Table 1.
Study | Study design | Sample size | Study period | Population | Cognitive test | Vitamin D levels | Outcomes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Schneider et al. [25] | Longitudinal study | 13,044 | 20 years | Mean age 57 years From USA |
DWRT DSST, WFT |
Insufficiency 20–30 ng/ml Sufficiency > 30 ng/ml Deficiency < 20 ng/ml |
Multivariate-adjusted linear mixed effect model used for analysis. No significant association with cognitive decline deficient versus sufficient: –0.035 (95% CI – 0.104 to 0.033) and intermediate versus sufficient: –0.029 (95% CI – 0.080 to 0.023)). |
| |||||||
Olsson et al. [22] | Longitudinal study | 2,841 | 18 years | Mean age 68 years From Sweden |
MMSE | Deficient < 50 nmol/L Sufficient > 75 nmol/L |
Cox proportional hazards regression (95% CI: 0.59, 1.31) in men with plasma 25(OH)D concentrations 50 compared with 0.75 n·mol/L. (95% CI: 0.63, 1.32) for the lowest compared with highest tertiles of vitamin D intake. |
| |||||||
Feart et al. [21] | Longitudinal study | 916 | 12 years | Mean age 65 years and more From France |
MMSE Benton visual retention test Trail making test |
Sufficient > 50 nmol/L Insufficient 25–50 nmol/L Deficiency < 25 nmol/L |
Multivariate analysis Vitamin D deficiency and insuffiency had double the risk of all cause dementia with 95% CI (1.21–3.71) for deficiency and 95% CI (1.17–3.36) for insufficiency |
| |||||||
Beydoun et al. [26] | Longitudinal study | 1,803 | 10 years | Age (30–64 years) From USA White urban adults African-Americans |
MMSE CVLT TMT-B BVRT CDT DF-S and DFS-B AF |
Linear regression Higher aseline serum 25OHD was linked toa slower decline in verbal fluency (p < 0.001) Higher intake of vitamin D was associated with aslower rate of decline constructive ability (p < 0.001). Use of vitamin D supplements during follow-up was related to slower rate of decline in verbal fluency among older individuals. |
|
| |||||||
Goodwill et al. [27] | Longitudinal study | 252 | 10 years | Age (55–67 years) From Australia |
CVLT-11 TMT-B CERAD, |
Deficient < 25 nmol/L | One-way ANOVA and Pearson Chi square Vitamin D > 25n·mol/L performed better on verbal fluency (95% CI = 0.53, 4.40) and TMT-B time (95% CI = −32.86, −3.61), with higher executive function (95% CI: 0.44,2.37) These relationships persisted 10 years later in the follow-up |
| |||||||
Laughlin et al. [9] | Longitudinal study | 1,058 | 12 years | MMSE TMT Halstead–Reitan neuropsychological test Animal naming category test, fluency test |
MMSE TMT Halstead–Reitan neuropsychological test Animal naming category test, fluency test |
Insufficiency ˂ 30 ng/ml | Linear mixed effect regression model. Vitamin D insufficiency associated with poor performance on MMSE(p=0.013). No association found on follow-up |
| |||||||
Jorde et al. [23] | Longitudinal study | 4,624 | 13 years | Age 54.9 years From Norway |
MMSE | Continuous variable | Linear regression Association of low vitamin D and CI found in older, more than 65 years (p=0.001) at cross-sectional level; no association found on follow-up |
| |||||||
Moon et al. [24] | Longitudinal study | 412 | 5 years | Mean age 74 From Korea |
MMSE | Deficiency 25–49 nmol/L Severe deficiency ˂ 25nmol/L Sufficiency ˃ 50 nmol/L |
One-way ANOVA Severe Vitamin D deficiency was associated with future risk of MCI and dementia. 95% CI (1.46–14.8) |
| |||||||
Lam et al. [28] | Longitudinal study | 179 | — | Mean age 74 From Korea |
MMSE and RAVLT | 31-334.4 mol/L (mean 84.7 nmol/L) | Bayesian mixed model 25(OH)D levels were negatively associated |
MSE: Mini-Mental Status Examination, WFT: word fluency test, DSST: digit symbol substitution test, DWRT: delayed word recall test, and TMT: trial making test; MCI: mild cognitive impairment and RAVLT: Rey auditory verbal learning test; Consortium to Establish a Registry for Alzheimer's Disease (CERAD), California Verbal Learning Test Second Edition (CVLT-II), verbal fluency and trail making test-B (TMT-B), delayed free recall (DFR), digit span forward and backward tests (DS-F and DS-B), Benton Visual Retention Test (BVRT), animal fluency test (AF), Brief Test of Attention (BTA), and Clock Drawing Test (CDT).