Skip to main content
. 2020 May 15;10(1):010357. doi: 10.7189/jogh.10.010357

Table 1.

Advantages and disadvantages of current devices used during testing of COVID-19 patients

Feature Advantage Disadvantage
South Korean “phone booth”
Negative pressure environment contains aerosols and airborne particles generated by patient
Intensive sanitisation required between patients for reusable parts eg, semi-permanent gloves
Virtually zero contact between operator and patient
Power source/generator required to maintain negative pressure environment; difficult to adapt for community/field use
Plastic shield with circular arm holes
Easily manufactured, reproducible, portable
No light source
Plastic must be able to withstand high-level disinfection or be prone to degradation
Limited protection for HCW whose limbs and hands must be enclosed in separate PPE
PPE alone / with added plastic face shield Highly portable, versatile to any clinical situation Resource-intensive if single-use per patient

HCW – health care worker, PPE – personal protective equipment