Table 4.
Subjects | Original data (a) | Spline data (b) | GAN up-sampling (c) | WGAN up-sampling (d) |
---|---|---|---|---|
AO-1 | 62.83 | 58.72 | 64.51 | 69.52 |
AO-2 | 53.12 | 51.67 | 52.83 | 55.61 |
AO-3 | 70.31 | 68.92 | 73.96 | 72.66 |
AO-4 | 75.26 | 71.78 | 73.96 | 80.99 |
AO-5 | 59.12 | 58.27 | 61.28 | 64.22 |
AO-6 | 74.22 | 70.30 | 73.96 | 76.82 |
AO-7 | 55.43 | 54.28 | 60.72 | 59.83 |
AO-8 | 58.27 | 55.42 | 59.82 | 59.73 |
AO-9 | 77.08 | 76.07 | 83.85 | 84.37 |
AO-10 | 68.49 | 68.78 | 75.26 | 70.57 |
AO-11 | 79.17 | 74.64 | 87.76 | 89.85 |
AO-12 | 73.44 | 66.15 | 66.67 | 75.53 |
AO-13 | 55.83 | 59.42 | 61.42 | 63.49 |
AO-14 | 61.82 | 55.23 | 63.83 | 65.72 |
AO-15 | 55.49 | 53.82 | 56.29 | 58.73 |
AO-16 | 62.42 | 57.59 | 63.86 | 65.82 |
AO-17 | 64.58 | 57.81 | 58.59 | 67.44 |
AO-18 | 53.28 | 53.28 | 55.87 | 57.89 |
AO-19 | 52.82 | 51.87 | 55.89 | 57.63 |
AO-20 | 63.83 | 62.57 | 68.59 | 67.83 |
AO-21 | 70.31 | 61.98 | 61.98 | 72.91 |
AO-22 | 57.55 | 55.73 | 57.29 | 59.37 |
AO-23 | 61.83 | 58.89 | 63.82 | 63.58 |
AO-24 | 59.27 | 58.73 | 62.82 | 63.93 |
AVG | 63.57 | 60.91 | 65.41 | 67.67 |
T-test | – | a vs. b | c vs. a | d vs. a |
p-value | – | **p <0.01 | *p <0.05 | **p <0.01 |
The bold text is the best performance.