USA 2018 |
Curetis Unyvero lower
respiratory tract panel |
5 h |
10 samples |
7.4 square feet |
788 |
tracheal aspirate samples |
92.5% |
97.4% |
Qi et al.59
|
Germany 2018 |
Curetis
Unyvero P50 cartridge |
5 h |
10 samples |
7.4 square feet |
79 |
43 BAL
fluids; 30 tracheal aspirates; 6 pleural fluids |
73.1% |
97.9% |
Papan et al.60
|
UK 2016 |
Curetis
Unyvero P50 cartridge |
90 |
55 sputa; 32
endotracheal tubes aspirates; 3 BAL |
>95% |
33% |
Personne et al.61
|
UK 2017 |
Curetis Unyvero
P55 pneumonia cartridge |
5 h |
10 samples |
7.4 square feet |
85 |
52 sputa; 31 endotracheal tubes aspirate;1 BAL |
88.8% |
94.9% |
Ozongwu et al.62
|
UK 2019 |
Curetis
Unyvero P55 pneumonia cartridge |
74 |
BAL |
56.9% |
58.5% |
Gadsby et al.63
|
France
2019 |
BioFire FilmArray pneumonia panel |
1.25 h |
264 samples (FilmArray
Torch) |
4.25 square feet (or less, depending on number
of modules) |
63 |
not specified |
93% positive agreement |
95% negative agreement |
Gastli et al.64
|
UK 2019 |
BioFire FilmArray, pneumonia
panel and Curetis Unyvero pneumonia
panel |
|
|
|
634 |
sputa, endotracheal tube exudates, BAL |
FilmArray: 89.2–99.3%
Unyvero: 88.6–97.0% |
FilmArray: 93.8–99.9% Unyvero: 99.2–99.9% |
Enne et al.65
|
not
quoted |
BioFire FilmArray pneumonia panel |
|
|
|
not quoted |
sputa |
96.3% |
97.2% |
data
on file at BioFire Diagnostics (https://www.biofiredx.com/products/the-filmarray-panels/filmarray-pneumonia/) |