Skip to main content
. 2009 Jul 8;2009(3):CD007303. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD007303.pub2
Overall survival in all cancer patients ESA arm Control arm ESA versus control  
Subgroups Patients events sample % events sample % HR 95% CI P value*
Patient level characteristics                    
Hb at baseline                    
Hb at baseline (continuous)                   0.75
Hb at baseline (cat 1)                   0.63
Hb ≤ 8 g/dL 791 176 448 39% 147 343 43% 1.08 0.87‐1.35  
Hb 8‐≤10 g/dL 3930 725 2222 33% 672 1708 39% 1.02 0.92‐1.14  
Hb 10‐≤12 g/dL 5004 967 2851 34% 777 2153 36% 1.11 1.01‐1.22  
Hb 12‐≤14 g/dL 2843 566 1433 39% 553 1410 39% 1.06 0.95‐1.20  
Hb >14 g/dL 839 155 428 36% 155 411 38% 0.94 0.75‐1.18  
Unknown 526 54 252 21% 46 274 17% 1.22 0.82‐1.82  
Hb at baseline (cat 2)                   0.83
Hb ≤ 8 g/dL 791 176 448 39% 147 343 43% 1.08 0.87‐1.35  
Hb 8‐≤9 g/dL 1319 256 742 35% 252 577 44% 1.05 0.88‐1.25  
Hb 9‐≤10 g/dL 2611 469 1480 32% 420 1131 37% 1.02 0.89‐1.16  
Hb 10‐≤11 g/dL 2927 542 1699 32% 414 1228 34% 1.16 1.02‐1.32  
Hb 11‐≤12 g/dL 2077 425 1152 37% 363 925 39% 1.06 0.92‐1.22  
Hb 12‐≤13 g/dL 1739 377 873 43% 371 866 43% 1.04 0.90‐1.20  
Hb 13‐≤14 g/dL 1104 189 560 34% 182 544 33% 1.12 0.91‐1.37  
Hb >14 g/dL 839 155 428 36% 155 411 38% 0.94 0.75‐1.18  
Unknown 526 54 252 21% 46 274 17% 1.23 0.83‐1.83  
Malignancy type                    
Tumour (cat. 1)                   0.23
Haematological malignancies 2403 378 1400 27% 286 1003 29% 1.19 1.02‐1.39  
Solid tumours 10795 2103 5848 36% 1916 4947 39% 1.04 0.98‐1.11  
Other 693 158 369 43% 145 324 45% 0.99 0.82‐1.20  
Missing / unknown 42 4 17 24% 3 25 12% 2.14 0.48‐9.62  
Tumour (cat. 2)                   0.21
Haematological malignancies 2403 378 1400 27% 286 1003 29% 1.18 1.01‐1.38  
Breast cancer 4302 563 2245 25% 481 2057 23% 1.13 1.00‐1.28  
Head and neck cancer 868 235 443 53% 208 425 49% 1.14 0.91‐1.42  
Lung cancer 3076 986 1618 61% 975 1458 67% 0.98 0.89‐1.07  
Gastrointestinal cancer 708 124 434 29% 103 274 38% 0.89 0.68‐1.16  
Gynaecological cancer 1399 115 842 14% 87 557 16% 1.13 0.85‐1.50  
Genitourinal cancer 442 80 266 30% 62 176 35% 1.24 0.89‐1.73  
Other 693 158 369 43% 145 324 45% 0.99 0.82‐1.20  
Missing / unknown 42 4 17 24% 3 25 12% 2.12 0.47‐9.50  
Sex                    
Male 5136 1323 2854 46% 1193 2282 52% 1.01 0.94‐1.10 0.15
Female 8797 1320 4780 28% 1157 4017 29% 1.10 1.02‐1.19  
Age                    
Age continuous                   0.38
Age categorical                   0.26
 < 18 years 123 0 55 0% 1 68 1% Not estimable Not estimable  
 ≥18‐35 years 346 37 191 19% 27 155 17% 0.89 0.54‐1.46  
 ≥35‐45 years 1343 196 745 26% 147 598 25% 1.02 0.82‐1.26  
 ≥45‐55 years 3010 536 1614 33% 439 1396 31% 1.16 1.03‐1.32  
 ≥55‐65 years 4193 818 2237 37% 793 1956 41% 1.01 0.91‐1.11  
 ≥65‐75 years 3517 780 1970 40% 711 1547 46% 1.04 0.94‐1.15  
 ≥75 years 1389 276 816 34% 231 573 40% 1.20 1.00‐1.43  
Missing 12 0 6 0% 1 6 17% Not estimable Not estimable  
Hct levels at baseline                    
Hct continuous                   0.90
Hct categorical                   0.03
≤ 23.5% 390 82 210 39% 55 180 31% 1.66 1.18‐2.34  
23.5‐≤ 29.4% 2788 476 1567 30% 479 1221 39% 0.94 0.83‐1.07  
29.4‐≤ 35.3% 4615 945 2692 35% 732 1923 38% 1.10 0.99‐1.21  
35.3‐≤ 41.2% 2458 579 1258 46% 558 1200 47% 1.07 0.95‐1.21  
> 41.2% 785 169 414 41% 165 371 44% 1.02 0.82‐1.26  
Missing / unknown 2897 392 1493 26% 361 1404 26% 1.08 0.93‐1.24  
                     
Serum Epo at baseline                    
Serum Epo continuous                   0.14
Serum Epo categorical                   0.81
< 25 mU/ml 1497 341 876 39% 309 621 50% 0.97 0.84‐1.14  
25‐100 mU/ml 2908 586 1643 36% 548 1265 43% 1.02 0.90‐1.14  
100‐200 mU/ml 740 187 451 41% 130 289 45% 1.10 0.88‐1.38  
200‐500 mU/ml 325 60 190 32% 51 135 38% 1.18 0.81‐1.72  
> 500 mU/ml 181 31 103 30% 22 78 28% 1.08 0.63‐1.88  
Unknown 8282 1438 4371 33% 1290 3911 33% 1.09 1.01‐1.17  
Performance score                    
ECOG categorical                   0.41
ECOG 0 3392 351 1808 19% 341 1584 22% 1.06 0.91‐1.23  
ECOG 1 4900 984 2779 35% 814 2121 38% 1.09 0.99‐1.20  
ECOG 2 1678 490 933 53% 433 745 58% 1.01 0.89‐1.15  
ECOG 3 139 48 77 62% 35 62 56% 1.18 0.76‐1.82  
ECOG 4 3 2 2 100% 0 1 0% Not estimable Not estimable  
ECOG missing 3821 768 2035 38% 727 1786 41% 1.02 0.93‐1.14  
ECOG dichotomous                   0.50
ECOG 0, 1, 2 10083 1847 5578 33% 1604 4505 36% 1.08 1.01‐1.15  
ECOG 3, 4 142 50 79 63% 35 63 56% 1.25 0.81‐1.93  
ECOG missing 3708 746 1977 38% 711 1731 41% 1.02 0.92‐1.13  
Body mass index                    
≤ 19 kg/m² 865 187 424 44% 195 441 44% 0.95 0.78‐1.17 0.72
19‐≤ 25 kg/m² 5487 1098 2964 37% 945 2523 37% 1.06 0.97‐1.15  
25‐≤ 30 kg/m² 3443 642 1864 34% 543 1579 34% 1.09 0.97‐1.22  
> 30 kg/m² 1650 250 867 29% 224 783 29% 1.03 0.86‐1.24  
Missing 2488 466 1515 31% 443 973 46% 1.10 0.97‐1.26  
History of thromboembolic events                    
Yes 561 128 318 40% 107 243 44% 1.03 0.80‐1.33 0.90
No 9059 1720 5044 34% 1509 4015 38% 1.05 0.98‐1.12  
Missing / not reported 4313 795 2272 35% 734 2041 36% 1.08 0.98‐1.20  
History of cardiovascular events                    
Yes 3593 758 2002 38% 648 1591 41% 1.07 0.96‐1.19 0.69
No 6729 1141 3700 31% 1010 3029 33% 1.04 0.96‐1.13  
Missing / not reported 3611 744 1932 39% 692 1679 41% 1.07 0.97‐1.19  
History of hypertension                    
Yes 2093 420 1219 34% 373 874 43% 1.01 0.88‐1.16 0.57
No 7527 1428 4143 34% 1243 3384 37% 1.06 0.98‐1.14  
Missing / not reported 4313 795 2272 35% 734 2041 36% 1.08 0.98‐1.20  
History of diabetes mellitus                    
Yes 709 163 372 44% 158 337 47% 1.05 0.84‐1.31 0.94
No 7316 1456 3927 37% 1250 3389 37% 1.06 0.98‐1.14  
Missing / not reported 5908 1024 3335 31% 942 2573 37% 1.06 0.97‐1.16  
Geographical region                    
Northern America 3569 490 2004 24% 470 1565 30% 1.11 0.98‐1.27 0.90
Northern, Western & Southern Europe 7440 1529 4030 38% 1322 3410 39% 1.05 0.98‐1.13  
Eastern Europe 1955 514 1030 50% 469 925 51% 1.03 0.91‐1.17  
Australia & New Zealand 342 40 216 19% 28 126 22% 1.08 0.66‐1.75  
Other 226 48 123 39% 46 103 45% 0.95 0.63‐1.43  
Missing / not reported 401 22 231 10% 15 170 9% 1.47 0.75‐2.89  
Tumour stage                    
Metastatic / advanced 8113 1918 4482 43% 1698 3631 47% 1.05 0.98‐1.12 0.86
Not metastatic / not advanced 4039 420 2116 20% 408 1923 21% 1.06 0.93‐1.22  
Missing / not reported 1781 305 1036 29% 244 745 33% 1.04 0.87‐1.23  
Planned Hb ceiling                    
Planned Hb ceiling (cat 1)                   0.40
≤Hb 13.0 g/dL 3043 437 1624 27% 399 1419 28% 1.09 0.95‐1.25  
Hb 13.0 ‐ ≤15.0 g/dL 10193 2019 5631 36% 1782 4562 39% 1.04 0.97‐1.11  
Hb >15.0 g/dL 494 159 259 61% 152 235 65% 1.21 0.97‐1.51  
Other 203 28 120 23% 17 83 20% 1.13 0.61‐2.07  
Planned Hb ceiling (cat 2)                   0.60
≤Hb 13.0 g/dL 3043 437 1624 27% 399 1419 28% 1.09 0.95‐1.25  
Hb 13.0 – ≤14.0 g/dL 6816 1142 3733 31% 1013 3083 33% 1.03 0.95‐1.13  
Hb 14.0 – ≤15.0 g/dL 3377 877 1898 46% 769 1479 52% 1.05 0.95‐1.15  
>Hb 15.0 g/dL 494 159 259 61% 152 235 65% 1.21 0.97‐1.51  
Other 203 28 120 23% 17 83 20% 1.13 0.61‐2.07  
Study level characteristics                    
Treatment population                    
Treatment population                    
Chemotherapy 10441 1888 5676 33% 1667 4765 35% 1.04 0.97‐1.11 0.11
Radiochemotherapy 737 204 368 55% 211 369 57% 0.91 0.75‐1.10  
Radiotherapy 799 220 408 54% 196 391 50% 1.17 0.96‐1.42  
Mixed 266 17 175 10% 7 91 8% 1.53 0.63‐3.69  
None 1690 314 1007 31% 269 683 39% 1.22 1.04‐1.44  
Treatment population                    
Chemotherapy 10441 1888 5676 33% 1667 4765 35% 1.04 0.97‐1.11 0.25
Radiotherapy / radiochemotherapy 1536 424 776 55% 407 760 54% 1.03 0.90‐1.18  
Mixed 266 17 175 10% 7 91 8% 1.53 0.63‐3.69  
None 1690 314 1007 31% 269 683 39% 1.22 1.04‐1.44  
Iron supplementation                    
Fixed iron supplementation 2589 468 1293 36% 467 1296 36% 1.00 0.87‐1.13 0.48
Iron supplementation as needed 11120 2075 6232 33% 1782 4888 36% 1.07 1.00‐1.14  
Other 224 100 109 92% 101 115 88% 1.17 0.89‐1.55  
Planned ESA treatment duration                    
Up to 8 weeks 415 55 256 21% 47 159 30% 1.09 0.74‐1.62 0.74
9‐16 weeks 4800 667 2738 24% 644 2062 31% 1.02 0.91‐1.14  
> 17 weeks 3269 816 1701 48% 747 1568 48% 1.11 1.00‐1.22  
Until end of chemo‐ or radiotherapy 5449 1105 2939 38% 912 2510 36% 1.05 0.96‐1.14  
Planned weekly ESA dosage                    
< 100 µg Darbepoetin or < 40000 IU Epoetin 4197 832 2297 36% 669 1900 35% 1.04 0.94‐1.15 0.88
= 100 µg Darbepoetin or = 40000 IU Epoetin 3081 557 1545 36% 536 1536 35% 1.08 0.96‐1.22  
> 100 µg Darbepoetin or > 40000 IU Epoetin 3845 876 2076 42% 808 1769 46% 1.08 0.98‐1.19  
Other 2810 378 1716 22% 337 1094 31% 1.02 0.88‐1.18  
Planned frequency of ESA application                  
Three times per week or more frequent 6131 1067 3458 31% 840 2673 31% 1.07 0.98‐1.18 0.07
Once per week 3948 911 1972 46% 886 1976 45% 1.06 0.97‐1.17  
Every second week or less frequent 3036 347 1795 19% 286 1241 23% 1.20 1.02‐1.40  
Other 818 318 409 78% 338 409 83% 0.90 0.77‐1.05  
Placebo controlled trial                    
Yes 7657 1578 4211 37% 1403 3446 41% 1.09 1.01‐1.17 0.29
No 6276 1065 3423 31% 947 2853 33% 1.02 0.93‐1.12  
Randomisation                    
Adequate 3882 739 2047 36% 636 1835 35% 1.07 0.96‐1.19 0.80
Unclear 10051 1904 5587 34% 1714 4464 38% 1.05 0.99‐1.13  
Concealment of allocation                    
Adequate 10595 2176 5839 37% 1901 4756 40% 1.07 1.00‐1.14 0.49
Unclear 3338 467 1795 26% 449 1543 29% 1.02 0.89‐1.16  
Endpoint survival                    
Primary endpoint 3116 732 1547 47% 715 1569 46% 1.02 0.92‐1.13 0.39
Secondary endpoint 4313 1164 2282 51% 985 2031 48% 1.04 0.96‐1.14  
Safety /adverse events 6504 747 3805 20% 650 2699 24% 1.13 1.01‐1.25  
Designed for long‐term follow‐up                    
Yes 8974 2213 4619 48% 1972 4355 45% 1.06 1.00‐1.13 0.64
No 4959 430 3015 14% 378 1944 19% 1.03 0.89‐1.18  
Year of last patient randomized                    
1990‐1994 1447 100 890 11% 70 557 13% 0.96 0.70‐1.31 0.13
1995‐1999 1725 312 1001 31% 224 724 31% 0.97 0.81‐1.16  
2000‐2004 7620 1453 4105 35% 1296 3515 37% 1.13 1.04‐1.21  
2005‐2006 3141 778 1638 47% 760 1503 51% 0.99 0.89‐1.09  
Source of data                    
Manufacturer 12229 2434 6789 36% 2151 5440 40% 1.06 1.00‐1.13 0.57
Clinical study group 1704 209 845 25% 199 859 23% 1.00 0.83‐1.22  
*P value for likelihood‐ratio test (test for interaction), patients with missing data are excluded from this test, analysis based on one‐stage Cox fixed‐effects model stratified by study
ESA= erythropoiesis‐stimulating agents