Table 1. Key challenges in splitting ventilation.
A comparison of the capabilities of existing splitting mechanisms and iSAVE. *See fig. S9 for details regarding the rerouting of standard sensing metrics required for ventilator calibration and self-tests. PEEP, positive end-expiratory pressure; FiO2, fraction of inspired oxygen; ΔC, change in compliance; ΔR, change in resistance; Pplat, plateau pressure.
Concern |
Uniform splitting (pressure control mode) |
iSAVE (volume control mode) |
|||
Individualized management of ventilation | |||||
- PEEP | x | Shared between patients | o | Individualized to each patient | |
- Tidal volume | x | Shared between patients | o | Individualized to each patient | |
- FiO2, respiratory rate | x | Shared between patients | x | Shared between patients | |
- Alarms | x | Changes to one patient’s status may not result in main ventilator alarm | o | Changes to one patient’s status will cause main ventilator to alarm. Mechanical components to provide auditory alarms can be incorporated | |
Sudden changes to patient status can cause damaging rebalancing of airflow to other patient(s) toward most compliant lungs | x | Ventilation cannot be quickly adjusted | o | Can be managed by titrating flow control valves. One-way valves prevent backflow. Pressure release valves prevent excess pressure delivery | |
Improvement or deterioration of one patient (ΔC, ΔR) will automatically rebalance airflow, potentially harming other patient(s) | x | Ventilation cannot be individually rebalanced. Patients would need to be re-matched as they improve/deteriorate | o | Desired ventilation for each patient can be achieved through valve adjustment, allowing patients to improve/deteriorate while remaining on the same system. | |
Abruptly removing patients requires breaking the circuit, causing aerosolization of the virus, exposing healthcare personnel | x | Individual patient circuits cannot be quickly removed from circuit | o | Individual patients can be quickly shunted/removed from the circuit. Inline filters limit aerosolization risk | |
Monitoring | x | Additional respiratory monitors and heightened clinical vigilance required | x | Additional respiratory monitors and heightened clinical vigilance required | |
Measurement of pulmonary mechanics | x | Shared between patients | o | Pplat can be measured using expiratory hold button. C, R can be computed for each patient | |
Ventilator calibration/self-test | x | Added circuit volume defeats the operational self‐test | o | Can be executed with modifications to circuit* | |
Triggering | x | Disabled. Patients will require sedation | x | Disabled. Patients will require sedation |