3.15. Analysis.
Comparison 3: Antenatal pelvic floor muscle training (PFMT) versus control for (mixed) prevention or treatment of incontinence, Outcome 15: Self‐reported measures of pelvic floor dysfunction
Self‐reported measures of pelvic floor dysfunction | ||||
Study | Outcome measure | PFMT data | Control data | Difference |
PFMT versus no PFMT | ||||
Ko 2011 | UDI‐6 (0‐100, 100 worse) | Mean 3.44, SD 3.26, n = 150 in late pregnancy; Mean 0.81, SD 1.36, n = 150 at 0‐3 months postpartum; Mean 0.35, SD 0.84, n =150 at > 3‐6 months postpartum | Mean 4.66, SD 3.32, n = 150 in late pregnancy; Mean 1.54, SD 1.59, n = 150 at 0‐3 months postpartum; Mean 0.86, SD 1.14, n = 150 at > 3‐6 months postpartum | Mean difference ‐1.22 (95% CI ‐1.96 to ‐0.48) in late pregnancy; Mean difference ‐0.73 (95% CI ‐1.06 to ‐0.40) at 0‐3 months' postpartum; Mean difference ‐0.51 (95% CI ‐0.74 to ‐0.28) at > 3‐6 months postpartum |
Sut 2016 | UDI‐6 (0‐100, 100 worse) |
Mean 46.9, SD 8.7, n = 30 in late pregnancy; Mean 34.1, SD 6.6, n = 30 at early postpartum | Mean 44.1, SD 8.7, n=30 in late pregnancy; Mean 34.0, SD 8.2, n=30 at 0‐3 months' postpartum | Mean difference 2.8 (95% CI ‐1.60 to 7.20) in late pregnancy; Mean difference 0.1 (95% CI ‐3.67 to 3.87) at 0‐3 months' postpartum |
Overactive bladder questionnaire (OAB‐q) total score (0‐100, 100 better) |
Mean 85.7, SD 13.5, n = 30 in late pregnancy; Mean 97.2, SD 8.7, n = 30 at early postpartum | Mean 90.0, SD 13.6, n = 30 in late pregnancy; Mean 97.6, SD 6.3, n = 30 at 0‐3 months' postpartum | Mean difference ‐4.3 (95% CI ‐11.16 to 2.56) in late pregnancy; Mean difference ‐0.4 (95% CI ‐4.24 to 3.44) at 0‐3 months' postpartum | |
Szumilewicz 2019 | IIQ‐7 (0‐100; 100 worse) | Mean percentage change 0.20, SD 7.58%, n = 70 in late pregnancy | Mean percentage change 0.12, SD 0.93%, n = 27 in late pregnancy | Mean difference 0.8 (95% CI ‐1.73 to 1.89) |
PFMT versus usual care | ||||
Fritel 2015 | Female Pelvic Floor Questionnaire (FPFQ) bladder score (0‐10, 10 worse) | Mean 1.7, SD 1.3, n = 112 in late pregnancy; Mean 0.8, SD 0.9, n = 105 at 0‐3 months postpartum; Mean 0.9, SD 1.1, n = 94 at > 6‐12 months postpartum | Mean 2.0, SD 1.4, n = 111 in late pregnancy; Mean 0.9, SD 1.0, n = 107 at 0‐3 months postpartum; Mean 1.0, SD 1.1, n = 97 at > 6‐12 months postpartum | Mean difference ‐0.30 (95% CI ‐0.65 to 0.05) in late pregnancy; Mean difference ‐0.10 (95% CI ‐0.36 to 0.16) at 0‐3 months postpartum; Mean difference ‐0.10 (95% CI ‐0.41 to ‐0.12) at > 6‐12 months postpartum |
FPFQ bowel score (0‐10) | Mean 1.3, SD 1.1, n = 112 in late pregnancy; Mean 1.2, SD 1.2, n = 104 at 0‐3 months postpartum; Mean 1.0, SD 1.0, n = 94 at > 6‐12 months postpartum | Mean 1.4, SD 1.1, n = 112 in late pregnancy; Mean 1.4, SD 1.2, n = 107 at 0‐3 months postpartum; Mean 1.1, SD 1.0, n = 97 > 6‐12 months postpartum | Mean difference ‐0.10 (95% CI ‐0.39 to ‐0.19) in late pregnancy; Mean difference ‐0.20 (95% CI ‐0.52 to 0.12) at 0‐3 months postpartum; Mean difference ‐0.10 (95% CI ‐0.38 to 0.18) at > 6‐12 months postpartum | |
Hughes 2001 | BFLUTs questionnaire: a negative effect on exercise in response to question "does incontinence affect physical activity?" | 47 of 585 at 6 months postpartum | 41 of 584 at 6 months postpartum | Relative risk 1.14 (95% CI 0.76 to 1.71) |
Hyakutake 2018 | PFDI‐20 total score (20 items; 0‐300, 300 worse) | Mean 27.8, SD 31.6, n = 37 at 6 weeks postpartum | Mean 35.5, SD 37.7, n = 37 at 6 weeks postpartum | Mean difference ‐7.70 (95% CI ‐23.55 to 8.15) at 6 weeks postpartum |
POPDI‐6 (prolapse subscale) (6 items; 0‐100, 100 worse) | Mean 6.6, SD 8.4, n = 37 at 6 weeks postpartum | Mean 5.9, SD 12.1, n = 37 at 6 weeks postpartum | Mean difference 0.70 (95% CI ‐4.05 to 5.45) at 6 weeks postpartum | |
Mørkved 2003 | Sexual satisfaction at 6 years post‐delivery | 34 of 94 | 17 of 94 | Relative risk 2.00 (95% CI 1.20 to 3.32) |
PFMT versus unspecified control | ||||
Dokmeci 2008 | UDI‐6 (6 items; 0‐100, 100 worse) | No data | No data | Authors stated that there was a significant decrease in scores between first trimester and third trimester and between third trimester and 6 weeks postpartum |
IIQ‐7 | No data | No data | ||