Skip to main content
. 2020 May 15;10:8012. doi: 10.1038/s41598-020-64942-0

Table 4.

Accuracy, precision, recall, AUROC and F1-score for the methods tested with different hyperparameters evaluated by 10 times 5-fold Cross Validation (mean and standard deviation of the 10 times’ division).

(η,W,C,S) Accuracy Precision.OA Precision.Control
(F1,P1) 0.737 (0.025) 0.760 (0.032) 0.718 (0.023)
(F2,P1) 0.763 (0.050) 0.770 (0.060) 0.762 (0.053)
(F2,P2) (0.001,2,0.7,0.5) 0.793 (0.032) 0.793 (0.028) 0.797 (0.046)
(F2,P2) (0.001,1,0.7,0.5) 0.804 (0.022) 0.804 (0.020) 0.808 (0.038)
(F2,P2) (0.01, 2, 0.7,0.5) 0.807 (0.034) 0.804 (0.029) 0.812 (0.046)
(F2,P2) (0.01, 1, 0.7,0.5) 0.813 (0.023) 0.811 (0.022) 0.817 (0.032)
(F2,P2) (0.01,1,0.5,0.5) 0.814 (0.025) 0.807 (0.026) 0.822 (0.028)
(F2,P3) (0.01,1,0.7,0.5) 0.802 (0.039) 0796 (0.035]) 0.811 (0.054)
(F2,P3) (0.001,1,0.7,0.5) 0.800 (0.034) 0.795 (0.033) 0.807 (0.043)
(F2,P3) (0.01,2,0.7,0.5) 0.805 (0.044) 0.800 (0.039) 0.814 (0.058)
(F2,P3) (0.01,2,0.7,0.7) 0.805 (0.044) 0.800 (0.039) 0.814 (0.058)
(F2,P4) 0.795 (0.035) 0.790 (0.036) 0.802 (0.042)
(F2,P2+P3) (0.01,1,0.5,0.5)+ (0.01,2,0.7,0.5) 0.823 (0.029) 0.815 (0.033) 0.833 (0.035)
(η,W,C,S) Recall.OA Recall.Control AUC Mean.F1.Score
(F1,P1) 0.693 (0.030) 0.780 (0.038) 0.805 (0.026) 0.736 (0.025)
(F2,P1) 0.757 (0.072) 0.770 (0.080) 0.838 (0.024) 0.762 (0.051)
(F2,P2) (0.001,2,0.7,0.5) 0.796 (0.061) 0.791 (0.036) 0.858 (0.025) 0.793 (0.032)
(F2,P2) (0.001,1,0.7,0.5) 0.807 (0.053) 0.802 (0.030) 0.861 (0.033) 0.804 (0.022)
(F2,P2) (0.01, 2, 0.7,0.5) 0.811 (0.060) 0.802 (0.347) 0.868 (0.031) 0.806 (0.034)
(F2,P2) (0.01, 1, 0.7,0.5) 0.817 (0.040) 0.809 (0.027) 0.875 (0.038) 0.813 (0.023)
(F2,P2) (0.01,1,0.5,0.5) 0.826 (0.031) 0.802 (0.030) 0.870 (0.029) 0.814 (0.025)
(F2,P3) (0.01,1,0.7,0.5) 0.813 (0.063) 0.791 (0.040) 0.859 (0.035) 0.802 (0.039)
(F2,P3) (0.001,1,0.7,0.5) 0.809 (0.050) 0.791 (0.039) 0.864 (0.029) 0.800 (0.034)
(F2,P3) (0.01,2,0.7,0.5) 0.815 (0.068) 0.796 (0.044) 0.861 (0.035) 0.805 (0.044)
(F2,P3) (0.01,2,0.7,0.7) 0.815 (0.068) 0.796 (0.044) 0.861 (0.035) 0.805 (0.044)
(F2,P4) 0.804 (0.048) 0.785 (0.044) 0.795 (0.035) 0.794 (0.035)
(F2,P2+P3)

(0.01,1,0.5,0.5)+

(0.01,2,0.7,0.5)

0.837 (0.044) 0.809 (0.043) 0.870 (0.033) 0.823 (0.029)