TABLE 1.
Study | Mean | Maximum | |||||
size | MRD | sensitivity | |||||
Author | Year | Key findings | Disease state | Technique | (n) | coverage | (VAF) |
Klco | 2015 | Clearance of disease-specific mutations at 30 days post induction correlated with better EFS and OS | AML, post induction | WES or WGS, and amplicon-based sequencing with paired normal tissue | 50 | 543X (exome) 14,780X (amplicon) | 2.5% |
Jongen- Lavrencic | 2018 | Persistence of non-“DTA” mutations correlated with decreased RFS and OS. Combining NGS and flow MRD data produced strong correlations with outcome when methods were concordant and defined an intermediate prognosis group when methods were discordant | AML, post induction | 54 Gene tumor-only NGS panel with position-based error correction | 482 | Not stated | 0.02% |
Morita | 2018 | Patients with clearance of disease-associated mutations (<1% VAF) at 30 days post induction had better OS and better EFS after multivariate analysis; this correlation was strengthened by the exclusion of “DTA mutations” from the analysis | AML, post induction | 295 Gene tumor only NGS panel | 131 | 575X | <1.0% |
Thol | 2018 | Detection of disease-associated mutations post-transplant was associated with higher incidence of relapse, but no difference in OS | AML, pre- transplant | 46 Gene custom amplicon panel with UMI-based error correction | 116 | 6,100x | 0.02% |
Kim | 2018 | MRD positive patients had a higher incidence of relapse and lower OS | AML, post-transplant | 84 Gene NGS panel with paired normal T-cells and position-based error correction | 104 | 1726X | 0.02% |
Balagopal | 2019 | Found evidence of MRD in 18/30 (60%) of post-transplant AML patients who showed no evidence of disease by standard engraftment studies | AML, post-transplant | 22 Gene panel with UMI-based error correction | 30 | >10,000X | 0.1% |
Press | 2019 | NGS MRD positive pre-transplant patients had higher risk of relapse in multivariate analysis | AML, pre- transplant | 42 Gene panel, coverage-based error correction | 42 | 1900x | 0.5% |
Hourigan | 2019 | NGS MRD positive pre-transplant patients with reduced-intensity conditioning had increased relapse rates, decreased overall survival, and decreased OS compared to patients who underwent myeloablative conditioning | AML, pre- transplant | 13 Gene panel with UMI-error correction run in peripheral blood samples. | 190 | >100,000x | 0.001% |
Abbreviations: EFS, event free survival; OS, overall survival; NGS, next generation sequencing; WES, whole exome sequencing; WGS, whole genome sequencing; RFS, relapse free survival; MRD, measurable residual disease; UMI, unique molecular identifier.