Table 2.
Three-tiered design of GCS-NeuroCOVID study
Tier 1 | Tier 2 | Tier 3 | |
---|---|---|---|
Design | Prospective, Observational Registry | Prospective outcome study | Experimental translational study |
Study characteristics—adult (age ≥ 18) |
Population: Simple inclusion and exclusion criteria. Broadly inclusive Data: Small # of core data elements, low data granularity, capture basic groups Outcome: Global outcomes measured at acute care hospital discharge: Mortality, discharge disposition, length of stay Patient contact: All data collected remotely from electronic health records ± telecommunication with clinical team. No direct contact with study subjects Ethical board: Qualifies for expedited review and waiver of consent |
Population: COVID-19 with neurological symptoms Data: More detailed clinical and neuro-diagnostic data, e.g., Detailed neuro examination Clinical laboratory data Clinical imaging and neurophysiologic data. Outcome: Longitudinal study to capture subacute and long-term events; include cognitive outcome Patient contact: Require contact via telecommunication for outcome assessment. (no direct contact to reduce exposure) Ethical board: Requires full board review and informed consent |
Population: Same as Tier 2 Data: Advanced, non-standard neuro-diagnostics (e.g., advanced magnetic resonance techniques) Prospective biospecimens collection (CSF, blood, other) for experimental biomarkers investigation Possible histologic tissue study Outcome: Same as Tier 2 Patient contact: Involves direct contact + biospecimens. Needs infection containment for study procedure and biospecimen storage (BSL2/2 +) Ethical board: Requires full board review and written informed consent |
Study characteristics—pediatrics (age < 18) |
Population: All confirmed and presumed COVID-19 cases Data: Detailed clinical and neuro-diagnostic data collection Outcomes: In-hospital outcomes Patient contact: No direct contact, electronic chart review + telecommunication with clinical team Ethical board: Qualifies for expedited review and waiver of consent |
Population: Same as Tier 1 Data: Post-hospital discharge child and family outcomes Outcome: Post-hospital outcome at 1–3 months after acute care hospital discharge Patient contact: Require contact via telecommunication for outcome assessment. (no direct contact to reduce exposure) Ethical board: Requires full board review and informed consent |
Population: Same as Tier 1 Data: Prospective biospecimens collection (CSF, blood, other) for experimental biomarkers investigation; clinically obtained imaging and other testing; neuropsychological testing Outcome: Descriptive biomarkers; biomarker association with neurological outcome Patient contact: Involves direct contact for biospecimen handling and storage. Needs infection containment for biospecimen storage (BSL 2 +) Ethical board: Requires full board review and informed consent |
Common data elements | Core | Enhanced | Supplemental |
Participating centers |
All centers All centers able to participate regardless of resource levels Many centers Large sample size |
Able/willing centers participate Fewer sites Smaller overall sample size but more granular data |
Small # of centers with necessary resources participate Few sites Smaller overall sample size but with longitudinal data and biomarker data |
Cost/resource needs | Low, self-funded | Modest cost for data collection and entry | High cost for research coordinator time, specimen processing, laboratory or imaging studies that are not part of routine clinical care |