Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2020 May 24.
Published in final edited form as: Heart Fail Rev. 2013 Jan;18(1):79–94. doi: 10.1007/s10741-012-9332-0

Table 1.

Characteristics of studies included in the meta-analysis of peak VO2

Author Years N Enrollment Follow-up (m) Test mode Threshold End point Event rate (%) Study quality (%)

Corra et al. 2006 231 1995–2001 39 CE 14.8 D/CT 36 78.6
Davies et al. 2006 243 1992–1996 108 TM 14.7 D 57 64
Ferreira et al. 2010 663 1999–2006 36 CE & TM 12–14 D/CT 28.9 64
Francis et al. 2000 303 1992–1996 24 TM 14 D 30 64
Goda et al. 2010 681 1993–2008 32 TM 14 D/CT/VAD 49.5 64
Guimaraes et al. 2008 391 1999–2004 28 TM 16 CD/CT 53.7 71
Ingle et al. 2011 423 NR 12 TM 20 D 28 71
Kruger et al. 2006 83 2000–2001 14 CE 14 CD/AD 16.8 86
MacGowan et al. 1997 104 1991–1993 18 CE & TM 15 D 17 71
Mancini et al. 1991 79 1986–1989 15 TM 14 D 25 78.6
Mezzani et al. 2003 570 1996–2000 19.6 CE 14 CD/CT 14 71
Myers et al. 2009 847 1993–2007 36 CE & TM 14 D/CT 17 78.6
Opasich et al. 1998 372 1992–1995 24 TM 14 CD/CT 45 71
Osada et al. 1998 500 1991–1996 36 TM 14 D/CT listing 25.6 57
Peterson et al. 2003 540 1994–2001 36 TM 14 D/CT 25 71
Sarullo et al. 2010 184 2006–2007 12 CE 12.2 D/C CH 51 78.6
Shakar et al. 2004 127 1992–1999 31.2 CE & TM 14 D/CT 19.7 71
Sun et al. 2010 508 NR 6 CE & TM 11 D/C CH 25 86
Robbins et al. 1999 470 NR 18 TM 13.9 D/CT 15.1 64
Median 391 24 14 25.6 71

NR not reported, CE cycle ergometer, TM treadmill, D death, CD cardiac death, CT cardiac transplantation, CH cardiac hospitalization, VAD ventricular assist device