Table 3.
Comparison of monitoring results with quality requirements for toilet flushing from 18 selected wastewater reuse specifications (details in Table S5). The type of requirement (max/min concentration, max/min average, or min removal) is specified in brackets. The column “quality requirements met” describes the percentage of requirements that were met (compared to the number of specifications that give requirements for the parameter) and is categorized into all (100%), mostly (90%), partially (50%), mostly not (<50%) or none (0%) of the specifications were met.
| Parameter | Range of requirements | Quality requirements met |
||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| P1 Hand Washing Station Zurich |
P2 Hand Washing Station Durban |
P3 Toilet System Durban |
||
| Chemical composition | ||||
| COD (mgO2/L) | 50-100 (max), 50 (max avg) | n/a | all | all |
| TOCa (mgC/L) | 5 (max), 3 (max avg) | all | n/a | n/a |
| Total nitrogen (mgN/L) | 1.6–7.8 (max), 70% (min removal) | all | all | partially |
| Ammonium (mgN/L) | 6 (max), 4 (max avg) | all | all | mostly not |
| Total phosphorus (mgP/L)b | 0.2 (max), 80% (min removal) | partially | partially | partially |
| pH (−) | 6–9.5 | all | all | all |
| Hygiene | ||||
| Residual chlorine (mg/L) | 0.2–5 (min), 0.5 (min avg) | none | mostly not | none |
| E. coli (#/100 mL) | <1–200 (max), <1–20 (max avg) | all | all | all |
| Total coliforms (#/100 mL) | 0.3–240 (max), 2.2–23 (max avg) | n/a | all | allc |
| Appearance | ||||
| Color (Pt/Co) | 15-30 (max) | n/a | all | all |
| Turbidity (NTU) | 0.5–10 (max), 0.2–5 (max avg) | n/a | mostly | mostly |
| TSS (mg/L) | 5-1500 (max) | n/a | all | all |
TOC DOC.
Measured phosphate.
Excluding one sample that was presumably contaminated during sampling or analysis.