Table 2.
Overview of the main characteristics and development methods of instruments that measure and value capability for economic evaluations in health
Instrument | Instrument full name | Field | Population | Number of | Development method | Informants | Number of informants | References | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Dimensions | Levels | ||||||||
ACQ‐CMH‐104 | Achieved Capabilities Questionnaire for Community Mental Health | Mental health | Patients | 104 | Unknown | Focus groups | Participants of Portuguese community mental health services | 50 | [56] |
ASCOT | Adult Social Care Outcomes Toolkit | Social care | Patients | 8 | 4 | Delphi exercise, Literature review and expert opinion, Further improvement of the Older People’s Utility Scale (OPUS) | Experts and service users | 330 | [52] |
ASCOT Easy Read version | Easy Read Version of the Adult Social Care Outcomes Toolkit | Social care | People w. intellectual disabilities | 8 | 4 | Focus groups and in-depth interviews | Intellectual disability or autism | 54 | [57] |
ASCOT – proxy version | Proxy-report version of the Adult Social Care Outcomes Toolkit | Social care | Patients | 8 | 4 | In-depth qualitative interviews | Adult care workers or unpaid family carers of patients with cognitive and/or communication impairments | 25 | [58] |
ASCOT-Carer | Carer Version of Adult Social Care Outcomes Toolkit | Social care | Carers | 7 | 4 | Literature review and feedback from service users, carers, practitioners and policy-makers | Service users, carers, practitioners and policy-makers | 31 | [59] |
CAF | Currently Achieved Functioning | General | Older people | 5 | 5 | In-depth qualitative interviews | Older people living in 3 Dutch urban areas | 99 | [60] |
ICECAP-A | ICEpop CAPability measure for Adults | General | General public | 5 | 4 | In-depth, informant-led, interviews | General public (purposively selected through a random electoral sample) | 36 | [53] |
ICECAP-CPM | ICEpop CAPability Close Person Measure | End of life | Close persons | 6 | 5 | In-depth qualitative interviews | Bereaved within the last 2 years or with a close person currently receiving end-of-life care | 27 | [61] |
ICECAP-O | ICEpop CAPability measure for Older people | General | Older people | 5 | 4 | In-depth qualitative interviews | Purposively selected informants aged 65 and over in private households | 40 | [54] |
ICECAP-SCM | ICEpop CAPability Supportive Care Measure | End of life | Patients | 7 | 4 | In-depth qualitative interviews | Older people from different groups across the dying trajectory | 23 | [62] |
OCAP-18 | OCAP-18 | Public health | General public | 18 | Unknown |
Theoretical framework, Focus groups and in-depth interviews |
Purposively sampled from various community groups in Glasgow, United Kingdom | 40 | [63] |
OxCAP-MH | Oxford Capabilities Questionnaire for Mental Health | Mental health | Patients | 16 | 5 |
Theoretical framework, Focus group discussions |
Psychiatrists, Psychologists, Social scientists, Health economists | 336 | [39] |
(Low-income questionnaire) | (Low-income questionnaire) | Low-income settings | General public | 6 | Unknown | Focus groups | Women in rural Malawi | 129 | [64] |
(Chronic pain questionnaire) | (Chronic pain questionnaire) | Chronic pain | Patients | 8 | Unknown | Focus groups and in-depth interviews | Respondents were recruited through a Pain Management Clinic in the East of England | 16 | [65] |