Skip to main content
. 2020 Apr 16;12(4):365. doi: 10.3390/pharmaceutics12040365

Table 3.

Comparison between various solidification process of su-SEDDS.

Process Physical State of Pre-Concentrate [213] Solvent Use 1 Description/Advantages (A) and Disadvantages (D) [30,131,212] Max Loading Capacity (%, w/w) 2 [30,213] Suitable Drug Dose/Potency [30] Self-Emulsification Rate [30] Ref.
O X Drug Lipid Vehicle
Physical adsorption L 3 Adsorption onto solid carrier using physical blending with a mixer
-A: Easy and Low cost, Easy scale-up
-D: Low adsorption efficiency (large amount of solid carrier) and exudation of liquid lipid by tablet compaction
10 80 Low dose, high potency ++ [68,108,119]
Granulation/pelletization followed by drying L 3, SS 4, S 5 Similar with conventional wet granulation
-A: Easy and low cost, Excellent powder property, Flexible applicable to various solid dosage forms (including controlled release system), Easy scale-up
-D: Destabilization by high temperature for drying
- - Low dose, high potency ++ [5,127,211]
Spray drying L 4, SS 4, S 5 Evaporation of solvent from atomized SEDDS with solid carrier
-A: Narrow particle size distribution, Relatively easy scale-up
-D: Destabilization or loss of drug and/or volatile component by high temperature for drying
50 60 Low dose, high potency +++ [113,114,115,215,220]
Freeze drying or Spray freeze-drying L 3, SS 4, S 5 Lyophilization of solvent (mainly aqueous) from frozen SEDDS with solid carrier
-A: Prevent destabilization or loss of drug and/or volatile by heat
-D: Destabilization of drug by freezing and lyophilization, Low process efficiency, particle aggregation and poor re-dispersibility
50 60 Low dose, high potency +++ [221,222,223]
Spray congealing SS 4, S 5 Spraying of molten formula with or without solid carrier into a cooling chamber
-A: Prevent destabilization or loss of drug and/or volatile by heat, Solvent free
-D: Destabilization of drug by freezing, Bad flow property, Limitations on the use of liquid lipids, particle aggregation and poor re-dispersibility
30 99 Low-medium dose ++ [224,225]
Melt granulation or Melt extrusion and spheronization SS 4, S 5 High shear mixing at high temperature
-A: High process efficiency, Solvent free
-D: Destabilization or loss of drug and/or volatile component by high temperature for drying
60–80 50 Low-medium dose ++ [226,227]
Supercritical fluid (SCF) L 3, SS 4, S 5 Adsorption and/or coating onto solid carrier using high diffusivity of SCF
-A: Mild condition, High loading efficiency
-D: High cost for development of commercial scale equipment
20 99 Low-medium dose +++ [204,228,229]

1 Whether the solvent is used or not, 2 The percentage of the mass ratio of a drug or vehicle that can be maximally loaded in the formulation, 3 Liquid, 4 Semi-solid, 5 Solid.