Table 1.
Study | Patients | Extremities | Disease Site | Stage | Primary versus Secondary | Lymphedema Duration (mean) | No. LVA | Mean Follow-up | Outcome Assessment Tool | Objective Result | Objective % CasesImproved | Subjective (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Akita et al 201723 | NR | 29 | Lower | Stardust pattern | Secondary | 12 months | 4.4 | 12.1 months | LEL index | 4% decline | NR | 58.6 |
AlJindan et al 201924 | 58 | 58 | Upper and lower | Cheng grade I–II | Primary and secondary | 43 months (median) | 1 | 16.5 months | Circumference measurement | 2.2%–3.2% decline | 100% | 100 |
Chang et al 201311 | 89 | 89 | Upper | MDA lympho Stage I–IV | Secondary | 42 months | NR | 30.4 months | Volumetry | 42% decline volume differential | NR | 96 |
Chang et al 201311 | 7 | 11 | Lower | MDA lympho Stage I–IV | Secondary | 79 months | NR | 18.2 months | Volumetry | 0%–33% decline volume differential | NR | 57 |
Gennaro et al 201625 | 69 | 69 | Upper and lower | ISL II–IV | Primary and secondary | 69.6 months | 5.3 | “at least” 12 months | Circumference measurement | 50% decline volume differential | 100% had improvement | 81 |
Hara et al 201826 | 109 | 196 | Upper and lower | ISL I–III Lympho I–V | Primary and secondary | 89.2 months | 3.3 | 9.1 months | Circumference measurement | 0.34%–1.83% decline | 100% had improvement | NR |
Huang et al 19859 | 91 | 91 | Lower | NR | Secondary | 135.6 months | 4.5 | 24 months | Circumference measurement | 59.2% decline volume differential | 100% had improvement | NR |
Koshima et al 20007 | 12 | 12 | Upper | 11 “severe” 1 “moderate” | Secondary | 42 months | 4.1 | 26.4 months | Circumference measurement | 47.3% decline volume differential | 92% had improvement | NR |
Koshima et al 20037 | 13 | 17 | Lower | NR | Primary and secondary | 80.4 months | NR | 39.6 months | Circumference measurement | 55.6% decline volume differential | 100% had improvement | NR |
Koshima et al 200417 | 52 | NR | Lower | Campisi Stage III, IV | Secondary (primary NR) | 63.6 months | 2.1 | 14.5 months | Circumference measurement | 41.8% decline volume differential | 82.5% had improvement | NR |
Mihara et al 201427 | 95 | NR | Upper and lower | ISL 0–III | Primary and secondary | NR | 3 or more | 27.3 months | No. cellulitis episodes | 1.46 episodes/year to 0.18 episodes/year | NR | NR |
Mihara et al 201612 | 84 | 162 | Lower | ISL I–III Lympho I–V | Primary and secondary | NR | NR* | 18.3 months | Lymphoscintigraphy, circumference measurement | 58.9%–80% decline volume differential depending on stage | 47.7% had improvement | 61.5 |
Seki et al 201528 | 30 | 30 | Lower | LDB stage I–IV | Secondary | 41–63 months | 2 | 12 months | LEL, lymphoscintigraphy | 0.03–24.4 reduction LEL | 77% had improvement | NR |
Yamamoto et al 201420 | 48 | NR | Lower | ISL I–III | Primary and secondary | 66 months (median) | 1.6–1.8 | 6 months | LEL | 10.9–16.5 LEL | NR | NR |
*Not reported; however, increased numbers of ISL indicates International Society of Lymphology; LDB, lymphatic dermal back flow; LEL, lower extremity lymphedema index, combination of circumference measurement and body mass index; NR, not reported.