Table 2.
Organ donation medical humanities curriculum content system.
| First-layer items (χ̄±S, CV, Approval rate %) | Second-layer items (χ̄±S, CV, Approval rate %) | Third-layer items (χ̄±S, CV, Approval rate %) |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Overview of organ donation (4.571±0.676, 0.148, 90.48%) | 1.1 Introduction to organ donation (4.476±0.602, 0.134, 95.20%) | 1.1.1 Concepts about organ donation (4.429±0.598, 0.135, 95.24%) |
| 1.1.2 History and development of organ donation (4.143±0.655, 0.158, 85.71%) | ||
| 1.1.3 Types of organ donation (4.381±0.590, 0.135, 95.24%) | ||
| 1.2 Importance of organ donation (4.524±0.750, 0.166, 85.70%) | 1.2.1 Historical significance of organ donation (4.143±0.727, 0.175, 80.95%) | |
| 1.2.2 Social significance of organ donation (4.524±0.750, 0.166, 85.71%) | ||
| 1.3 Factors influencing organ donation (4.667±0.577, 0.124, 95.20%) | 1.3.1 Knowledge of organ donation (4.619±0.590, 0.128, 95.24%) | |
| 1.3.2 Family members’ attitude towards organ donation (4.571±0.598, 0.131, 95.24%) | ||
| 1.3.3 Social education, public support factors (4.476±0.602, 0.134, 95.24%) | ||
| 2. Cultural concepts on organ donation (4.476±0.750, 0.167, 85.71%) | 2.1 Cultural attitudes on promoting organ donation (4.524±0.602, 0.133, 95.20%) | 2.1.1 Helping others (4.333±0.577, 0.133, 95.24%) |
| 2.1.2 Positive life values (4.476±0.680, 0.152, 90.48%) | ||
| 2.1.3 Family support culture (4.333±0.658, 0.152, 90.48%) | ||
| 2.2 Cultural attitudes on discouraging organ donation (4.429±0.676, 0.153, 90.50%) | 2.2.1 Traditional death culture (4.381±0.669, 0.153, 90.48%) | |
| 2.2.2 Traditional filial piety and body concept (4.429±0.676, 0.153, 90.48%) | ||
| 3. Organ donation ethics (4.762±0.436, 0.092, 100.00%) | 3.1 Ethics of organ sources (4.524±0.680, 0.150, 90.50%) | 3.1.1 Organs of executed prisoners (4.333±0.796, 0.184, 80.95%) |
| 3.1.2 Organ trafficking (4.429±0.746, 0.169, 85.71%) | ||
| 3.1.3 Organ transplantation tourism (4.381±0.669, 0.153, 90.48%) | ||
| 3.2 Ethical issues related to organ donors (4.857±0.359, 0.074, 100.00%) | 3.2.1 Donor body protection (4.619±0.498, 0.108, 100.00%) | |
| 3.2.2 Privacy protection (4.857±0.359, 0.074, 100.00%) | ||
| 3.2.3 Informed consent (4.857±0.359, 0.074, 100.00%) | ||
| 3.3 Ethical review of organ donation and access (4.810±0.402, 0.084, 100.00%) | 3.3.1 Basic ethical principles for organ donation and access (4.810±0.402, 0.084, 100.00%) | |
| 3.3.2 Ethics review committee responsibilities and procedures (4.524±0.602, 0.133, 95.24%) | ||
| 4. Laws and regulations on organ donation (4.714±0.561, 0.119, 95.24%) | 4.1 Organ donation laws and regulations (4.667±0.577, 0.124, 95.20%) | 4.1.1 Current situation of organ donation legislation at domestic and overseas (4.333±0.796, 0.184, 80.95%) |
| 4.1.2 Regulations on organ donation in China (4.667±0.577, 0.124, 95.24%) | ||
| 4.1.3 Relevant regulations for medical personnel (4.714±0.561, 0.119, 95.24%) | ||
| 4.2 Organ donation process (4.762±0.436, 0.092, 100.00%) | 4.2.1 Organ donation application process (4.762±0.436, 0.092, 100.00%) | |
| 4.2.2 Steps to obtain donated organs (4.762±0.436, 0.092, 100.00%) | ||
| 4.2.3 Organ donation allocation process (4.762±0.436, 0.092, 100.00%) | ||
| 4.3 Organ donation organizations (4.429±0.598, 0.135, 95.20%) | 4.3.1 Red Cross Association (4.429±0.598, 0.135, 95.24%) | |
| 4.3.2 OPO, organ procurement organization (4.429±0.598, 0.135, 95.24%) | ||
| 5. Medical knowledge of organ donation (4.762±0.436, 0.092, 100.00%) | 5.1 Donation after death (4.762±0.539, 0.113, 95.20%) | 5.1.1 Standard of determination of death (4.714±0.561, 0.119, 95.24%) |
| 5.1.2 Standards for donation after death (4.857±0.478, 0.098, 95.24%) | ||
| 5.1.3 Methods and time of different organs preservation (4.857±0.478, 0.098, 95.24%) | ||
| 5.2 Live organ donation (4.810±0.512, 0.106, 95.20%) | 5.2.1 Standards for live donor donation (4.857±0.478, 0.098, 95.24%) | |
| 5.2.2 Possible harm from organ donation (4.714±0.561, 0.119, 95.24%) | ||
| 5.2.3 Care for living organ donors (4.857±0.478, 0.098, 95.24%) | ||
| 5.3 Medical skills for organ donation (4.714±0.561, 0.119, 95.20%) | 5.3.1 Identification and interpretation skills of potential organ donors (4.667±0.658, 0.141, 90.48%) | |
| 5.3.2 Health management skills of organ donors (4.714±0.644, 0.137, 90.48%) | ||
| 5.3.3 Humanistic care skills on organ donation (4.619±0.669, 0.145, 90.48%) | ||
| 6. Psychological care in organ donation (4.714±0.463, 0.098, 100.00%) | 6.1 Psychological care for living organ donors (4.857±0.359, 0.074, 100.00%) | 6.1.1 Psychological activities and characteristics of living organ donors (4.762±0.436, 0.092, 100.00%) |
| 6.1.2 Factors affecting the psychological changes of living organ donors (4.810±0.402, 0.084, 100.00%) | ||
| 6.2 Psychological care for family members (4.762±0.436, 0.092, 100.00%) | 6.2.1 Psychological activities and characteristics of the relatives of living organ donors (4.810±0.402, 0.084, 100.00%) | |
| 6.2.2 Psychological activities and characteristics of the relatives of dead organ donors (4.810±0.402, 0.084, 100.00%) | ||
| 6.2.3 Factors affecting the psychological changes of family members (4.714±0.463, 0.098, 100.00%) | ||
| 6.3 Psychological care skills (4.762±0.436, 0.092, 100.00%) | 6.3.1 Standards for psychological caregivers (4.619±0.590, 0.128, 95.24%) | |
| 6.3.2 Goals of psychological care (4.571±0.598, 0.131, 95.24%) | ||
| 6.3.3 Skills of psychological care (4.762±0.436, 0.092, 100.00%) |