Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2020 May 26.
Published in final edited form as: Neurosci Biobehav Rev. 2019 Feb 23;100:108–128. doi: 10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.02.017

Table 4.

Average contribution of each experimental contrast for significant clusters identified for the meta-analysis of monetary reward anticipation.

Cluster Name. Study N Task Contrast No. of foci Average contribution (%)
VS Adcock et al. (2006) 12 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 17 3.25
Adcock et al. (2006) 12 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 17 3.14
Bjork et al. (2004) 12 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 13 2.9
Treadway et al. (2013) 38 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 13 2.55
Herbort et al. (2016) 23 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 25 2.5
Samanez-Larkin et al. (2007) 12 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 21 2.38
Kirsch et al. (2003) 27 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 26 2.2
Enzi et al. (2012a) 19 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 15 2.17
Kirsch et al. (2003) 27 monetary incentive delay task/social incentive delay task monetary reward > social reward 12 2.13
Saji et al. (2013) 18 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 22 2.07
Wu et al. (2014) 52 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 20 2.05
Kirk et al. (2015) 44 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 15 1.91
Bjork et al. (2012) 23 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 19 1.85
Stark et al. (2011) 31 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 14 1.82
Knutson et al. (2001b) 9 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 13 1.68
Samanez-Larkin et al. (2007) 12 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 43 1.61
Wittmann et al. (2005) 16 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 22 1.6
Bjork et al. (2004) 12 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 8 1.56
Knutson et al. (2008) 12 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 8 1.54
Adcock et al. (2006) 12 monetary incentive delay task high monetary reward > low monetary reward 12 1.47
Wrase et al. (2007a) 14 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 18 1.46
Knutson et al. (2001a) 8 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 10 1.4
Enzi et al. (2012b) 15 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 9 1.39
Beck et al. (2009) 19 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 6 1.39
Bjork et al. (2010a) 24 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 13 1.36
Damiano et al. (2014) 31 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 15 1.35
Costumero et al. (2013) 44 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > monetary punishment 18 1.34
Juckel et al. (2012) 13 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 18 1.32
Maresh et al. (2014) 84 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 18 1.32
Knutson et al. (2001a) 8 monetary incentive delay task high monetary reward > low monetary reward 12 1.31
Knutson et al. (2003) 12 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 10 1.29
Bjork et al. (2010b) 12 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 7 1.28
Juckel et al. (2006) 10 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 9 1.26
Rademacher et al. (2010) 28 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 36 1.23
Bjork et al. (2008b) 23 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 17 1.22
Kappel et al. (2013) 10 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 13 1.19
Bjork et al. (2010a) 24 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 10 1.19
Carl et al. (2016) 20 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 15 1.17
Arrondo et al. (2015) 21 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 29 1.13
Pfabigan et al. (2014) 25 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 12 1.13
Carter et al. (2009) 17 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 10 1.12
Ströhle et al. (2008) 10 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 7 1.04
Yau et al. (2012) 20 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 6 1.03
Costumero et al. (2013) 44 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 16 1.02
Yan et al. (2016a) 23 monetary incentive delay task brain regions showing proportional activation to increasing anticipated monetary reward 15 0.99
Spreckelmeyer et al. (2009) 16 monetary incentive delay task brain regions showing proportional activation to increasing anticipated monetary reward 12 0.98
Figee et al. (2011) 19 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 7 0.97
Spreckelmeyer et al. (2009) 32 monetary incentive delay task brain regions showing proportional activation to increasing anticipated monetary reward 7 0.96
Staudinger et al. (2011) 24 monetary incentive delay task high monetary reward > low monetary reward 6 0.91
Romanczuk-Seiferth et al. (2015) 17 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 22 0.89
Simon et al. (2010) 24 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 6 0.87
Plichta et al. (2013) 14 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 6 0.87
Spreckelmeyer et al. (2009) 32 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 8 0.87
Stoy et al. (2012) 15 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 6 0.86
Funayama et al. (2014) 20 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 17 0.85
Schlagenhauf et al. (2008) 10 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 12 0.84
Kappel et al. (2013) 20 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 6 0.83
Kollmann et al. (2017) 41 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 17 0.82
Spreckelmeyer et al. (2009) 16 monetary incentive delay task brain regions showing proportional activation to increasing anticipated monetary reward 8 0.82
Stoy et al.(2011) 12 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 6 0.82
Kocsel et al. (2017) 37 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 10 0.76
Bjork et al. (2012) 23 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 7 0.75
Abler et al. (2005) 12 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward anticipation > target + outcome 3 0.74
Schlagenhauf et al. (2008) 10 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 9 0.74
Abler et al. (2005) 12 monetary incentive delay task high monetary reward > low monetary reward 4 0.73
Behan et al. (2015) 20 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 15 0.71
Dillon et al. (2010) 32 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 7 0.71
Yan et al. (2016a) 23 monetary incentive delay task brain regions showing proportional activation to increasing anticipated monetary reward 6 0.7
Kappel et al. (2013) 20 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 7 0.66
Yan et al. (2016b) 22 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 33 0.63
Ossewaarde et al. (2011) 27 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 12 0.62
Gossen et al. (2014) 20 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 8 0.62
Gossen et al. (2014) 15 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 7 0.53
Kaufmann et al. (2013) 19 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 15 0.51
Kaufmann et al. (2013) 19 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > monetary punishment 3 0.48
Stoy et al. (2012) 15 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 3 0.42
Wrase et al. (2007b) 16 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 2 0.4
Schreiter et al. (2016) 20 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 8 0.38
Barman et al. (2015) 63 monetary incentive delay task/social incentive delay task monetary reward > social reward 2 0.37
Pujara et al. (2016) 14 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 6 0.32
Bustamante et al. (2014) 18 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 3 0.28
Mucci et al. (2015) 22 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 11 0.27
Weiland et al. (2014) 12 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 4 0.26
Abler et al. (2005) 12 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 1 0.25
Bjork et al. (2008a) 13 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 1 0.2
Costumero et al. (2013) 44 monetary incentive delay task high monetary reward > low monetary reward 2 0.19
Simon et al. (2010) 24 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 1 0.15
Balodis et al. (2012) 14 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 4 0.14
dACC Treadway et al. (2013) 38 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 13 14.84
Bjork et al. (2012) 23 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 19 12.71
Adcock et al. (2006) 12 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 17 11.91
Adcock et al. (2006) 12 monetary incentive delay task high monetary reward > low monetary reward 12 11.91
Adcock et al. (2006) 12 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 17 11.27
Yan et al. (2016b) 22 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 33 9.47
Arrondo et al. (2015) 21 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 29 7.85
Spreckelmeyer et al. (2009) 16 monetary incentive delay task brain regions showing proportional activation to increasing anticipated monetary reward 12 7.35
Knutson et al. (2001a) 8 monetary incentive delay task high monetary reward > low monetary reward 12 5.06
Rademacher et al. (2010) 28 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 36 2.85
Enzi et al. (2012a) 19 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 15 2.3
Simon et al. (2010) 24 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 6 1.29
Carter et al. (2009) 17 monetary incentive delay task/social incentive delay task monetary reward > social reward 7 0.88
dACC/SMA Maresh et al. (2014) 84 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 18 7.01
Goerlich et al. (2017) 45 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 4 5.81
Costumero et al. (2013) 44 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 16 5.13
Knutson et al. (2001a) 8 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 10 4.32
Funayama et al. (2014) 20 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 17 3.97
Knutson et al. (2001b) 9 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 13 3.96
Kirsch et al. (2003) 27 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 26 3.63
Plichta et al. (2013) 14 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 6 2.78
Herbort et al. (2016) 23 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 25 2.75
Gossen et al. (2014) 35 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 3 2.74
Ossewaarde et al. (2011) 27 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 12 2.72
Knutson et al. (2001a) 8 monetary incentive delay task high monetary reward > low monetary reward 12 2.67
Kappel et al. (2013) 20 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 7 2.59
Figee et al. (2011) 19 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 7 2.57
Bjork et al. (2010a) 24 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 13 2.49
Bjork et al. (2012) 23 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 19 2.49
Wittmann et al. (2005) 16 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 22 2.46
Dillon et al. (2010) 32 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 7 2.38
Kollmann et al. (2017) 41 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 17 2.21
Yan et al. (2016b) 22 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 33 2.21
Bjork et al. (2010a) 24 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 10 2.2
Kirk et al. (2015) 44 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 15 2.19
Kappel et al. (2013) 20 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 6 2.16
Knutson et al. (2003) 12 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 10 2.14
Behan et al. (2015) 20 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 15 2.08
Damiano et al. (2014) 31 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 15 2.08
Bjork et al. (2008b) 23 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 17 1.96
Samanez-Larkin et al. (2007) 12 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 43 1.85
Gossen et al. (2014) 20 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 8 1.83
Kaufmann et al. (2013) 19 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > monetary punishment 3 1.8
Staudinger et al. (2011) 24 monetary incentive delay task high monetary reward > low monetary reward 6 1.66
Kaufmann et al. (2013) 19 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 15 1.57
Stark et al. (2011) 31 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 14 1.5
Spreckelmeyer et al. (2009) 16 monetary incentive delay task brain regions showing proportional activation to increasing anticipated monetary reward 12 1.5
Saji et al. (2013) 18 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 22 1.26
Pfabigan et al. (2014) 25 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 12 1.18
Enzi et al. (2012a) 19 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 15 1.15
Kirsch et al. (2003) 27 monetary incentive delay task/social incentive delay task monetary reward > social reward 26 0.96
Kappel et al. (2013) 10 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 13 0.86
Arrondo et al. (2015) 21 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 29 0.64
Romanczuk-Seiferth et al. (2015) 17 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 22 0.32
Rademacher et al. (2010) 28 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 36 0.04
postcentral gyrus Costumero et al. (2013) 44 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 16 8.01
Stark et al. (2011) 31 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 14 7.82
Knutson et al. (2001b) 9 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 13 7.61
Bjork et al. (2012) 23 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 19 7.56
Samanez-Larkin et al. (2007) 12 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 43 7.42
Kappel et al. (2013) 20 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 6 6.95
Behan et al. (2015) 20 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 15 6.91
Kollmann et al. (2017) 41 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 17 6.77
Bjork et al. (2010a) 24 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 10 6.38
Pfabigan et al. (2014) 25 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 12 6.25
Romanczuk-Seiferth et al. (2015) 17 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 22 5.07
Kirsch et al. (2003) 27 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 26 4.12
Arrondo et al. (2015) 21 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 29 3.68
Herbort et al. (2016) 23 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 25 3.65
Bjork et al. (2010a) 24 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 13 3.54
Carl et al. (2016) 20 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 15 2.59
Wittmann et al. (2005) 16 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 22 1.87
Yan et al. (2016b) 22 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 33 1.63
Bjork et al. (2008b) 23 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 17 0.87
Ossewaarde et al. (2011) 27 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 12 0.79
Samanez-Larkin et al. (2007) 12 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 43 0.31
precentral gyrus Herbort et al. (2016) 23 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 25 13.73
Arrondo et al. (2015) 21 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 29 13.6
Kollmann et al. (2017) 41 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 17 12.89
Kirsch et al. (2003) 27 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 26 12.54
Damiano et al. (2014) 31 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 15 10.78
Kirsch et al. (2003) 27 monetary incentive delay task/social incentive delay task monetary reward > social reward 12 10.04
Saji et al. (2013) 18 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 22 9.2
Kaufmann et al. (2013) 19 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 15 6.63
Yan et al. (2016b) 22 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 33 6.6
Dillon et al. (2010) 32 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 7 1.45
Wittmann et al. (2005) 16 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 22 0.86
Pfabigan et al. (2014) 25 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 12 0.75
Bjork et al. (2012) 23 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 19 0.69
Rademacher et al. (2010) 28 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 36 0.12
middle occipital gyrus Kocsel et al. (2017) 37 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 10 11.65
Kirsch et al. (2003) 27 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 26 10.16
Bjork et al. (2012) 23 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 19 9.41
Juckel et al. (2012) 13 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 18 8.04
Funayama et al. (2014) 20 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 17 7.96
Van Duin et al. (2016) 12 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 13 7.65
Yan et al. (2016b) 22 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 33 7.65
Pfabigan et al. (2014) 25 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 12 7.11
Samanez-Larkin et al. (2007) 12 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 21 6.88
Maresh et al. (2014) 84 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 18 4.36
Stoy et al. (2011) 12 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 6 3.96
Dillon et al. (2010) 32 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 7 3.63
Spreckelmeyer et al. (2009) 32 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 8 3.23
Weiland et al. (2014) 12 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 4 3.11
Spreckelmeyer et al. (2009) 16 monetary incentive delay task brain regions showing proportional activation to increasing anticipated monetary reward 12 2.02
Behan et al. (2015) 20 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 15 0.95
Kollmann et al. (2017) 41 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 17 0.74
Damiano et al. (2014) 31 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 15 0.32
Spreckelmeyer et al. (2009) 16 monetary incentive delay task brain regions showing proportional activation to increasing anticipated monetary reward 8 0.27
Abler et al. (2005) 12 monetary incentive delay task high monetary reward > low monetary reward 4 0.24
Carter et al. (2009) 17 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 10 0.21
Kappel et al. (2013) 10 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 13 0.17
cuneus Damiano et al. (2014) 31 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 15 10.2
Romanczuk-Seiferth et al. (2015) 17 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 11 9.89
Spreckelmeyer et al. (2009) 16 monetary incentive delay task brain regions showing proportional activation to increasing anticipated monetary reward 8 9.08
Spreckelmeyer et al. (2009) 32 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 8 8.69
Adcock et al. (2006) 12 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 17 8.57
Saji et al. (2013) 18 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 22 8.27
Bjork et al. (2010a) 24 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 13 8.14
Spreckelmeyer et al. (2009) 16 monetary incentive delay task brain regions showing proportional activation to increasing anticipated monetary reward 12 8.04
Adcock et al. (2006) 12 monetary incentive delay task high monetary reward > low monetary reward 12 7.42
Enzi et al. (2012b) 15 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 9 6.74
Carl et al. (2016) 20 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 15 6.06
Costumero et al. (2013) 44 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 16 4.28
Bjork et al. (2008b) 23 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 17 2.51
Samanez-Larkin et al. (2007) 12 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 43 0.33
Bjork et al. (2004) 12 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 13 0.32
Stoy et al. (2012) 15 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 6 0.31
Kocsel et al. (2017) 37 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 10 0.29
Carter et al. (2009) 17 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 10 0.23
Stoy et al. (2012) 15 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 3 0.19
Juckel et al. (2012) 13 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 18 0.16
Bjork et al. (2010a) 24 monetary incentive delay task monetary reward > no reward 10 0.15