variation was taken | ||
End of intervention | 60 | 61 | P = 0.28 −0.1 (95% CI −0.4 to 0.1) |
|||||
Luepker 1996 | Baseline | 4019 boys and girls | 54 | 53 | P < 0.93 | 5 recordings (1 min apart) were obtained after a 5 min rest period using the Dinamap automatic BP device. The average of the last 3 readings was used | ||
End of intervention (year 3) | 56 | 56 | P < 0.66 | |||||
Martinez 2008 | Boys | Baseline | 1044 boys and girls | 63 | 66 | P = 0.007 | After a 5‐min rest, 3 BP readings were taken at 2‐min intervals. BP was obtained with an OMRON M5‐I automatic sphygmomanometer using 3 cuffs sized for arm circumference. The mean of the 3 BP readings was used in the analyses | |
End of intervention (9 months) |
63 | 62.5 | P = 0.03 1.6 (95% CI 0.2 to 2.9) |
|||||
Girls | Baseline | 65 | 67 | P = 0.001 | ||||
End of intervention (9 months) |
63 | 64 | P = 0.85 0.1 (95% CI ‐1.4 to 1.2) |
|||||
McManus 2008 | Intervention 1 | Baseline End of intervention (6 months) |
193 boys and girls | 56 | 54 | Diastolic BP was measured manually using a paediatric cuff after 15 min of supine rest | ||
End of intervention (6 months) | 60 | 57 | NS | |||||
Intervention 2 | Baseline | 58 | 54 | |||||
End of intervention (6 months) | 60 | 57 | NS | |||||
Reed 2008 | Baseline | 514 boys and girls | 63 | 60 | NA | Duplicate measurements were taken on the left arm using an automated sphygmomanometer and an appropriately sized cuff after 5 to 10 min rest in a supine position The lowest systolic and diastolic BP (mm Hg) were recorded |
||
End of intervention | 63 | 65 | NS | |||||
Simon 2004 | Baseline | 954 adolescent males and females | 65 | 64 | Diastolic BP was measured on seated children, after a 5‐min rest, using a fully automatic BP monitor and an adapted cuff size. | |||
End of intervention (year 4) | 67 | 66 | P = 0.60 ‐0.5 (95% CI ‐2 to 1) |
|||||
Stephens 1998 | Baseline | 90 boys and girls | 58 | 58 | ||||
End of intervention | 50 | 50 | NS | |||||
Walter 1988 | Westchester | Baseline | 3388 boys and girls | 70 | 73 | NS | BP was measured in the seated position using the right arm using a Baum mercury sphygmomanometer 3 times. The average of the 3 measures was used | |
End of intervention | 70 | 73 | NS | |||||
Bronx | Baseline | 74 | 73 | NS | ||||
End of intervention | 73 | 73 | NS | |||||
Walther 2009 | Baseline | 182 boys and girls | 63 | 65 | NS | |||
End of intervention (year 1) | 54 | 54 | P = 0.937 0 (95% CI ‐3 to 3) |
|||||
Wang 2008 | Baseline | 316 boys and girls | 66 | 66 | NS | The biological measurements were made in a mobile laboratory that was brought to the school sites. Diastolic BP was measured with a Dinamap. Subjects sat quietly for 5 min, 5 measurements were taken at 1‐min intervals, and the mean of the last 3 measurements was used | ||
End of intervention | 63 | 65 | P = 0.41 ‐1 (95% CI ‐4 to 2) |
|||||
Young 2006 | Baseline | 210 adolescent girls | 60 | 59 | ||||
End of intervention (1 year) | 58 | 57 | NS P = 0.49 |
|||||
CI: confidence interval; NA: not acknowledged; NS: not significant; BP: blood pressure; PE: physical education. |