Setting |
Specify:
Urban vs. rural setting*
Season
Smoking rates*
Breastfeeding rates*
|
|
Participants |
|
Population-based vs. healthcare attendance very different
OM varies by multiple factors and readers not familiar with your setting will not know the prevalence of risk factors (e.g., breastfeeding, smoking)
|
Variables |
|
|
Measurement |
|
No consistency with techniques and sensitivity varies by technique
No consistency with cut-off (e.g., Type B or Type B + C tympanograms)
Examiners varied experience/expertise
|
Descriptive data |
|
|
Outcome data for OM |
Specify results for each diagnostic technique (e.g., frequency of each tympanogram type)
Report prevalence by both child and ear separately
Specify diagnostic hierarchy used.
Suggested hierarchy:
- Cholesteatoma
- CSOM
- AOM with perforation
- TTO
- Dry perforation
- recurrent AOM
- other AOM
- chronic OME
- other OME
- Wax
- Other
- Normal
|
Reporting the frequency of each type of Tympanogram enables comparison with studies using different definitions
No consensus on reporting and important to differentiate child level vs. ear level hearing impairment
Most clinical decisions are determined at the child level not ear level
When reporting by child, the reader needs to know how children with different conditions in each ear were categorised
|
Outcome data for hearing |
Report prevalence by both child and ear separately
Use WHO definitions
Report loss by each frequency tested
Report loss in some other way (e.g., 3FAHL) please also report as above
|
|
Generalisability |
|
|