Table 1.
Number of patients (N=) | Treatment | Results | |||||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Authorship | Intervention | Control | su, ms chx 0.2%, tb | ms chx 0.2% | su, ms 2% chx, tb | su, ms chx 0.12% | su, ms 0.12% chx, tb | pi 10% | pb gel 3.3% + sw | su, ms 0.2% chx | su, ms sa | su, ms + mw 0.12% chx | su, tb,sbc mw | su,mw chx 0.2%, tb | su, mw sw, tb | Incidence statistic | |
[6] | 104 | 102 | √ | X | study group = 8.6/1000 ventilated days control group = 11.6/1000 | P value = 0.82 | |||||||||||
[11] | 57 | 57 | X | √ | study- 5.3% control − 22.8% | P value = 0.007 | |||||||||||
[12] | 105 | 108 | X | √ | control 25.9% study 16.19% | P value = 0.084 | |||||||||||
[10] | 78 | 72 | √ | X | control 28% study 31% | P value = 0.69 | |||||||||||
[8] | 217 | 219 | X | √ | study 9.7% control 11% | P value = 0.75 | |||||||||||
[13] | 29 | 32 | √ | X | study 41.4% control − 68.8% | P value = 0.03 | |||||||||||
[7] | 74 | 73 | √ | X | study 24.7% control 20.3% | P value = 0.55 | |||||||||||
[9] | a = 33, c = 33 | 43 | √ | √ | X | study B 5.2% study C 5.6% control 1.2% NM |
√, intervention; X, control; su, suction; ms, mouth swab; chx, chlorexidine; tb, toothbrush; pi, povidone-iodoine; pb, placebo; sa, saline; pw tb, powered toothbrush; mw, mouthwash; sbc, sodium bicarbonate; sw, sterile water