Table 3.
Scenario analyses: total costs ($ millions)
Scenario | With PCV IIP | Without PCV IIP | Incremental |
---|---|---|---|
Base case | 15,072 | 16,832 | − 1760 |
Average IPD incidence from 2001 to 2004 used as baseline | 15,072 | 16,668 | − 1596 |
2001 IPD incidence used as baseline | 15,072 | 16,771 | − 1700 |
2004 IPD incidence used as baseline | 15,072 | 16,583 | − 1511 |
Including AOM for 5–9 year olds | 16,572 | 19,182 | − 2610 |
No incremental AOM incidence reduction after 2008 | 15,072 | 15,643 | − 571 |
Only 25% of pneumonia and 50% of AOM decline attributed to PCV IIP | 10,686 | 12,055 | − 1370 |
Vaccination rate set to 90% for all years | 15,176 | 16,832 | − 1656 |
IPD incidence based on weighted average of Quebec and Ontario data | 15,316 | 17,125 | − 1809 |
Exclusion of indirect costs | 11,001 | 11,771 | − 770 |
Costs presented in 2018 Canadian dollars. Base case assumed the following: maximum historical IPD incidence (per 100,000) from 2001 to 2004 for the setting without PCV IIP (35.97 for < 5 years; 3.22 for 5–17 years; 4.29 for 18–49 years; 13.12 for 50–64 years; 33.72 for 65+ years); 80% vaccination rate for all years; IPD incidence from TIBDN only; incremental reduction in AOM incidence throughout the PCV era; 50% of pneumonia decline change and 100% of AOM decline due to PCV IIP introduction; indirect costs considered
For the scenario in which we assume the 2001 incidence for IPD, the incidence rates per age group were: 31.46 for < 5 years; 3.09 for 5–17 years; 4.00 for 18–49 years; 13.12 for 50–64 years; 30.70 for 65+ years
For the scenario in which we assume 2004 incidence for IPD, the incidence rates per age group were: 25.9 for < 5 years; 1.52 for 5–17 years; 3.48 for 18–49 years; 11.53 for 50–64 years; 26.72 for 65 + years
For the scenario in which we assume the average IPD incidence (per 100,000) from 2001 to 2004, the incidence rates were: 31.46 for < 5 years; 2.33 for 5–17 years; 3.78 for 18–49 years; 10.95 for 50–64 years; 30.33 for 65+ years
AOM acute otitis media, IIP infant immunization program, IPD invasive pneumococcal disease, PCV pneumococcal conjugate vaccine