Skip to main content
. 2020 May 15;15(5):e0232900. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0232900

Table 1. Most significant SNPs identified through case-control (bilaterally deaf vs. controls) genome-wide association studies in Dalmatians, Australian cattle dogs, and English setters.

Breed N CFA bp SNP ID af all (deaf/controls) pvea beta P-value
Dalmatians North America 20 deaf, 91 controls 30 37,235,914 BICF2P1106247 0.104 (0.300/0.060) 0.167 -0.353 7.25×10−6*
30 33,816,254 BICF2P113616 0.333 (0.625/0.269) 0.155 -0.222 1.60×10−5*
23 48,506,877 BICF2G630365393 0.441 (0.725/0.379) 0.150 -0.220 2.28×10−5*
30 22,647,163 BICF2G630405064 0.068 (0.200/0.038) 0.130 -0.408 8.93×10−5*
37 27,255,309 BICF2G630132623 0.243 (0.450/0.198) 0.122 -0.245 1.54×10−4*
Dalmatians UK 72 deaf, 43 controls 38 21,626,523 BICF2G63068103 0.152 (0.083/0.267) 0.127 0.350 8.22×10−5*
Australian cattle dogs 16 deaf, 61 controls 3 37,793,043 BICF2G630338450 0.299 (0.656/0.205) 0.277 -0.313 6.46×10−7**
3 17,067,881 BICF2G630703558 0.117 (0.344/0.057) 0.229 -0.408 8.45×10−6*
16 36,220,138 BICF2P1229299 0.091 (0.281/0.041) 0.213 -0.453 1.91×10−5*
6 10,527,823 BICF2S23125774 0.240 (0.500/0.172) 0.212 -0.330 2.05×10−5*
17 18,275,241 chr17_18275241 0.110 (0.313/0.057) 0.187 -0.377 6.96×10−5*
6 75,622,113 BICF2P481353 0.071 (0.219/0.033) 0.184 -0.505 8.37×10−5*
22 48,747,165 BICF2G630335709 0.494 (0.188/0.574) 0.181 0.239 9.66×10−5*
9 8,460,580 BICF2S23511312 0.130 (0.313/0.082) 0.178 -0.395 1.09×10−4*
24 47,255,337 TIGRP2P322787_rs9139922 0.136 (0.344/0.082) 0.176 -0.344 1.19×10−4*
English setters 11 deaf, 39 controls 39 111,315,267 BICF2G6304357 0.220 (0.421/0.154) 0.192 -0.276 1.20×10−3

af = allele frequency, beta = effect size, pve = proportion of variance explained

All bp positions are listed in canFam3.1 assembly

aCalculated using output of GEMMA with equation pve = 1/(1+(N*(se(beta)^2)/beta^2) where N = sample size, se(beta) = standard error of beta. This equation is simplified from Shim et al. (2015) [38]

**Significant association using genome-wide threshold determined from unlinked SNPs

*Suggestive association using threshold determined from unlinked SNPs at the chromosome level