Skip to main content
. 2020 May 15;15(5):e0233206. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0233206

Table 6. Calculated Resting Energy Requirement (RER) and Maintenance Energy Requirement (MER) range for golden retrievers (n = 43) fed a non-Traditional Diet (NTD) and the difference in number of calories fed compared to calculated MER for a sedentary and active lifestyle.

Subject No. Weight (kg) BCS Diet Calculated RER (kcal/day) MER Range (kcal/day) % Difference in actual vs MER
Sedentary Active
1 25.91 5 1A 835 1170–1337 -21.00 -30.87
2 31.59 5 2A 933 1306–1492 * *
3A
3 28.64 5 3A 867 1213–1386 * *
3B
4A
4B
5A
5B
4 34.09 5 6A 988 1383–1580 * *
5 21.36 5 3A 696 974–1113 * *
3B
7A
6 22.73 4 8A 729 1020–1166 -13.93 -24.69
9A
7 29.09 5 3C 877 1228–1403 * *
7B
10A
8 28.59 5 11A 866 1212–1358 -24.90 -34.29
11B
9 27.23 4 6B 834 1168–1335 39.71 22.25
10 35.77 5 12A 1024 1433–1638 0.46 -12.10
11 28.18 5 5C 856 1199–1370 * *
12 26.82 5 13A 825 1155–1320 * *
13 23.64 4 14A 750 1051–1201 * *
14 35.45 5 15A 1017 1424–1627 -18.36 -28.57
16D
15 30.91 5 1B 918 1285–1468 -38.97 -46.60
16 27.27 4 6C 835 1170–1337 1.83 -10.90
17 33.18 5 7C 968 1355–1548 -25.90 -35.16
18 27.73 4 16A 846 1184–1353 -26.11 -35.34
19 25.00 4 16A 783 1096–1252 -4.17 -16.15
20 35.91 6 17A 1027 1438–1643 -36.59 -44.52
18A
18B
21 30.45 6 17A 907 1270–1452 -28.25 -37.22
18A
18B
22 30.00 5 19A 897 1256–1436 -46.51 -53.19
23 32.73 9 20A 958 1341–1532 * *
20B
20C
20D
20E
20F
21A
21B
24 26.36 5 16B 814 1140–1303 * *
16C
25 30.91 5 16B 918 1285–1468 * *
16C
26 31.36 5 20A 928 1299–1484 * *
20B
20C
20D
20E
20F
21A
21B
27 34.09 7 3D 988 1383–1580 * *
8B
22A
28 33.64 6 19A 978 1369–1564 * *
19B
19C
29 30.30 6 6B 904 1266–1446 -11.47 -22.53
30 35.45 5 23A 1017 1424–1627 -15.80 -26.32
31 34.45 5 16A 995 1394–1593 -49.77 -56.05
32 40.25 7 19C 1119 1566–1790 * *
19E
33 36.00 7 19D 1029 1440–1646 -18.14 -28.37
34 29.20 5 23A 879 1231–1407 -32.82 -41.22
24A
25A
35 34.09 6 5D 988 1383–1580 -33.46 -41.78
6D
36 25.45 5 5D 793 1111–1269 -17.16 -27.52
6D
37 36.36 5 1C 1037 1451–1659 -18.96 -29.09
38 40.45 6 26A 1123 1572–1797 * *
39 28.18 5 3E 856 1199–1370 * *
23B
40 37.73 7 1D 1066 1492–1705 -47.98 -54.49
41 35.00 6 19A 1007 1410–1612 7.22 -6.18
42 25.45 6 8C 793 1111–1269 -36.43 -44.38
43 38.64 7 27A 1085 1519–1736 -14.07 -24.81

List of individual weight, body condition score (BCS), diet brand and variety, calculated resting energy requirement (RER) in kilocalories per day (kcal/day), calculated maintenance energy requirement (MER) in kilocalories per day (kcal/day), and percent (%) difference in actual amount of diet fed (kcal/day) to calculated MER for group 2 diets. Maintenance energy requirements were listed as a range of RER multiplied by a factor of 1.4–1.6 to account for a less active or more active lifestyle, respectively. For dogs being fed multiple diets, % difference in actual vs MER was calculated as an average between the different diets.

* Information not available or dog received most of calories from other food sources

1 This value is an underestimate as only diets 23A and 24A were used to calculate % difference in actual vs MER for subject 34.

1A = ACANA Pacifica (dry)

1B = ACANA Meadowland (dry)

1C = ACANA Singles Lamb and Apple (dry)

1D = ACANA Grasslands (dry)

2A = Greentripe Xkaliber: Green Tripe, Heart, Tongue, Trachea and Ground Bone (raw)

3A = The Honest Kitchen Dehydrated–Grain Free Turkey Recipe (Embark)

3B = The Honest Kitchen Dehydrated–Whole Grain Turkey Recipe (Keen)

3C = The Honest Kitchen Dehydrated–Grain Free Fish Recipe (Zeal)

3D = The Honest Kitchen Dehydrated–Limited Ingredient Fish Recipe (Brave)

3E = The Honest Kitchen Dehydrated–Grain Free Fruit and Veggie Base Mix (Preference)

4A = Instinct by Nature’s Variety Original Grain-Free Recipe with Real Duck (dry)

4B = Instinct by Nature’s Variety Limited Ingredient Diet Grain-Free Recipe with Real Turkey (dry)

5A = Taste of the Wild High Prairie Canine Recipe with Roasted Bison and Roasted Venison (dry)

5B = Taste of the Wild Wetlands Canine Recipe with Roasted Fowl (dry)

5C = Taste of the Wild Pacific Stream Canine Recipe with Roasted Salmon (dry)

5D = Taste of the Wild Sierra Mountain Canine Recipe with Roasted Lamb (dry)

6A = Fromm Weight Management Gold (dry)

6B = Fromm Adult Gold (dry)

6C = Fromm Salmon a La Veg Recipe (dry)

6D = Fromm Lamb and Lentil Recipe (dry)

7A = Sport Dog Food Elite Grain Free Chicken Meal 30/14 (dry)

7B = Sport Dog Food Elite Grain Free Whitefish Meal 30/14 (dry)

7C = Sport Dog Food Working Dog–Grain and Peas Free Turkey Formula (dry)

8A = Nutri Source Pure Vita Duck and Oatmeal (dry)

8B = Nutri Source Pure Vita Salmon Entrée (canned)

8C = Nutri Source Weight Management Dog Food Chicken and Chicken Meal Protein (dry)

9A = Sojos Complete Turkey Recipe (raw)

10A = Stella and Chewy’s Freeze Dried Dinner Patties, Lamb and Venison Flavors (raw)

11A = Oma’s Pride Beef and Veggies (raw)

11B = Oma’s Pride Turkey and Veggies (raw)

12A = Annamaet Ultra Chicken Meal and Brown Rice (dry)

13A = Darwin’s Natural Selections Beef, Turkey and Pork (raw)

14A = Raw Bistro Dog Fare Grass-Fed Beef Entrée

15A = Earthborn Holistic Coastal Catch (dry)

16A = Natural Balance L.I.D. Limited Ingredient Diets Grain Free Potato and Duck Dry Dog Food Formula

16B = Natural Balance L.I.D. Limited Ingredient Diets Grain Free Sweet Potato and Fish Dry Dog Food Formula

16C = Natural Balance L.I.D. Limited Ingredient Diets Grain Free Chicken and Sweet Potato Canned Dog Formula

16D = Natural Balance L.I.D. Limited Ingredient Diets Grain Free Bison and Sweet Potato Dry Dog Food Formula

17A = Victor Grain Free Yukon River Canine (dry)

18A = Merrick Grain Free Wilderness Blend in Gravy (canned)

18B = Merrick Chunky Grain Free Big Texas Steak Tips Dinner in Gravy (canned)

19A = Kirkland Signature Nature’s Domain Salmon Meal and Sweet Potato Dog Food (dry)

19B = Kirkland Signature Nature’s Domain Beef Meal and Sweet Potato Dog Food (dry)

19C = Kirkland Signature Nature’s Domain Turkey Meal and Sweet Potato Dog Food (dry)

19D = Kirkland Signature Adult Formula Chicken, Rice and Vegetable Dog Food (dry)

19E = Kirkland Signature Nature’s Domain Turkey and Pea Stew for Dogs (canned)

20A = Top Quality Dog Food Beef HVM (raw)

20B = Top Quality Dog Food Chicken HVM (raw)

20C = Top Quality Dog Food Pork HVM (raw)

20D = Top Quality Dog Food Green Tripe Ground (raw)

20E = Top Quality Dog Food Green Tripe Chunks (raw)

20F = Top Quality Dog Food Beef with Tripe and Organ Meats (raw)

21A = K-9 Kravings Beef and Vegetables (raw)

21B = K-9 Kravings Chicken, Beef and Vegetables (raw)

22A = Canidae Grain Free Pure Ancestral Fish Formula Raw Coated Dry Dog Food

23A = Orijen Original Dog Food (dry)

23B = Orijen Tundra Dog Food (dry)

24A = Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula Lamb and Brown Rice Recipe (dry)

25A = Primal Freeze-Dried Nuggets, Beef and Duck Flavor (raw)

26A = Wellness Core Grain Free Large Breed (dry)

27A = Zignature Lamb Formula (dry)