Skip to main content
. 2020 May 12;7:135. doi: 10.3389/fmed.2020.00135

Table 2.

Main outcomes of the included studies.

References Peak ALT Peak AST EAD PNF Total biliary complications
MP CS MP CS MP(%) CS(%) p MP(%) CS(%) p MP(%) CS(%) p
Guarrera et al. (10) 560.0 ± 355.5 IU/mL 1358 ± 1208.4 IU/mL* 1154 ± 355.5 IU/mL 3339 ± 3376.9 IU/mL* 5 25 0.08 0 0 ns 10 20 N/A
Dutkowski et al. (22) 1239
(689–2126) U/L
2065
(1331–3596) U/L *
1808
(1133–3547) U/L
2848
(1485–6724) U/L *
20 44* 0.03 0 6 ns 20 46 0.035*
Guarrera et al. (21) 550 IU/mL 900 IU/mL #* 1300 IU/mL 1600 IU/mL # 19 30 0.384 3.2 6.7 0.612 13 43.3 0.001*
Ravikumar et al. (25) N/A N/A 417
(84–4681) U/L
902
(218–8786) U/L*
15 22.5 0.734 0 0 ns N/A N/A N/A
Selzner et al. (23) 619
(55–2858) U/L
949
(233–3073) U/L
1182
(167–6700) U/L
1474
(521–5156) U/L
0 0 ns 0 0 ns N/A N/A N/A
Bral et al. (24) N/A N/A 1252
(383–2600) U/L
839
(153–2600) U/L
55.6 29.6 0.23 0 0 ns 0 14.8 0.55
van Rijn et al. (26) 966 U/L 1858 U/L* N/A N/A 0 10 1.00 0 0 ns 40 55 N/A
Watson et al. (27) 1069
(187–4991) IU/L
787
(155–2238) IU/L
N/A N/A NA NA N/A NA NA N/A NA NA N/A
Nasralla et al. (18) N/A N/A 488.1
(408.9–582.8) U/L
964.9
(794.5–1,172.0) U/L*
10.1 29.9* 0.0002 0.8 0 ns N/A N/A N/A
Ghinolfi et al. (30) 332
(263–610) U/L
428
(303–616) U/L
709.5
(371–1575) U/L
574
(377–1162) U/L
20.0 10.0 1.000 0 0 ns 10.0 0 1.000
Patrono et al. (29) 792 ± 773 U/L 817 ± 540 U/L 1425 ± 1729 U/L 1498 ± 1034 U/L 32 34 1.0 0 0 ns 24 18 0.76
Liu et al. (28) 1357 ± 1492 U/L 2615 ± 2541 U/L* 363 ± 318 U/L 1021 ± 999 U/L* 19 46.4 0.02 0 0 ns N/A N/A N/A

ns, not significant; N/A, non-available;

*

, statistically significant; #, approximate number because only diagram form was available in this included study.