Table 5.
Comparison of indirect and direct methods by laterality of AVVR
| Mitral regurgitation | Tricuspid regurgitation | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Spearman | WSRT |
Median Difference (IQR) |
Spearman | WSRT |
Median Difference (IQR) |
|
| VOL vs. AIMstat | ρ = 0.79 | p = 0.231 | 3.1% (− 2.0–6.0) | ρ = 0.58 | p = 0.078 | 8.1% (−2.7–19.0) |
| VOL vs. AIMtrack | ρ = 0.76 | p = 0.078 | 5.5% (− 0.6–10.6) | ρ = 0.61 | p = 0.036* | 11.1% (− 0.7–20.0) |
| VOL vs. JET | ρ = 0.66 | p = 0.349 | −7.0% (− 10.1–7.3) | ρ = 0.66 | p = 0.869 | −0.4% (− 7.1–8.2) |
| AIMstat vs. AIMtrack | ρ = 0.98 | p = 0.001* | 2.4% (1.1–4.8) | ρ = 0.98 | p = 0.004* | 1.6% (−0.3–3.8) |
| AIMstat vs. JET | ρ = 0.66 | p = 0.157 | −1.3% (− 14.5–4.2) | ρ = 0.85 | p = 0.014* | −4.5% (− 11.5–1.4) |
| AIMtrack vs. JET | ρ = 0.69 | p = 0.018* | −4.3% (− 15.0–1.1) | ρ = 0.85 | p = 0.001* | −6.4% (− 13.8 – − 1.2) |
| ICC | Paired T-Test |
Mean Difference (± SD) |
ICC | Paired T-Test |
Mean Difference (± SD) |
|
| Intra-observer reliability | ||||||
| VOL | 0.996 | p = 0.844 | −0.12% ± 1.64 | 0.962 | p = 0.995 | 0.01% ± 7.01 |
| AIMstat | 0.918 | p = 0.397 | 1.71% ± 5.37 | 0.989 | p = 0.472 | −0.89% ± 4.23 |
| AIMtrack | 0.931 | p = 0.652 | 0.96% ± 5.76 | 0.990 | p = 0.467 | −0.93% ± 4.27 |
| JET | 0.935 | p = 0.591 | 1.42% ± 7.18 | 0.995 | p = 0.074 | −1.10% ± 1.92 |
| Inter-observer reliability | ||||||
| VOL | 0.909 | p = 0.133 | −3.60% ± 5.98 | 0.981 | p = 0.232 | −1.62% ± 4.42 |
| AIMstat | 0.902 | p = 0.751 | 0.76% ± 6.51 | 0.959 | p = 0.269 | 2.64% ± 7.85 |
| AIMtrack | 0.973 | p = 0.586 | −0.70% ± 3.45 | 0.957 | p = 0.353 | 2.44% ± 8.70 |
| JET | 0.928 | p = 0.644 | 1.25% ± 7.35 | 0.954 | p = 0.238 | 2.36% ± 6.54 |
An asterisk (*) denotes statistical significance defined as p < 0.05. VOL Volumetry method, AIMstat Annular inflow method by static plane, AIMtrack Annular inflow method by valve-tracking plane, JET Direct measurement of the atrioventricular regurgitant jet, ICC Intra-class correlation, SD Standard deviation, IQR Interquartile range, WSRT Wilcoxon signed rank test