Table 1. Examples of studies assessing criterion validity.
Indicator domain | Examples of studies (reference standard and setting) |
---|---|
Care coverage | Women’s self-report compared to: • Observations during antenatal, intrapartum and postnatal care from ○ Hospitals in Kenya [40, 43], ○ Health facilities in Mozambique [44]. Women’s self-report compared to: • Medical records from medical booklets and HMIS: China through population-based survey [45]. |
Coverage of maternal and newborn care interventions, skilled provider at birth, caesarean section rate | |
Care content and quality | Women’s self-report compared to: • Observations of care in hospitals in Tanzania, Bangladesh, Nepal [46] • Medical records/facility registers in hospitals in Tanzania, Bangladesh, Nepal [46]. |
Immediate initiation of breastfeeding, newborn resuscitation | |
Impact | Women’s self-report compared to: • Biomarkers and/or medical diagnoses as captured in clinical notes in samples drawn from: ○ Indonesian hospitals [47], ○ Ghana hospital [48], ○ A tertiary hospital in Brazil [49], ○ Maternity hospitals in Bolivia [50]. Women’s self-report compared to: • Clinical examination findings from a community survey in Egypt [51]. |
Prevalence of maternal morbidities or obstetric complications (e.g. haemorrhage, pre-eclampsia/eclampsia, labour dystocia, prolapse), prevalence of severe maternal morbidity or near miss |