Table 2.
Outcome | Risk | Risk if there is no PoC test | Risk if PoC test is implemented | Risk Difference | Relevant Risk Mitigation Strategy |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
False negative COVID-19 | False negative is not able to be confirmed by the public health lab | 100% of COVID cases will continue to interact with the community actively spreading the infection as a test would not have occurred. | Up to 30% of cases tested could be a false negative | Risk is lower by completing PoC testing | Patient should be isolated and retested next day if there are clinical concerns for a false negative |
False negative that can be corrected by the public health laboratory | Could not occur as the public laboratory does not need to confirm its own result | The chances of this occurring are unknown but expected to be small with units listed in Table 1. | This should be small given the similar automated tests are used in the public hospital setting | Consider sending a proportion of negative samples to a public health laboratory for confirmation. | |
False positive COVID-19 | If a positive is identified and the public health lab is unable to confirm this | Could not occur as no confirmation test is done | Unnecessary diagnosis, further investigation and isolation Unnecessary intensity of clinical monitoring Stigma attached to having COVID-19 Initiating therapeutics assuming positive result |
False positive rates are expected to be small Treatment is currently only symptomatic treatment and isolation, no pharmacological risk currently |
Informed consent within the team prior to doing test Careful maintenance and cleaning of working space to limit contamination May require additional support from team doctor/mental health professional |
False positive that can be corrected by the public health laboratory | Could not occur | Consider probability that a low positive sample degrades prior to reference laboratory testing Confusion and distrust in PoC test |
Discordant PoC to public health laboratory results could occur. The chances of this occurring are unknown | Reference laboratory testing is a risk mitigation strategy Review for sources of contamination in testing workflow Complete additional negative quality controls Option of re-testing same individuals 24 hours later |