Table 1.
Ref. | Study design | Cell source | Subject | Treatment group | Control group | Extraction method | Cell treatment | Delivery method | Follow-up duration (wk) | Results |
Hei et al[47], 2016 | Case Control | Human | Murine | 20 BDNF-transfected UCMSCs; 20 UCMSCs only | 20 PBS | Human umbilical vein obtained immediately after delivery | UCMSCs were expanded in keratinocyte-serum free medium with various growth factors. Passage 5 UCMSCs were transfected with adenovirus vector containing BDNF | Xenogenic transplantation into crushed left sciatic nerve | 4 | Significant improvement in SFI, axon count, axon density, and nerve regeneration in both treated groups. BDNF-loaded UCMSCs showed greater improvements in the above metrics than the UCMSC group |
Sung et al[46], 2012 | Case Control | Human | Murine | 18 UCMSCs | 18 PBS | Human umbilical vein obtained immediately after delivery | UCMSCs were culture-expanded in growth factors. Passage 5 UCMSCs were labelled with PKH26 fluorescent cell linker | Xenogenic transplantation into crushed sciatic nerve | 4 | Significant improvement in SFI, axon density and axon regeneration in UCMSCs group compared to control. Increased BDNF and tyrosine kinase receptor B mRNA compared to control |
Gartner et al[48], 2012 | Case Control | Human | Murine | 6 undifferentiated UCMSCs + PLC; 7 differentiated UCMSCs + PLC; 7 UCMSCs only | 6 injury only; 7 injury repaired with PLC only; 6 without injury | UCMSCs from human umbilical cord Wharton’s jelly matrix purchased from third-party source (PromoCell GmbH) | Passage 5 UCMSCs were supplemented with bovine foetal serum. UCMSCs were treated with neurogenic media and differentiated into neuroglial-like cells | Xenogenic transplantation into right sciatic nerve lesion (3 mm) crushed with non-serrated clamp | 12 | Significant improvement in both undifferentiated and differentiated UCMSCs groups in terms of SFI, EPT, WRL as well as myelin sheath thickness compared to all controls |
Gartner et al[49], 2012 | Case Control | Human | Murine | 6 UCMSCs only; 6 undifferentiated USMSCs + Chitosan type III | 6 negative control; 6 wrapped in Chitosan type III | UCMSCs from human umbilical cord Wharton’s jelly matrix purchased from third-party source (PromoCell GmbH) | Passage 5 UCMSCs were loaded on Chitosan type III biomaterial scaffold | Xenogenic transplantation into crushed right sciatic nerve lesion | 12 | Significant improvement in muscle force deficit and axonal regrowth in UCMSC Chitosan type III group compared to controls |
Xia et al[54], 2015 | Case Control | Human | Murine | 40 UCMSCs | 40 saline solution; 40 untreated rats | Human umbilical cord blood plasma obtained from different individuals with identical blood type | UCMSCs were culture-expanded in normal MSC media. Number of passage was not specified | Intravascular injection into left femoral artery of rat with streptozotocin induced diabetic foot ulcer | 2 | Significant improvement in restoring femoral nerve conduction in UCMSCs group compared to control groups at 3 days, 1 wk and 2 wk |
UCMSCs: Umbilical cord derived mesenchymal stem cells; BDNF: Brain-derived neurotrophic factor; SFI: Sciatic function index; PBS: Phosphate buffered saline; PLC: Poly (DL-lactide-ε-caprolactone); WRL: Withdrawal reflex latency; EPT: Extensor postural thrust.