Skip to main content
. 2020 Mar 24;10(10):4178–4192. doi: 10.1002/ece3.6186

Table 3.

Top five climate (1964–2011), environmental (1982–2011 except 1986 due to missing data), biological (1992–2006), and geographic location models based on AICc scores for δ13C and δ15N of ringed seal claw annuli

Model Response Rank Model AICc ΔAICc AICc Wt
Climate δ13C 1 AOO 751.5 0.0 0.60
2 LAGGED AOO 753.7 2.3 0.10
3 AUTUMN PDO + AOO 754.8 3.3 0.11
4 AUTUMN PDO + LAGGED AO + AOO 757.0 5.6 0.037
5 AUTUMN PDO + LAGGED AOO 757.4 6.0 0.030
δ15N 1 NULL 1,081.3 0.0 0.50
2 SUMMER AO 1,083.5 2.2 0.17
3 AUTUMN PDO 1,083.9 2.7 0.13
4 LAGGED AO 1,084.7 3.4 0.089
5 AUTUMN PDO + SUMMER AO 1,085.4 4.1 0.063
Environmental δ13C 1 AOO 483.25 0.00 0.48
2 NULL 485.43 2.18 0.26
3 SUMMER SST + AOO 486.81 3.56 0.081
4 SPRING AT + AOO 487.81 4.56 0.049
5 SUMMER SST 488.08 4.83 0.043
δ15N 1 SUMMER SST 595.25 0.00 0.81
2 SUMMER AT 600.08 4.83 0.073
3 NULL 600.73 5.48 0.053
4 SUMMER SST:SUMMER AT 601.27 6.02 0.040
5 SUMMER SST + SUMMER AT 602.62 7.37 0.020
Biological δ13C 1 LAGGED PWI + AOO 334.1 0.0 0.65
2 LAGGED PWI + OVULATION +AOO 336.5 2.4 0.20
3 LAGGED PWI + CONDITION +AOO 338.8 4.7 0.063
4 LAGGED PWI + %PUPS + CONDITION +AOO 340.5 6.4 0.027
5 LAGGED PWI + %PUPS + CONDITION + %PUPS:CONDITION + AOO 341.0 6.8 0.021
δ15N 1 % PUPS + SUMMER SST 402.58 0.00 0.58
2 SUMMER SST 405.50 2.92 0.14
3 % PUPS + OVULATION +SUMMER SST 406.27 3.70 0.092
4 % PUPS + PWI +CONDITION + SUMMER SST 406.35 3.78 0.088
5 OVULATION + SUMMER SST 408.05 5.48 0.038
Location δ13C 1 LONGITUDE 141.57 0.00 0.92
2 LATITUDE + LONGITUDE 146.43 4.86 0.081
3 LONGITUDE + SHORE 153.58 12.01 0.0020
4 LATITUDE + SHORE 153.78 12.21 0.0020
5 LATITUDE + LONGITUDE +SHORE 158.16 16.59 <0.00
δ15N 1 SHORE + LONGITUDE 205.10 0.00 0.99
2 SHORE + BATHY 216.23 11.13 0.004
3 BATHY + LONGITUDE +LATITUDE 217.11 12.01 0.002
4 SHORE + BATHY +LONGITUDE 220.38 15.27 <0.00
5 SHORE + BATHY +LATITUDE 220.88 15.78 <0.00

“:” denotes interaction.

Abbreviations: % PUPS, percentage of pups in harvest; AO, Arctic Oscillation; AOO, Arctic Ocean Oscillation; AT, air temperature; BATHY, bathymetry (m); CONDITION, body condition; OVULATION, ovulation rate; PDO, Pacific Decadal Oscillation; PWI, proportional width index; SHORE, distance to shore (km); SST, sea surface temperature.