TABLE 4.
Patients who underwent multiple surgeries grouped by initial MRI findings
| Surgery 1 | Surgery 2 | Surgery 3 | Further surgeries: invasive, pathology, reason for recurrence, resection | Seizure recurrence | ||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ID | Invasive | Pathology | Resection | Initial MRI | Invasive | Pathology | Reason for recurrence | Resection | Invasive | Pathology | Reason for recurrence | Resection | ||
| 1 | No | Unknown | TL | Cystic lesion | No | Gliosis | Unexplainable by prior findings | TL | SDE + depth | Gliosis | EEG finding elsewhere | TL | Seizure-free | |
| 2 | SDE | MCD | FL | MCD | SDE | Gliosis | Unexplainable by prior findings | FL | SEEG | MCD | EEG finding elsewhere | FL + insula | Seizure-free | |
| 3 | No | MCD | FL | MCD | No | MCD | MRI residual lesion | FL | No | NA | Unexplainable by prior findings | Callosotomy | Recurred | |
| 4 | SDE + depth | MCD | FL | MCD | No | MCD | Unexplainable by prior findings | FL | SDE + depth | MCD | Unexplainable by prior findings | FL | Recurred | |
| 5 | No | NA | TPO | MCD | Unknown | NA | MRI residual lesion | TPO | No | MCD | MRI residual lesion | TPO | Recurred | |
| 6 | No | Gliosis | TL | MTS | No | NA | MRI residual lesion | TL | SDE + depth | MTS | MRI residual lesion | TL + FL | Last surgery (total 6 surgeries): no invasive, MCD, EEG findings elsewhere, FL + PL | Recurred |
| 7 | No | MTS | TL | MTS | No | MTS | MRI residual lesion | TL | SDE | Gliosis | Unexplainable by prior findings | TL | Recurred | |
| 8 | No | MTS | TL | MTS | SDE | Gliosis | EEG finding elsewhere | FL + TL | SEEG | Gliosis | EEG finding elsewhere | TPO | Recurred | |
| 9 | No | MTS | TL | MTS | SDE | Gliosis | Unexplainable by prior findings | TL | SEEG | Gliosis | Unexplainable by prior findings | TL | 4th surgery: no invasive, pathology NA, EEG finding elsewhere, insula | Seizure-free |
| 10 | SEEG | MTS | TL | MTS | No | MTS | MRI residual lesion | TL | SEEG | MCD | Dual pathology | TL | Seizure-free | |
| 11 | Depth | NA | TL | NA | SDE | NA | unexplainable by prior findings | PL | SDE + depth | NA | EZ close to eloquent areas | PL | 4th surgery: SEEG, gliosis, unexplainable by prior findings, PO | Recurred |
| 12 | SDE | MCD | FL | Normal | SDE + depth | MCD | Unexplainable by prior findings | FL | SEEG | Gliosis | EEG finding elsewhere | TL + FL | 4th surgery: no invasive, nonspecific, unexplainable by prior findings, FL | Seizure-free |
| 13 | SDE | Nonspecific | FL + TL | Normal | No | Gliosis | EEG finding elsewhere | FL + TL | SEEG | Gliosis | EEG finding elsewhere | PO | Recurred | |
| 14 | No | Tumor | TL | Tumor | No | Tumor | MRI residual lesion | TL | No | Tumor | MRI residual lesion | TL | 4th surgery: no invasive, tumor, residual lesion, TL | Recurred |
| 15 | No | Tumor | TL | Tumor | No | Tumor | MRI residual lesion | TL | SDE | Tumor | MRI residual lesion | TL | 4th surgery: no invasive, gliosis, unexplainable by prior findings, TL | Recurred |
| 16 | No | Tumor | TL | Tumor | SDE | Gliosis | EEG finding elsewhere | TL + FL | SEEG | None | Unexplainable by prior findings | TL + FL | Recurred | |
| 17 | No | Tumor | TL | Tumor | SDE | Gliosis | unexplainable by prior findings | TL | SDE + depth | Gliosis | EEG finding elsewhere | TL + insula | 4th surgery: SEEG, gliosis, eloquent areas, TL | Recurred |
| 18 | No | Tumor | TPO | Tumor | No | Tumor | MRI residual lesion | TPO | No | Gliosis | Unexplainable by prior findings | TPO | Seizure-free | |
Abbreviations: depth, depth electrodes; EEG, electroencephalographic; EZ, epileptogenic zone; FL, frontal lobe; MCD, malformation of cortical development; MRI, magnetic resonance imaging; MTS, mesiotemporal sclerosis; NA, not available; PL, parietal lobe; PO, parietal-occipital; SDE, subdural grids; SEEG, stereo-EGG; TL, temporal lobe; TPO, temporal-parietal-occipital.