Skip to main content
. 2019 Dec 24;29(6):1433–1464. doi: 10.1007/s11136-019-02393-5

Table 2.

Overview of the main characteristics and development methods of instruments that measure and value capability for economic evaluations in health

Instrument Instrument full name Field Population Number of Development method Informants Number of informants References
Dimensions Levels
ACQ‐CMH‐104 Achieved Capabilities Questionnaire for Community Mental Health Mental health Patients 104 Unknown Focus groups Participants of Portuguese community mental health services 50 [56]
ASCOT Adult Social Care Outcomes Toolkit Social care Patients 8 4 Delphi exercise, Literature review and expert opinion, Further improvement of the Older People’s Utility Scale (OPUS) Experts and service users 330 [52]
ASCOT Easy Read version Easy Read Version of the Adult Social Care Outcomes Toolkit Social care People w. intellectual disabilities 8 4 Focus groups and in-depth interviews Intellectual disability or autism 54 [57]
ASCOT – proxy version Proxy-report version of the Adult Social Care Outcomes Toolkit Social care Patients 8 4 In-depth qualitative interviews Adult care workers or unpaid family carers of patients with cognitive and/or communication impairments 25 [58]
ASCOT-Carer Carer Version of Adult Social Care Outcomes Toolkit Social care Carers 7 4 Literature review and feedback from service users, carers, practitioners and policy-makers Service users, carers, practitioners and policy-makers 31 [59]
CAF Currently Achieved Functioning General Older people 5 5 In-depth qualitative interviews Older people living in 3 Dutch urban areas 99 [60]
ICECAP-A ICEpop CAPability measure for Adults General General public 5 4 In-depth, informant-led, interviews General public (purposively selected through a random electoral sample) 36 [53]
ICECAP-CPM ICEpop CAPability Close Person Measure End of life Close persons 6 5 In-depth qualitative interviews Bereaved within the last 2 years or with a close person currently receiving end-of-life care 27 [61]
ICECAP-O ICEpop CAPability measure for Older people General Older people 5 4 In-depth qualitative interviews Purposively selected informants aged 65 and over in private households 40 [54]
ICECAP-SCM ICEpop CAPability Supportive Care Measure End of life Patients 7 4 In-depth qualitative interviews Older people from different groups across the dying trajectory 23 [62]
OCAP-18 OCAP-18 Public health General public 18 Unknown

Theoretical framework,

Focus groups and in-depth interviews

Purposively sampled from various community groups in Glasgow, United Kingdom 40 [63]
OxCAP-MH Oxford Capabilities Questionnaire for Mental Health Mental health Patients 16 5

Theoretical framework,

Focus group discussions

Psychiatrists, Psychologists, Social scientists, Health economists 336 [39]
(Low-income questionnaire) (Low-income questionnaire) Low-income settings General public 6 Unknown Focus groups Women in rural Malawi 129 [64]
(Chronic pain questionnaire) (Chronic pain questionnaire) Chronic pain Patients 8 Unknown Focus groups and in-depth interviews Respondents were recruited through a Pain Management Clinic in the East of England 16 [65]