Table 3.
Reference | Physical activity questionnairea | Analysis performed | Study characteristics | Sample size (gender); Mean age (SD); Target population | Results | COSMIN rank | Quality criteria assessment |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Rocha et al., 201730 | AAQ | Translation and cross-cultural adaptation Reliability |
Translation process Test re-test: 4 h |
22 (F: 22); 72.5 (5.3); Elderly women |
Reliability: ICC: 0.97 |
Cross-cultural validity: Doubtful Reliability: Inadequate |
Reliability: (+) |
Souza Barbosa et al., 201238 | BASIC | Reliability; Measurement error | Test re-test: 7 days apart | 38 (F: 20/M: 18); 64 (11.4); Individuals with intermittent claudication |
Reliability: ICC: 0.87 (95% CI: 0.74,0.93) Measurement error: LoA: −117 to 250 kcal |
Reliability: Adequate Measurement error: Very good |
Reliability: (+) Measurement error: (?) |
Lopes et al., 201376 | BASIC | Construct validity | Comparator: Pedometer | 150 (F: 56/M: 94); 64 (9); Individuals with intermittent claudication | Construct validity: r = 0.34 | Construct validity: Doubtful | Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 3− |
Florindo et al., 200440 | BPAQ | Translation and cross-cultural adaptation; Internal consistency | Translation process | 326 (M: 326); 62.5 (7.9); Men aged 50 or more |
Internal consistency: Cronbach alpha OPA – 0.52 SPA – 0.52 LPA + TPA – 0.62 |
Cross-cultural validity: Doubtful Internal consistency: Very good |
Internal consistency: (?) |
Sardinha et al., 201021 | BPAQ | Translation and cross-cultural adaptation | Translation process | 30 (M: 11/F: 19); 48.13 (15.99); Adults | n/a | Cross-cultural validity: Doubtful | n/a |
Garcia et al., 201366 | BPAQ | Construct validity | Comparator: accelerometer | 58 (F: 40/M: 18); 39.9 (11.5); Adults |
Construct validity: SPA + LPA + TPA: r = 0.36 Total score: r = 0.54 |
Construct validity: Inadequate | Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 2−/2 + |
Florindo et al., 200348 | BPAQ | Reliability; Construct validity |
Test re-test: 45 days Comparator: VO2max |
27 (M: 21); 32.6 (3.1); Adult men |
Reliability: Total score – ICC: 0.77 LPA + TPA score – ICC: 0.80 SPA – ICC: 0.69 Construct validity: Total score: r = 0.17 LPA + TPA score: r = 0.24 SPA: r = 0.04 |
Reliability: Adequate Construct validity: Inadequate |
Reliability: (+) Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 3?/3?/3? |
Florindo et al., 200649 | BPAQ | Reliability; Construct validity |
Test re-test: 15–30 days Comparator: VO2max |
29; 37.2 (range: 26.0–49.5); HIV population |
Reliability: Total score – ICC: 0.72 LPA + TPA score – ICC: 0.44 SPA – ICC: 0.70 OPA – ICC: 0.85 Construct validity: Total score: r = 0.27 LPA + TPA score: r = 0.19 SPA: r = 0.41 OPA: r = −0.14 |
Reliability: Adequate Construct validity: Inadequate |
Reliability: (+) Construct validity: (?), level of evidence= 3?/3?/3?/3? |
Glaner et al., 200770 | BPAQ | Construct validity | Comparator: VO2max | 105 (F: 28/M: 77); 24.8 (5.3); Adults |
Construct validity: % concordance = 64.1% |
Construct validity: Inadequate | Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 3+ |
Mazo et al., 200150 (Modified for elderly women) | BPAQ | Reliability; Construct validity |
Test re-test: 15 days apart Comparator: Pedometer |
30 (F: 30); 71.2 (4.6); Elderly women |
Reliability: SPA: ICC = 0.84 LPA: ICC = 0.85 Home activities: ICC = 0.82 Total PA: ICC = 0.83 Construct validity: Total score: 0.27 |
Reliability: Adequate Construct validity: Inadequate |
Reliability: (+) Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 3? |
Carvalho et al., 201762 | BPAQ | Reliability; Construct validity |
Test re-test: 7 days Comparator: Accelerometer |
73 (F: 23/M: 50); 37.2 (12.2); Adults with chronic low back pain |
Reliability: Total PA ICC2,1: 0.77 OPA ICC2,1: 0.84 SPA ICC2,1: 0.83 LPA ICC2,1: 0.61 Construct validity: Total PA (counts/min) r = 0.18 Total PA (VM counts/min) r = 0.26 Total PA (MVPAmin/day) r = 0.17 Total PA (Steps/day) r = 0.27 |
Reliability: Adequate Construct validity: Inadequate |
Reliability: (+) Construct validity: (?), level of evidence: 2−/3−/3−/3− |
Guedes et al., 2005B63 | BPAQ | Reliability; Construct validity |
Test re-test: 2 weeks apart Comparator: PA recordatory |
≤14 years girls 59; 12.92 (0.86); >14 years girls 33; 15.8 (0.93); ≤14 years boys 38; 13 (0.81); >14 years boys 31; 15.81 (0.70); Adolescents |
Reliability: ≤14 years/≥ 14 years ♀ OPA ICC: 0.55/ICC: 0.61 SPA ICC: 0.79/ICC: 0.85 TPA ICC: 0.61/ICC: 0.70 Total PA ICC: 0.66/ICC: 0.76 ≤14 years/≥14 years ♂ OPA ICC: 0.68/ICC: 0.69 SPA ICC: 0.73/ICC: 0.82 TPA ICC: 0.71/ICC: 0.76 Total PA ICC: 0.75/ICC: 0.80 Construct validity: ≤14 years/≥14 years ♀ Total PA r: 0.36/r: 0.46 ≤14 years/≥14 years ♂ Total PA r: 0.41/r: 0.59 |
Reliability: Adequate Construct validity: Doubtful |
Reliability: (+) for ≥14 years old girls and boys and ≤14 years old boys. (−) for ≤14 years old girls. Construct validity: (?), level of evidence= 3−/3?/3?/3? |
Romero et al., 201136 (Internet version) | BPAQ | Reliability; Measurement error |
Test re-test: 14 days apart |
135 (F: 74/M: 61); Youth |
Reliability: k = 0.47 Measurement error: % of agreement: 95.5% |
Reliability: Adequate Measurement error: Very good |
Reliability: (−) Measurement error: (?) |
Florindo et al., 2006b51 | BPAQ | Development reliability; Construct validity |
Test re-test: 15 days apart Comparator: 20-m shuttle run test Frequency meter VO2max Waist circumference |
94 (F: 64/M: 30); 13 (1.1); Youth |
Reliability: ICC > 0.60 Construct validity: Yearly/weekly VO2max: r = 0.18/r = 0.28 Total speed: r = 0.15/r = 0.24 Total time: r = 0.19/r = 0.30 Maximum heart rate: r = 0.05/r = 0.08 Waist circumference: r = −0.12/r = −0.06 |
Reliability: Adequate Construct validity: Doubtful |
Reliability: (−) Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 3− (all analysis) |
Morelhão et al., 201882 | BPAQ | Responsiveness | Follow up period: 2 months |
106 (F: 56/M: 50); 40 (11.6); Adults with chronic low back pain |
Responsiveness: Mean difference: 0.18 (2.25) Effect size (84% CI): 0.12 (−0.08 to 0.34) |
Responsiveness: Inadequate | Responsiveness: (−) |
Costa et al., 201053 | DAFA | Reliability | Test re-test: 15 days apart |
101 (F: 44/M: 57); 9.4 (1.0); Youth |
Dance – ICC: 0.50 Walk/run – ICC: 0.51 Play with the dog – ICC: 0.75 Household – ICC: 0.68 Cycle – ICC: 0.79 Rope jump – ICC: 0.51 Climb stairs – ICC: 0.62 Play soccer – ICC: 0.86 Swim – ICC: 0.79 Skateboard – ICC: 0.83 Gymnastics – ICC: 0.77 |
Reliability: Adequate | Reliability: (+) |
Barros et al., 200754 | DAFA | Reliability; Construct validity |
Test re-test: days apart Comparator: Questionnaire answered by parents/teachers |
69 (F: 35/M: 35); 7–10 years old |
Reliability: Dance ICC: 0.62 Walk/run ICC: 0.55 Play with the dog ICC: 0.77 Household ICC: 0.75 Cycle ICC: 0.63 Jump rope ICC: 0.65 Climb stairs ICC: 0.75 Play soccer ICC: 0.79 Swim ICC: 0.33 Skate ICC: 0.63 Gymnastics ICC: 0.75 General PA ICC: 0.85 Construct validity: k = 0.28 |
Reliability: Adequate Construct validity: Inadequate |
Reliability: (+/−) Unclear Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 3− |
Legnani et al., 201337 | DAFA (Internet version) | Reliability; Measurement error |
Test re-test: a day apart | 127 (F: 58/M: 69); 8.4 (1.1); Youth |
Reliability: General PA ICC: 0.94 Measurement error: Mean error: 1.7 (95% CI: −25.6,29.1) |
Reliability: Adequate Measurement error: Very good |
Reliability: (+) Measurement error: (?) |
Cabral et al., 201179 | DAFA (previous day version) | Construct validity | Comparator: Pedometer | 50 (F: 25/M: 25); 10.2 (1.49); Youth |
Construct validity: r = 0.45 |
Construct validity: Very good | Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 3− |
Jesus et al., 201664 | DAFA (Internet version of the previous day) | Reliability; Construct validity |
Test re-test: 3 h apart Comparator: Direct observation |
Reliability: 94 (F: 25/M: 25) Validity: 390 (F: 194/M: 196) 9.53 (1.53); Youth |
Reliability: Incidence ratio ranged from 0.63 to 7.52 Construct validity: Childs play incidence ratio ranged from 0.52 to 18.1 |
Reliability: Inadequate Construct validity: Inadequate |
Reliability: (?) Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 1? |
Sao Joao et al., 201325 | GSLTPAQ | Translation and cross-cultural adaptation Reliability; Content validity |
Translation process Test re-test: 15 days apart |
80 (F: 48/M: 32); 53.2 (10.4); Healthy individuals and individuals with cardiovascular disease |
Reliability: Strenuous PA ICC: 0.79 Moderate PA ICC: 0.80 Mild PA ICC: 0.82 Total PA ICC: 0.84 |
Cross-cultural validity: Doubtful Reliability: Adequate Content validity: Inadequate |
Reliability: (+) Content validity: (−) |
São João et al., 201580 | GSLTPAQ | Construct validity | Comparator: VO2peak, VO2pred, PA Questionnaires | 236 (F: 138/M: 98); 52.8 (11.1); Healthy individuals and with cardiovascular disease |
VO2peak: Total PA r = 0.09/MVPA r = 0.03 VO2pred: Total PA r = 0.15: MVPA r = 0.19 PA Questionnaire (VSAQ): Total PA r = 0.23/MVPA r = 0.34 PA Questionnaire (Baecke): Total PA r = 0.36/MVPA r = 0.25 PA in leisure: r = 0.62 |
Construct validity: Very good | Construct validity: (+), level of evidence = 3− (all analysis) |
Souza et al., 200624 | HAP | Translation and cross-cultural adaptation; Internal consistency |
Translation process | 230 (F: 198/M: 32); 66.32 (8.50); Elderly |
Internal consistency: Rash analysis: 0.91 | Cross-cultural validity: Doubtful Internal consistency: Inadequate |
Internal consistency: (?) |
Bastone et al., 201473 | HAP | Construct validity | Comparator: Accelerometer | 120 (F: 120); 71.8 (6.6); Elderly women |
Construct validity: Counts/day: r = 0.61 Moderate activity/day: r = 0.63 Steps/day: r = 0.69 Energy expenditure/day: r = 0.55 |
Construct validity: Inadequate | Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 2+/1+/1−/2+ |
Tajik et al., 201022 | HPLP-II | Translation and cross-cultural adaptation; Internal consistency | Translation process | 30 (F: 18/M: 12); 37.4; Adults |
Internal consistency: Cronbach alpha Total – 0.93 PA subscale – 0.85 |
Cross-cultural validity: Doubtful Internal consistency: Very good |
Internal consistency: (?) |
Barros et al., 200042 | IPAQ – long version | Reliability | Test re-test: 7 days apart |
42 (F: 20/M: 22); 34.7 (8.8); Adult |
OPA ICC: 0.88/k = 0.33 Household PA ICC: 0.67/k = 0.25 TPA ICC: 0.68/k = 0.41 LPA ICC: 0.71/k = 0.32 Total ICC: 0.86/k = 0.39 |
Reliability: Adequate | Reliability: (+) |
Benedetti et al., 200433 | IPAQ – long version | Reliability; Construct validity |
Test re-test: 15 days apart Comparator: Pedometer and PA diary |
41 (F: 41); 67 (4.8); Elderly women |
Reliability: OPA ICC: 0.97/r = 1.00 Household PA ICC: 0.89/r = 0.77 TPA ICC: 0.73/r = 0.67 LPA ICC: 0.86/r = 0.95 Sitting time ICC: 0.76/r = 0.60 Total ICC: 0.88/r = 0.77 Construct validity: r = 0.12–0.27 Pedometer r = 0.16–0.37 PA diary |
Reliability: Adequate Construct validity: Inadequate |
Reliability: (+) Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 3?/3? |
Benedetti et al., 200733 | IPAQ – long version | Reliability; Construct validity; Measurement error |
Test re-test: 21 days apart Comparator: Pedometer and PA diary |
29 (M: 29); 66.6 (4.3); Elderly men |
Reliability: rs = 0.95 Construct validity: r = 0.24/k = 0.03 Pedometer r = 0.38/k = 0.35 PA diary Measurement error: LoA: 7.29 kcal/min to −14.0 kcal/min |
Reliability: Doubtful Construct validity: Inadequate Measurement error: Very good |
Reliability: (?) Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 3?/3? Measurement error: (?) |
Lima et al., 201044 | IPAQ – long version | Reliability; Construct validity |
Test re-test: 7 days apart Comparator: Pedometer |
26 (F: 22/M: 4); 74.4 (6.5); Elderly with Alzheimer's disease |
Reliability: ICC: 0.56 Construct validity: r = 0.57 |
Reliability: Adequate Construct validity: Inadequate |
Reliability: (−) Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 3? |
Guedes et al., 2005A34 | IPAQ – long version | Reliability; Construct validity; Measurement error |
Test re-test: 4 days apart Comparator: 24 h recordatory |
≤14 years 97 (F: 59/M: 33); 12.9 (0.84) ≥14 years 64 (F: 33/M: 31); 15.8 (0.84); Youth |
Reliability: ≤14 years/≥14 years ♀ Walk rs = 0.52/rs = 0.55 Moderate PA rs = 0.49/rs = 0.63 Intense PA rs = 0.70/rs = 0.55 Sitting rs = 0.58/rs = 0.61 ≤14 years/≥14 years ♂ Walk rs = 0.56/rs = 0.61 Moderate PA rs = 0.59/rs = 0.66 Intense PA rs = 0.67/rs = 0.83 Sitting rs = 0.62/rs = 0.82 Construct validity: ≤14 years/≥14 years ♀ Walk rs = 0.17/rs = 0.11 Moderate PA rs = 0.24/rs = 0.35 Intense PA rs = 0.26/rs = 0.43 Sitting rs = 0.16/0.24 ≤14 years/≥14 years ♂ Walk rs = 0.09/rs = 0.12 Moderate PA rs = 0.29/rs = 0.34 Intense PA rs = 0.35/rs = 0.51 Sitting rs = 0.29/rs = 0.39 Measurement error: LoA: ♂ ≥ 14 years: 16 ± 92 min LoA: ♀ ≤ 14 years: 131 ± 429 min |
Reliability: Doubtful Construct validity: Doubtful Measurement error: Very good |
Reliability: (?) Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 3+ (for ≤14 years girls at Int. efforts and ≥14 years boys at Int. efforts and sitting) 3− (for all other analyses) Measurement error: (?) |
Garcia et al., 201366 | IPAQ – long version | Construct validity | Comparator: Accelerometer | 58 (F: 40/M: 18); 39.9 (11.5); Adults |
Construct validity: Moderate vigorous intensity: r = 0.34 |
Construct validity: Inadequate | Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 1− |
Hallal et al., 201035 | IPAQ – long version | Reliability; Construct validity; Measurement error |
Test re-test: 5 days Comparator: Accelerometer |
156 (F: 81/M: 75); 40.3 (15.1); Adults |
Reliability: TPA rs = 0.87 LPA rs = 0.92 TPA + LPA rs = 0.90 Construct validity: Moderate intensity: r = 0.23 Vigorous intensity: r = 0.30 Total score: r = 0.22 Measurement error: Mean difference: 3 min % of agreement: 89.8% |
Reliability: Doubtful Construct validity: Inadequate Measurement error: Very good |
Reliability: (?) Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 1−/1−/2− Measurement error: (?) |
Carvalho et al., 201762 | IPAQ –long version | Reliability; Construct validity |
Test re-test: 7 days Comparator: Accelerometer |
73 (F: 23/M: 50); 37.2 (12.2); Adults with low back pain |
Reliability: Total PA ICC2,1: 0.37 OPA ICC2,1: 0.32 TPA ICC2,1: 0.20 Household PA ICC2,1: 0.40 LPA ICC2,1: 0.38 Walking ICC2,1: 0.72 MVPA ICC2,1: 0.25 Construct validity: Total PA (counts/min) r = 0.33 Total PA (VM counts/min) r = 0.33 Total PA (MVPAmin/day) r = 0.22 Total PA (steps/day) r = 0.37 MVPA (counts/min) r = 0.18 MVPA (VM counts/min) r = 0.21 MVPA (MVPAmin/day) r = 0.22 MVPA (steps/day) r = 0.25 |
Reliability: Adequate Construct validity: Inadequate |
Reliability: (−) Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 2−/3−/3−/3−/2−/1−/1−/3− |
Pardini et al., 200146 | IPAQ –long version | Reliability; Construct validity |
Test re-test: one day apart Comparator: PA recordatory and accelerometer |
43 (F: 21/M: 22); 24 (4.5); Young adults |
Reliability: Total PA rs: 0.71 Construct validity: PA Recordatory r = 0.49 Accelerometer r = 0.24 |
Reliability: Doubtful Construct validity: Inadequate |
Reliability: (?) Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 3?/2? |
Lopes et al., 201577 | IPAQ – long version | Construct validity | Comparator: Questionnaire for physical activity and sedentary lifestyle | 240 (F: 157/M: 83); 54.6 (range: 18–69 years); Adults with high blood pressure |
Construct validity: Accuracy – ROC curve: 0.70 (95% CI: 0.64–0.75) |
Construct validity: Doubtful | Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 3+ |
Alves et al., 201067 | IPAQ – Short Version | Construct validity | Comparator: Celafisc criteria | 173 (F: 98/M: 75); 40 (13); Adults |
Construct validity: k = 0.85 |
Construct validity: Inadequate | Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 3+ |
Matsudo et al., 200147 | IPAQ – Short Version | Reliability; Construct validity |
Test re-test: 3–10 days apart Comparator: Accelerometer |
Reliability: 257 (F: 149/M: 108); 36.8 (13.8) Validity: 28 (F: 16/M: 12) 42.9 (14.2); Adults |
Reliability: Total PA ICC: 0.77 Total PA: rs = 0.74 Construct validity: Total PA r = 0.75 |
Reliability: Adequate Construct validity: Inadequate |
Reliability: (+) Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 2? |
Colpani et al., 201469 | IPAQ – Short Version | Construct validity | Comparator: Pedometer | 292 (F: 292); 57.1 (5.3); Climateric women | Construct validity: r = 0.13 | Construct validity: Inadequate | Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 3− |
Glaner et al., 200770 | IPAQ – Short Version | Construct validity | Comparator: VO2max | 105 (F: 28/M: 77); 24.8 (5.3); Young adults |
Construct validity: % concordance = 47% |
Construct validity: Inadequate | Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 3− |
Pinto et al., 201671 | IPAQ – Short Version | Construct validity | Comparator: Accelerometer | 19; 14.6 (3.9); Juvenile dermatomyositis 20; 14.5 (2.4); Juvenile systemic lupus erythematosus |
Construct validity: Total PA r = 0.51 JSLE Total PA r = 0.29 JDM Light-intensity PA and MVPA ranged from r = 0.05 to r = 0.32 |
Construct validity: Inadequate |
Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 2?/2?/2/1 |
Moraes et al., 201368 | IPAQ – Short Version | Construct validity | Comparator: American College of Sport Medicine criteria | 2197 Adults | Construct validity: Male: k = 0.95 Female: k = 0.93 | Construct validity: Inadequate | Construct validity: (?), level of evidence= 3+/3+ |
Lustosa et al., 201129 | MLTAQ | Translation and cross-cultural adaptation | Translation process | 39 (F: 32/M: 7); 71.2 (6.8); Elderly |
n/a | Cross-cultural validity: Doubtful | n/a |
Bielemann et al., 201174 | NPAQ | Construct validity | Comparator: Accelerometer | 239 (F: 123/M: 116); Youth |
Daily counts r = 0.24 Mean counts per min r = 0.21 Sedentary activity r = −0.08 Moderate activity r = 0.27 Vigorous activity r = 0.21 Moderate to vigorous activity r = 0.27 |
Construct validity: Inadequate | Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 1−/1−/3−/1−/1−/1− |
Cruciani et al., 201119 | PACI | Translation and cross-cultural adaptation; Content validity |
Translation process | 24; 8.5 (1.5); Youth | n/a | Cross-cultural validity: Doubtful Content validity: Inadequate |
Content validity: (−) |
Adami et al., 201131 | PACI | Reliability; Measurement error |
Test re-test: 3 h apart | 83 (F: 42/M: 41); 9.3 (1.0); Youth |
Reliability: PA time ICC: 0.89/r = 0.83 Total MET ICC: 0.91/r = 0.87 Total weighted MET ICC: 0.89/r = 0.86 Sedentary time ICC: 0.97/r = 0.97 Measurement error: PA time MD: 4.48 (LoA = 50 min) Total MET MD: 17.8 (LoA = 294.6 min) Total weighed MET MD: 25.8 (LoA = 298.4 min) Sedentary time MD: 1.35 (LoA = 47.4 min) |
Reliability: Inadequate Measurement error: Inadequate |
Reliability: (+) Measurement error: (?) |
Adami et al., 201365 | PACI | Construct validity | Comparator: Accelerometer | 83 (F: 42/M: 41); 9.3 (1.0); Youth |
Construct validity: PA time – r = 0.34 (counts/min) MET – r = 0.38 (counts/min) Weighted MET – r = 0.34 (counts/min) |
Construct validity: Inadequate | Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 2−/2−/2− |
Guedes et al., 201528 | PAQ-A | Translation and cross-cultural adaptation; Reliability; Construct validity |
Translation process Test re-test: 14 days apart Comparator: Accelerometer |
296 (F: 161/M: 135); F: 15.96 (1.25) M: 15.41 (1.09); Adolescents |
Reliability: Total PA ICC: 0.77 Construct validity: Total PA: r = 0.56 MVPA: r = 0.54 |
Cross-cultural validity: Doubtful Reliability: Adequate Construct validity: Very good |
Reliability: (+) Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 2+/1+ |
Guedes et al., 201528 | PAQ-C | Translation and cross-cultural adaptation; Reliability; Construct validity |
Translation process Test re-test: 14 days apart Comparator: Accelerometer |
232 (F: 124/M: 108); F: 11.12 (1.38) M: 11.48 (1.15); Childrens |
Reliability: Total PA ICC: 0.74 Construct validity: Total PA: r = 0.40 MVPA: r = 0.48 |
Cross-cultural validity: Doubtful Reliability: Adequate Construct validity: Very good |
Reliability: (+) Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 2−/1− |
Takito et al., 200860 | PAQPW | Reliability; Construct validity |
Test re-test: 7 days apart Comparator: Heart rate monitor |
68 (F: 68); 26.9 (6.1); Pregnant women |
Reliability: Sport k = 0.41 Vigorous PA k = 0.32 Moderate PA k = 0.29 Sedentary activity ICC: 0.81 Light PA ICC: 0.85 Moderate ICC: 0.75 Walking ICC: 0.80 Construct validity: LoA: 7–11 h |
Reliability: Adequate Construct validity: Inadequate |
Reliability: (+) for ICC (−) for Kappa Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 3? |
Neto et al., 200826 | PAR | Translation and cross-cultural adaptation; Reliability |
Translation process Test re-test: 14 days apart |
12 (F: 11/M: 1); 75 (4); Elderly population |
Reliability: ICC: 0.92 | Cross-cultural validity: Doubtful Reliability: Adequate |
Reliability: (+) |
Neto et al., 201175 | PAR | Construct validity | Comparator: VO2max | 98 (F: 43/M: 55); 67 (7); Elderly population |
Construct validity: r = 0.61 | Construct validity: Inadequate | Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 3+ |
Damasceno et al., 201727 | PAR-3D | Translation and cross-cultural adaptation | Translation process | n/a | n/a | Cross-cultural validity: Doubtful | n/a |
Farias Júnior et al., 200258 | PAR-3D | Reliability | Test re-test: 24 h apart |
45 (F: 20/M: 25); 16 (1.28); Adolescents |
Reliability: Habitual PA: ICC: 0.84 Light PA: ICC: 0.51 Moderate PA: ICC: 0.80 Vigorous PA: ICC: 0.78 |
Reliability: Adequate | Reliability: (+) |
Ribeiro et al., 201181 | PAR-24 | Development; Construct validity | Comparator: Accelerometer | 98 (F: 65/M: 33); 39.4 (11); Adults |
Construct validity: Counts – r = 0.38 kcal – r = 0.31 |
Construct validity: Very good | Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 2−/2− |
Militão et al., 201341 (Developed) | PASBEQ | Reliability; Construct validity; Internal consistency |
Test re-test: 72 h apart Comparator: Shuttle run test (VO2max) |
Reliability: 47 Validity: 46 (F: 23/M: 23); 10–13 years old |
Reliability: SPA ICC: 0.63–0.85 LPA (week days) ICC: 0.42–0.74 LPA (weekend) ICC: 0.44–0.75 Total LPA ICC: 1.00 TPA ICC: 0.60–0.86 PA in school ICC: 0.63–0.85 Total PA ICC: 0.61–0.84 Construct validity: SPA r = 0.04 LPA (week days) r = 0.27 LPA (weekend) r = 0.28 Total LPA r = 0.35 TPA r = 0.07 PA in school r = 0.19 Total PA r = 0.37 Internal consistency: Cronbach Alfa SPA – 0.86 LPA (week days) – 0.75 LPA (weekend) – 0.77 Total LPA – 1.0 TPA – 0.87 PA in school – 0.86 Total PA – 0.86 |
Reliability: Adequate Construct validity: Inadequate Internal consistency: Very good |
Reliability: bv Unclear Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 3? (all analysis) Internal consistency: (?) |
Oliveira et al., 201156 (Developed) | PASBQ | Reliability | Test re-test: 7 days apart |
65 (F: 27/M: 38); 4.2 (1.2); Youth |
Reliability: Outdoor playtime rs = 0.92 Sedentary behavior rs = 0.75 |
Reliability: Doubtful | Reliability: (?) |
Tavares et al., 201472 | PeNSE | Construct validity | Comparator: 24 h Recordatory | 174 (F: 94/M: 80); 14.7; Adolescents |
Construct validity: Accuracy: ≥300 min – 73.1% ≥150 min – 78.4% Inactive – 92.4% |
Construct validity: Inadequate | Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 3+/3+/3+ |
Silva et al., 201523 | PPAQ | Translation and cross-cultural adaptation |
Translation process | 305 (F: 305) Pregnant women |
n/a | Cross-cultural validity: Doubtful | n/a |
Farias Junior et al., 201232 | SAPAC | Reliability; Construct validity; Measurement error |
Test re-test: 7 days apart Comparator: 24 h PA recalls |
Test re-test: 239 (F: 133/M: 106); 16 (1.2) Validity: 70 (F: 39/M: 31); 15.7 (1.2); Youth |
Reliability: ICC: 0.88/k = 0.52 Construct validity: All: rho = 0.62/k = 0.59 Male: rho = 0.52/0.41 Female: rho = 0.51/k = 0.69 14–15 years: rho = 0.52/k = 0.58 16–19 years: rho = 0.60/0.61 Measurement error: % of agreement: 75.7% LoA: 871.1 to −639.4 |
Reliability: Adequate Construct validity: Very good Measurement error: Very good |
Reliability: (+) Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 3−/3−/3−/3−/3− Measurement error: (?) |
Prazeres Filho et al., 201761 | SAPAC | Reliability; Construct validity |
Test re-test: 2 days apart Comparator: Accelerometer |
Test re-test: 171 (F: 102/M: 69); 12.3 (1.1) Validity: 341 (F: 172/M: 169); 11.9 (1.0); Youth |
Reliability: ICC: 0.73/k = 0.58 Construct validity: All: rho = 0.37 Male: rho = 0.38 Female: rho = 0.37 10–11 years: rho = 0.36 12–14 years: rho = 0.39 |
Reliability: Adequate Construct validity: Inadequate |
Reliability: (+) Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 2− |
Checon et al., 201152 (Developed) | Saúdes | Reliability | Test re-test: 15 days apart |
91 (F: 49/M: 42); Youth |
Reliability: k or rs: from −0.01 to 1.00 |
Reliability: Doubtful | Reliability: (?) |
Nahas et al., 200757 (Developed) | SBQ | Reliability; Construct validity |
Test re-test: 7 days apart Comparator: Pedometer |
122 (F: 78/M: 44); 15.8 (1.6); Adolescents |
Reliability: ICC from 0.76 to 0.93 Construct validity: r = 0.23 |
Reliability: Adequate Construct validity: Very good |
Reliability: (+) Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 3− |
Hallal et al. 201378 | SVPAQ | Construct validity | Comparator: Doubly labeled water | 25 (F: 16/M: 9); 13 (0.3); Adolescents |
Construct validity: Total energy expenditure: r = 0.41 Physical activity energy expenditure: r = 0.30 |
Construct validity: Doubtful | Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 1? |
Monteiro et al., 200859 (Developed) | VIGITEL | Reliability; Construct validity |
Test re-test: 7–15 days apart Comparator: 24 h Recordatory |
Reliability: 110 (F: 63/M: 47); 45 Construct validity: 111 (F: 61/M: 50); 44; Adults |
Reliability: Sufficient active in LPA: k = 0.80 Inactive in four domains of PA: k = 0.78 Television for long periods: k = 0.53 Construct validity: Specificity greater than 80% Sensibility: long period on TV: 69.7% Sedentary activity: 59.1% Sufficiently active in leisure: 50% |
Reliability: Adequate Construct validity: Inadequate |
Reliability: (+) Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 3−/3−/3− |
Moreira et al., 201739 | VIGITEL | Reliability; Construct-validity; Measurement error |
Test re-test: 7–15 days apart Comparator: 24 h Recordatory |
305 (F: 177/M: 128); 49.7 (18.2); Adults |
Reliability: Active in LPA k = 0.70 Active in TPA k = 0.35 Inactive – k = 0.64 Watch Television – k = 0.56 Construct validity: PA Leisure Sensibility = 67.7% Specificity = 82.8% PA Locomotion Sensibility = 11.9% Specificity = 91.2% Sedentary Level Sensibility = 54.8% Specificity = 87.8% Measurement error: % of Agreement: 65% |
Reliability: Adequate Construct validity: Inadequate Measurement error: Very good |
Reliability: (−) Construct validity: (?), level of evidence = 3−/3−/3− Measurement error: (?) |
Table presents the description of the instruments evaluated in alphabetical order, also the psychometric properties assessed in each study, relevant characteristics of each property, such as the time between each test–retest (reproducibility) analysis, comparator instrument (construct validity), sample characteristics, relevant results to the statistical analyzes carried out, classification regarding the methodological quality, classification of the results of the analyzes and level of evidence of the comparator instrument (construct validity). The type of ICC used was specified in subscript when informed by the article.
ICC, intraclass correlation coefficient; LoA, limits of agreement; LPA, leisure physical activity; MD, mean difference; MET, metabolic equivalent of task; MVPA, moderate and vigorous physical activity; n/a, not applicable; OPA, occupational physical activity; PA, physical activity; ROC, receiver operating characteristic; SD, standard deviation; SPA, sports physical activity; SPPB, short physical performance battery; TPA, transportation physical activity; VO2, oxygen volume; WHODAS, Word Health Organization Disability Assessment Schedule.
(+) = sufficient rating, (?) = indeterminate rating, (−) = insufficient rating.
For the abbreviation listed in the physical activity questionnaire refer to Table 2.