Skip to main content
. 2020 May 29;15(5):e0232774. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0232774

Table 1. Summary data for included systematic reviews.

Alcohol reviews (n = 4 incl. 1 empty review) Smoking reviews (n = 16) Diet and / or Physical Activity Reviews (n = 16) Total across all reviews (n = 36)
Time period of included intervention studies in the reviews
Range in years: 1982 to 2011 1976 to 2017 1952 to 2018 1952 to 2018
Earliest year before 1990 (n) 1 2 2 5
Earliest year from 1990 (n) 1 8 1 10
Earliest year from 2000 (n) 1 2 11 14
Earliest year from 2010 (n) 0 4 2 6
Search strategies:
Databases only (n) 2 12 1 15
Databases + Supplementary searches (n) 2 4 15 21
Included study designs:
RCT only (n) 1 6 11 18
RCT + other design (n) 2 7 5 14
Not reported (n) 0 3 0 3
Number included studies in the systematic reviews
Range (n) 0 to 10 3 to 88 3 to 65 3 to 88
Median (n, IQR) 6 (4 to 8) 14 (8 to 25) 14 (8 to 22)
Not reported (n) n/a n/a n/a n/a
Pooled sample sizes included in the systematic reviews
Range (n women) 0 to 3,494 1,009 to 31,958 209 to 15,328 0 to 31,958
Median (n women, IQR) 2,047 (536 to 3,408) 4,721 (1,009 to 15,338) 3,723 (1,457 to 5,693)
Not reported (n) n/a 1 review 1 review 2 reviews
Countries of intervention studies included in the systematic reviews (reported for n systematic reviews) Reported for 3 out of 4 SRs (4th empty review) Not reported for 5 SRs Not reported for 4 SRs Not reported for 10 SRs (incl. 1 empty SR)
HICs represented in the included interventions 1. Norway 1. Argentina 1. Australia 1. Argentina
2. Sweden 2. Australia 2. Belgium 2. Australia
3. UK 3. Canada 3. Canada 3. Belgium
4. USA 4. Denmark 4. Croatia 4. Canada
5. France 5. Denmark 5. Croatia
6. Greece 6. Finland 6. Denmark
7. Netherlands 7. Germany 7. Finland
8. New Zealand 8. Ireland 8. France
9. Norway 9. Italy 9. Germany
10. Poland 10. Netherlands 10. Greece
11. Spain 11. Norway 11. Ireland
12. Sweden 12. New Zealand 12. Italy
13. UK 13. Spain 13. Netherlands
14. USA 14. Sweden 14. New Zealand
15. Taiwan 15. Norway
16. UK 16. Poland
17. USA 17. Spain
18. Sweden
19. Taiwan
20. UK
21. USA
UMICs represented in the included interventions 1. Mexico 1. Brazil 1. Brazil 1. Brazil
2. Cuba 2. China 2. China
3. Mexico 3. Columbia 3. Columbia
4. Iran 4. Cuba
5. South Africa 5. Iran
6. Thailand 6. Mexico
7. Turkey 7. South Africa
8. Thailand
9. Turkey
LMICs represented in the included interventions None None 1. Egypt 1. Egypt
LICs represented in the included interventions None None None None

Income status of the countries defined according to the World Bank data for the current 2020 fiscal year “low-income economies are defined as those with a GNI per capita, calculated using the World Bank Atlas method, of $1,025 or less in 2018; lower middle-income economies are those with a GNI per capita between $1,026 and $3,995; upper middle-income economies are those with a GNI per capita between $3,996 and $12,375; high-income economies are those with a GNI per capita of $12,376 or more” [43]

Abbreviations: HICs = High Income Countries; UMICs = Upper Middle-Income Countries; LMICs - = Lower Middle-Income Countries; LICs = Lower Income Countries.