Skip to main content
. 2020 May 20;5(5):e002138. doi: 10.1136/bmjgh-2019-002138

Table 4.

Deterministic sensitivity of incremental health service cost per DALY averted to changes in 16 key model parameters (2017 US$)

Parameter Best estimate (low-high) Source for range (if different to PSA range) 5% PfPR 50% PfPR
TS-N TS-T TS-U TS-N TS-T TS-U
Low High Low High Low High Low High Low High Low High
Base case ICER (Best estimates for each parameter) (See table 2, online supplementary file S2) 482 115 D 44 45 D
Discount rate 0.03 (0.01–0.10) Assumptions 290 1372 73 309 D D 27 120 28 122 D D
Proportion of patients under 5 years 0.40 (0.30–0.50) (See table 2) 636 389 128 105 D D 51 38 53 39 D D
Patients receiving RDT (‘uptake’)* 0.41 (0.08–0.72) (See table 2) 1401 316 109 121 D D 38 49 82 33 D D
Positive RDT gets antimalarial (See online supplementary file S4) D 154 280 72 D D 76 30 87 30 D D
Antimalarial with positive RDT result that is ACT 709 362 128 105 D D 47 41 49 42 D D
Negative RDT gets antibiotic D 47 233 31 D 196 45 37 47 37 D D
Initial treatment parameters for intervention with no test unchanged from control 492 268 868 107 59 210
Reduction in ACT effectiveness due to reduced API consumed Low transmission: 0.15 (0.00–0.30)
Med/high transmission: 0.10 (0.00–0.30)
Assumptions 103 D 90 159 D D 30 129 39 57 D D
Reduction in other antimalarial effectiveness due to reduced API consumed D 131 123 109 D D 59 31 47 42 D D
Malaria case progresses to severe with no (or not effective) treatment* (See PSA ranges in table 2 for <5 and >5 years, low and medium/high transmission settings) D 40 701 34 D D 129 5 111 6 D D
Severe case receives further (inpatient) care* 0.75 (0.19–0.88) (See table 2) 93 16 013 48 172 D D 22 58 23 59 D D
CFR of severe malaria receiving inpatient care * 0.10 (0.05–0.15) 5170 259 144 97 D D 56 36 56 38 D D
CFR of severe malaria with no further care * (See PSA ranges in table 2 for <5 and >5 years, low and medium/high transmission settings) D 216 236 91 D D 87 29 81 31 D D
RDT exmanufacturer price * 0.22 (0.17–0.28) (See table 2) 471 495 112 119 D D 43 45 44 46 D D
ACT exmanufacturer price* 0.68 (0.51–1.56) 472 535 117 106 D D 42 50 45 44 D D
Supporting intervention cost per febrile patient 0.43 (0.21–2.54) Min: −25%; Max: assumption based on18 294 2330 62 638 D D 26 217 24 247 D D
graphic file with name bmjgh-2019-002138ilf02.jpg Cost-effective at all six country-specific thresholds (Madagascar, Uganda, Nigeria, Tanzania, Ghana and Kenya)
graphic file with name bmjgh-2019-002138ilf06.jpg Cost-effective for at least one country-specific threshold (but not all six)
graphic file with name bmjgh-2019-002138ilf07.jpg Not cost-effective at any of six country-specific thresholds, but not dominated
graphic file with name bmjgh-2019-002138ilf08.jpg Dominated

*Parameters where range of uncertainty in deterministic sensitivity analysis is the same as the PSA range. D: dominated, that is, intervention is more costly and less effective than the control.

ACT, artemisinin combination therapy; API, active pharmaceutical ingredient; CFR, case fatality rate; DALY, disability-adjusted life year; ICER, incremental cost-effectiveness ratio; PfPR, Plasmodium falciparum positivity rate; PSA, probabilistic sensitivity analysis; RDT, rapid diagnostic test.