Skip to main content
. 2013 Feb 28;2013(2):CD007651. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD007651.pub2
Characteristic
Study ID
Measurement period Study population Intervention group Control group Overall effect Comments
Bayne‐Smith 2004 Baseline 442 girls 160 154 A Reflotron reflectance photometer measured total serum cholesterol.
End of intervention 151 150 NS
Bush 1989 Baseline 431 boys and girls 180 175 P < 0.01 Nonfasting blood samples were taken using venipuncture
Treatment effect favors intervention group but not statistically significant
During intervention (year 1) 187 189 P < 0.02
During intervention (year 2) 189 189 P = 0.418
During intervention (year 3) 171 167 P = 0.432
End of intervention (year 4) 177 180 P = 0.348
Luepker 1996 Baseline 4019 boys and girls 4.39 4.41 P = 0.64 Nonfasting blood samples were obtained via venipuncture and analyzed for total cholesterol.
End of intervention (year 3) 4.15 4.14 P = 0.21
Martinez 2008 Boys Baseline 1044 boys and girls 169 171 P = 0.48 12‐hour‐fasting blood samples were obtained under standardized conditions from the cubital vein in Vacutainer serum‐gel‐separator tubes. Samples were processed within 60 min of drawing
End of intervention
(9 months)
163 165 P = 0.54
1 (95% CI ‐2 to 4)
Girls Baseline 169 169 NS
End of intervention
(9 months)
165 163 P = 0.78
1 (95% CI ‐3 to 4)
Reed 2008 Baseline 514 boys and girls 4.3 4.5 NS Intravenous samples were taken from the antecubital vein between 8:00 AM and 9:30 AM, after an overnight fast. A 10 mL sample was taken by a nurse and stored on ice in a serum separator tube. Blood was separated within 30 min and then stored at ‐80 °C
End of intervention 4.1 4.3 NS
Simon 2004 Baseline 954 adolescent males and females 158 153 Subjects are asked to fast for a minimum of 10 h before the blood sampling, which was performed in the morning, before the medical examination, with minimal venous stasis. All samples were processed within 3 h of sampling and the serum and plasma samples were aliquoted for immediate analysis or long‐term storage at ‐80 °C until assay
End of intervention (year 4) 168 160 P = 0.15
3 (95% CI ‐1 to 6)
Walter 1988 Westchester Baseline 3388 boys and girls 169 166 Nonfasting blood samples were taken to measure total cholesterol
End of intervention 167 166 P < 0.05
Bronx Baseline 174 170
End of intervention 171 168 NS
Walther 2009 Baseline 182 boys and girls 4.2 4.26 NS Peripheral blood samples were obtained before the specific tests were performed in all pupils. Technicians were blinded for group assignments
End of intervention (year 1) 4.19 4.12 P = 0.370
0.11(‐0.13 to 0.35)
Wang 2008 Baseline 316 boys and girls 166 161 NS The biological measurements were made in a mobile laboratory that was brought to the school sites. Non‐fasting total cholesterol were measured with a Cholestech LDX system
End of intervention 172 169 P = 0.94
0 (95% CI ‐6 to 6)
Young 2006 Baseline 210 adolescent girls 155 161
End of intervention (1 year) 155 163 P = 0.43
CI: confidence interval; NA: not acknowledged; NS: not significant; mL: millilitres.